The verdict is in for On The Bay Seafood
As I promised last week, I checked out On The Bay Seafood over the weekend. Located on 42nd street, this cool little restaurant is on its way to being my favorite spot in town.
The first thing you notice at On The Bay is that it's not "on the bay", but rather on the ocean side of the highway. There's no indoor seating, as all of the tables and benches are outside. Wear some flip-flops, as the each table is set on a sandy beach under an umbrella.
Inside, On The Bay has one of the strangest, yet coolest gadgets around – a crab shedding tank. Many people believe that blue crabs will only shed their shells at a certain phase of the moon cycle, making it hard to keep fresh soft crabs in stock throughout the summer months. The shedding tank means that they almost always have soft crabs available.
For my first visit, I ordered the crab cake sandwich platter. It came with two sides, but I was in a hurry so I just got two orders of French fries. You can also order potato salad, corn, cole slaw and more.
I am always skeptical about crab cakes. I've been spoiled by the ones my mother and grandmother make, and I rarely find a restaurant that does it right. On The Bay's crab cake was cooked perfectly and was almost all crabmeat, with little filler. Each bite had lump backfin meat in it, which means they use quality crab for their sandwiches. Of course there were no shells in the meat, which is another testament to the integrity of the crab cake.
The fries were pretty standard boardwalk fries. They were decent and went well with the sandwich.
The rest of the menu is excellent as well. The soft crabs were juicy and fresh, just as I expected. I'm told the "Fried Rrr'ysters" are a good choice for the oyster-loving diner.
On The Bay is moderately expensive, as most of the platters on the menu cost $14. Sandwiches are $9 or $10 each as well. Everything is available as carry out, but if you choose to order in, you can sit on the benches in the sand.
One of the most important parts of the menu is the steamed crab selection. On The Bay has a range of sizes from small females to jumbo males. A dozen jumbos will cost you $80, which is par for the course in Ocean City. I prefer to get a few dozen smaller ones to save money (small crabs are $25 per dozen). It does involve more work, but I think it's worth it.
They also sell crabs by the bushel, which is always the best deal. The popular bushel of No. 1 males will set you back $155, but a mixture of small and medium crabs is only $95.
If you're looking for a fancy seafood place, this isn't it. If you want to feel like you're sitting on a beach near the ocean (or bay) with your toes in the sand and a pile of crabs in front of you, check out On The Bay Seafood. The owners started with a place called Steamed Blues in Phoenix, Ariz. If you can sell blue crabs to people in Arizona, you must be doing something right.


Comments
I don't think it is right to be able to access this blog when I am chained to a desk at work...
Posted by: JTK | June 2, 2008 3:55 PM
Hi Peter! You should check out Pepper's Tavern at 16th St. & the boards. Pepper's has to be the best OC has to offer for fun and food! Denny-O would love to see some new faces; Pedro's food is contagious and Jeannie's Mega-Ritas can't be beat!! It's the best 5 star dive in the world!
If anyone is looking for great crabs, my favorite is The Best Crabs located at 14203 Coastal Hwy in The Misty Harbor shopping center on the bayside. Ph: (410) 250-4356 They only have carry out, but well worth the trip north!!
Posted by: Mel Harrison | June 3, 2008 8:14 AM
I live in Tempe, AZ and had not been to "Steamed Blues" restaurant in a long time. I started to look for them tonight on the web and it looks like they may not exist. The crabs were so good, I saved the business card of Robert Wyne.
It looks like you found the owners in Ocean City. Wish them the best!! Their food was great, I wish I had gone there more.
PS I grew up in Southern Maryland.
Posted by: Don Zyriek | June 17, 2008 1:09 AM
Don Zyriek - My hubby and I used to go to Steamed Blues all the time here in Phoenix. One night, years ago, we went there and it had been in a fire. The damage was severe, a few days later the whole building was razed. You couldn't find it because it's not there anymore. Too bad, it was a great restaurant. The atmostphere was fantastic and the food was great. I loved sitting on the patio and listenting to the live music. I miss it still...sigh.
Posted by: JEL | August 7, 2008 4:45 PM