baltimoresun.com

« WWE TLC thoughts | Main | WWE Raw: John Cena-Vickie Guerrero exchange highlights entertaining show »

December 20, 2010

Reader review of ROH’s Final Battle

Reader Rob Brown sent in a very detailed review of Ring Of Honor’s Final Battle Internet pay-per-view, which took place Saturday night.

Take it away, Rob:

On a night where so many fans were primarily focused on the fate of the Ring Of Honor world championship, the natural assumption seemed to be that the match between champion Roderick Strong and challenger Davey Richards would be last on the card. Instead, however, the unsanctioned "Fight Without Honor" between two former tag team partners who had become bitter enemies over the last year – Kevin Steen and El Generico – was the final match of the night.

The official reason for this was that they had to get all of the sanctioned matches out of the way before allowing Generico and Steen to end their feud in a fight that ROH assumed no responsibility for. But after the match began, it was clear that it deserved to be shown when it was. Both men put on a great show, both in terms of wrestling and acting. It was arguably an even better match than the world championship bout that preceded it, and that's saying a lot.

Over the last year, Steen has done an amazing job playing the role of a hate-filled psychopath who has been obsessed with hurting the man who was once his greatest friend, the man whom a deranged Steen had come to believe was the cause of everything wrong in his life. El Generico, for his part, has done extremely well given the limitations of his gimmick, which doesn't allow him to speak more than a sentence or two of English without breaking kayfabe.

Nevertheless, Generico was always convincing in his role. Originally too hurt by his best friend turning on him to even put up a fight when Steen attacked him, Generico eventually reached the point where he could take no more and gave as good as he got. With Colt Cabana and Steve Corino in Generico and Steen's corners, respectively, the story was so emotionally charged that when the two men stood across from each other in the ring at Final Battle, fans in attendance chanted "Feud of the Year!"

The match was brutal, with Steen being busted open early. Later on, as Steen was stalking and toying with a dazed Generico, he tore a large hole in Generico's mask near the eye, and Generico was soon bleeding from that exposed part of his face. I've seen plenty of matches where wrestlers have bladed or been busted open hardway, but there was something disturbing about the sight of Generico's bloody scalp and face showing through his torn mask. It seemed to create the illusion that an entire layer of skin had been ripped from his head.

At one point, Steen pulled the covers off of the ringside barricades one after the other and blasted Generico with each one in succession, burying him beneath a pile of them before hitting a frog splash on top of it. At another, Generico punched Steen several times with a chain wrapped around his hand, before tying the chain around Steen's head while he was propped up in the corner and hitting a Yakuza kick to Steen's face. Ladders, tables, and chairs were all brought into play at different times.

When Steen was on the offensive, he continued to be convincing as a lunatic; he seemed to be experiencing euphoria as he saw Generico suffer, and he was “creative” with the blood. By which I mean that after Generico started bleeding, Steen put a hand to Generico's face, got a handful of Generico's blood, and then licked it off. He then ran the blood through his hair and slathered it on his arms, a sadistic smile on his face, as fans chanted "You sick ****!" Steen also actually kissed Generico before picking him up and slamming him onto a ladder in the middle of the ring.

Steen initially didn't seem to care whether he got hurt so long as he could inflict punishment on El Generico. On one occasion, Steen was down on his knees and still spit at Generico, who unloaded on him. After taking all the shots, Steen flipped him off with both fingers and spit on him again. Three referees were needed before it was over, with the original one getting taken out by a normal ref bump and with Steen losing it and taking out his replacement with a package piledriver after only getting a two count on Generico.

Both men kicked out after taking a ridiculous amount of punishment, from finishers (including Steen kicking out after Generico hit him with a brainbuster onto the top turnbuckle) to shots from foreign objects to getting put through tables. In the end, though, Steen finally seemed to lose his heart for the match as Generico was poised to deliver a chair shot. He flinched, shielded his face and held out something for Generico to take.

It was Generico's old mask, the one that Steen had stolen from him at Glory By Honor IX in September. Steen apparently meant it as a peace offering, and he was pleading with Generico. Generico took the mask from Steen's hand, looked down at it with an expression that suggested memories flooding back of his past with Steen, both good and bad – and then he turned on Steen and laid him out with the chair for the three count. (While it was sold as a chair shot to the head, you could see that the chair really made contact with Steen's shoulder, which is good.)

Thoughts on the other matches:

Davey Richards vs. Roderick Strong: Practically everybody wanted Davey to win this. Roderick Strong is a great performer in the ring, but on the mic he's really not very good. Davey Richards is skilled in both areas, and in my opinion would make a much better champion. The fans thought so too, chanting "Best in the world!" and "Next world champ!" when Davey came out.

This was an excellent match, with a good mix of technical wrestling, brawling, and high flying. Perhaps the best spot saw Davey execute a suicide dive on Strong that not only knocked Strong down, but sent Davey literally several rows into the crowd.

Davey eventually made Strong tap out with an ankle lock, but the ref was distracted by Strong's manager, Truth Martini, and didn't see it. Davey responded by knocking him silly, but the damage was done. Both men absorbed a lot of punishment, which I'm not sure was necessarily a good idea; earlier this year, people complained about John Cena getting DDT'd on the concrete floor and bouncing back from it, and they had a point. In this match, Davey Richards got put through the announce table, and moments later got hit with a Gibson Driver – one of Strong's finishing moves – on the floor.

Strong then threw him into the crowd and got back in the ring, ordering the ref to start counting Davey out. Davey managed to get back in the ring before he was counted out, which required more suspension of disbelief from me than usual. That was more than a DDT on the concrete, after all. Strong immediately hit him with two more finishers, but still couldn't get the pin. After that, Davey came back and got in some more offense, locking on a cloverleaf (his own submission finisher) to chants of "Tap!" from the crowd. When Strong had Davey in his Stronghold submission finisher, the crowd chanted "Please don't tap!" As I said, they all really wanted Davey to become the champion.

The finish came about when Davey got another ankle lock on Strong, but suddenly seemed to become disoriented and have trouble staying on his feet, causing him to release the hold. Strong capitalized, hitting him with a couple more finishers, both of which Davey somehow kicked out of. While this was a very entertaining match, I'm a little old-fashioned since I believe finishers ought to finish a match nine times out of 10. Strong finally locked on a move similar to Chris Jericho's Liontamer (not a normal Boston Crab, but one where the wrestler applying the hold has his opponent almost vertical and is driving a knee into his back), and the ref stopped the match, not because Davey tapped, but because he had lost consciousness. Earlier on, the announcers had told us that it was possible to win by knockout in ROH, so Strong retained his title.

After the match, a number of people were in the ring checking on Davey. He was bleeding either from the side of the head or the ear, and it seemed like he might be legitimately hurt. It got scarier when the ring announcer asked everybody to be patient, since they were checking to see if he had a concussion. Finally, Davey did get up under his own power. The announcers were saying that it looked like the people in the ring were telling him what happened, that he lost via KO, and Davey did a tremendous job of acting crushed by the news. As he was accompanied to the back by his tag team partner Eddie Edwards and his protege Kyle O'Reilly, there was a "Thank you, Davey!" chant.

Briscoes vs. Kings of Wrestling and Shane Hagadorn: I personally think that this feud should have finished much earlier, either after the KOW's second consecutive victory over the Briscoes, or after their third. Nevertheless, ROH chose to book this final non-title match that involved KOW manager Shane Hagadorn and "Papa" Mike Briscoe, who earlier this year jumped the guardrail and attacked Chris Hero after Hero kept on insulting the man's sons to his face. Hero responded by knocking him out, and according to the story, this means that Papa Briscoe could sue the pants off of Chris Hero if he wanted to. So remember, kids, if a wrestler makes you angry at a live event, if you're stupid enough to jump the guardrail and attack him, and if he beats you up after you hit him first, that means that you have legal grounds for a lawsuit! (Just to make 100 percent sure that nobody gets the wrong idea, that was sarcasm.)

I've had a hard time seeing the Briscoes as the babyfaces during this feud, even though the Kings (Chris Hero and Claudio Castagnoli) have been cheating and acting arrogant like heels are supposed to. For one thing, the Briscoes attacked Sara Del Rey at Supercard Of Honor V after she provoked them by doing, well, not much of anything, according to the results. The Briscoes just ran out during a match between KOW and the Motor City Machine Guns and attacked the Kings. Their reasoning seemed to be that because Sara was associated with the Kings as the "Queen of Wrestling", she was fair game. That this happened before the incident with Papa Briscoe and Hero makes it even more unwarranted and disturbing.

Since Daizee Haze was also attacked by Austin Aries on ROH's TV show this year, and announcer Mike Hogewood acted outraged about Aries (a heel) hitting a woman, the message here seemed to be that it's never OK to hit a woman unprovoked, unless she's a heel, in which case it's perfectly fine. The addition of Papa Briscoe to the mix didn't help matters, since the Briscoes cut promos talking about how dangerous their dad was, how they knew because their dad had been beating them since they were little.

Dave Prazak, the heel commentator, was making these very same points, and I found myself agreeing with him. The fans in attendance were at the very least divided; there were chants of "Chris is awesome!" when Hero was in the ring, and "[F] you Briscoes!" To be fair, there was also a "Man up!" chant, which is used by Briscoe fans.

When the Kings and the Briscoes were in the ring, I enjoyed the match, because all four men are talented wrestlers. A couple of good spots involved Castagnoli hitting a European uppercut on one of the Briscoes as he flew off the top rope, and both Briscoes going airborne simultaneously and crashing onto Hero, Castagnoli, and Hagadorn on the floor.

When Papa Briscoe and/or Hagadorn were in the ring it wasn't that great. Hagadorn, who's a legit student of ROH's wrestling school, could have perhaps put on a good show if any of the Briscoes bothered to sell his offense. Pretty much everything Hagadorn did, aside from a low blow, was no-sold. Meanwhile, Papa Briscoe is pretty muscular and looks to have some wrestling experience, but he's still old and thus limited in what he can do. So Hagadorn was basically there to get beat up and run away, and Papa Briscoe was there to beat him up and chase him. Hero actually hit Papa Briscoe with a loud rolling elbow near the end of the match, which knocked him out cold and got a big pop, so apparently there were a lot of people in the building who weren't big fans of the guy.

Del Rey interfered in the match by pulling Papa Briscoe out of the ring. The "woman acts afraid of man, man grabs her, man makes like he might hit her, man kisses her" spot ensued. Then Del Rey was ejected from ringside. While I'm sort of glad that he didn't hit her, this spot was old a decade ago, and I wouldn't have been very entertained by it even if the male wrestler was one that I actually liked. Prazak kind of saved it, though, by complaining that Sara was being sent to the back and saying "She was the one who got violated by that pervert!" The way he said it made me chuckle.

The match finally ended with Hagadorn falling victim to a Doomsday Device, with Papa Briscoe hitting the clothesline off the top rope. The night immediately before this pay-per-view, ROH put on a show in Plymouth, Mass., in which the Kings of Wrestling took on the American Wolves (Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards). I would have much rather watched that match than the six-man.

Christopher Daniels vs. Homicide: Fresh off of winning the ROH Television title, the Fallen Angel was facing the Notorious 187, giving both men a chance to demonstrate that TNA made a mistake in releasing them. Before the match, there was a loud "[F] TNA!" chant from the crowd. Both Daniels and Homicide gestured for the fans to stop, with Daniels pointing to the ROH logo in the ring; the fans responded by chanting "ROH!"

It wasn't a bad match by any means, but I've seen both of these guys do much better. In Daniels' case, I saw him put on a match that was twice as good as this one with Austin Aries at the previous pay-per-view, and saw him have a great match against Roderick Strong when I attended the November ROH show in Mississauga, Ontario. I also saw Homicide in action that night against Jay Briscoe, and he was impressive as well. But for whatever reason, this particular match just didn't measure up to what I've seen from these two in the past.

There were some cool moments, such as Daniels hitting an Arabian press on Homicide outside the ring, and Homicide hitting Daniels with Eddie Guerrero's "three amigos" series of vertical suplexes (starting up an "Eddie!" chant). The finish was a little bit strange, however. After a ref bump, Homicide took off his shirt and threw it in Daniels' face. That's probably a little bit disorienting, but it's not what you expect a wrestler to do when taking advantage of a ref bump. Homicide followed that up by hitting the Ace Crusher on Daniels, and got the pin after the ref came to in time to make the count.

At ringside during this match was one of ROH's newer acquisitions: Mike Bennett, a.k.a. "The Prodigy", along with Bob Evans, his trainer and a guy who dresses like Mickey from the "Rocky" films. Bennett was there to scout his future opposition, apparently. After the match, Bennett grabbed the Television title belt, got up on the ring apron with a mic, and said "Hey Chris, that was a real impressive win, bud." He then handed him the title belt and walked away acting very smug, with Daniels seething. Looks like the beginning of a program between these two.

Sonjay Dutt vs. Eddie Edwards: Kenny Omega was originally scheduled to be Edwards' opponent, but he got injured. Dutt was a more than adequate replacement, as these two had a good, fast-paced match. While it started out friendly with a handshake, Dutt held out his hand as if to shake Edward's hand again, only to slap him across the face. Then Dutt bailed out of the ring before an angry Edwards could get him, and crawled under the ring. While Edwards was looking over the side at where he'd last seen Dutt, Dutt emerged on the other side of the ring. After putting a finger to his lips to tell the crowd full of Edwards fans to be quiet, he made a big show of sneaking up behind Edwards and getting ready to hit him from behind, only for Edwards to turn around at the last second and nail him.

Dutt showed why he should be seen on television and pay-per-view more often in the future, and Edwards proved that he deserves the push he seems to be getting after winning the promotion's Survival Of The Fittest event. (Based on the ROH Video Wire, it looks as though Edwards will be challenging for the world championship in 2011.) Edwards finally won after hitting the 2K1 on Dutt.

Sara Del Rey and Serena Deeb vs. Daizee Haze and Awesome Kong: The first thing that struck me as Serena walked out was how gorgeous she looks now that she's grown some hair back. She looked good even when she was bald, but she looks better with hair. Enough of that, since none of the women involved here are just eye candy. Del Rey and Haze have been the only women on ROH television to win consistently, being fed a steady diet of jobbers, and lately have been asking for better competition. The two of them decided to face one another, with each one picking a tag partner to join her. So two female wrestlers missed by WWE and TNA fans came to ROH. Kong had previously faced Del Rey at Supercard Of Honor V, in a match that Del Rey won by hitting her with Chris Hero's loaded elbow pad.

Haze wrestled most of the match, as Del Ray and Serena did a good job of isolating her from Kong and beating up on her. The crowd wanted Kong tagged in early on, but Serena stopped Haze from making the tag and heeled it up by taunting the crowd about it. There were chants of "[F] the divas!" and "CM Punk". Eventually Kong did get the hot tag, and while she didn't do a lot she definitely made an impact. (No TNA-related pun intended.) It wasn't long before Del Rey was down and on the receiving end of a big splash by Kong. Kong followed it up with the Implant Buster, but Del Ray kicked out. As the match continued, we also saw Del Rey hit her finisher – the Royal Butterfly – on Haze, with Haze also kicking out. Serena took Kong down near the end with an impressive spear that you'd never see from a WWE Diva, and was selling that she hurt her shoulder after crashing into Kong. The heels won the match after Del Ray hit Haze with a piledriver.

There was an amusing moment on commentary when Prazak dismissively said "Women's wrestling … it can be OK sometimes," as though he couldn't have cared less about it. For those who don't know, Prazak established and has a hand in running Shimmer Women Athletes, the all-female wrestling fed.

Colt Cabana vs. T.J. Perkins: This was a good match, although just decent by ROH standards. Cabana won with a rollup out of nowhere. Perkins looked good in defeat, since he managed to hit Colt before Colt nailed him with two of his signature moves: the bionic elbow and the flying [two syllable word that begins with A and ends with E]. Perkins looked frustrated after the loss, but Colt showed him respect by shaking his hand.

Kenny King and Rhett Titus vs. Kyle O'Reilly and Adam Cole: This was a good match to open the show. Titus isn't acting like a wannabe male stripper any more and has gotten rid of the silly bowtie that went with that gimmick, which I think is a step in the right direction. Fans might start taking him more seriously, and since he and King – known as the All Night Express – have a guaranteed future shot at the tag titles, that's a good thing. An interesting spot involved King pulling Titus out of the ring to regroup after he'd been getting beat up, followed by O'Reilly going for a suicide dive only to stop himself as his opponents moved out of the way and to another side of the ring. O'Reilly then leaped over the ropes to hit them with a cross body, only to get caught by the ANE. While they were holding onto O'Reilly, Cole flew over the ropes and crashed onto all three men. There was another spot where O'Reilly caught King by the leg, then threw King's leg at Titus (who instinctively grabbed it), then grabbed Titus' leg and executed a dragon screw leg whip that took down Titus, which also took down King since Titus was still holding onto his partner's leg. The ANE fought back, though, and finally got the victory with a combination blockbuster/powerbomb.

Also: Footage of Jim Cornette interviewing Shelton Benjamin & Charlie Haas, the World's Greatest Tag Team, was shown during the intermission. The two of them announced that they would be appearing regularly for ROH in 2011 and had their sights set on the tag titles currently held by the Kings of Wrestling.

Posted by Kevin Eck at 6:38 PM | | Comments (31)
        

Comments

This is exactly what is missing in wrestling today. It makes one long for the days of territories.

It's embarrassing that you haven't reviewed it, and worse, that you reviewed TLC over it.

what, exactly, is the point of covering pro wrestling if you don't cover the serious shows in pro wrestling? At the very least, you should have mentioned it was happening, like you do when MCW shows run. But i guess this is a blog that considers Hogan's wedding a more worthy wrestling event to write about.

RESPONSE FROM KE: I did mention it was happening last week and included a promotional video in the post. Trust me, if I did nothing but write a pro wrestling blog I would cover everything -- but that isn't the case. And if you really don't understand why Hogan's wedding and the TLC pay-per-view are covered here, then obviously you don't understand how blogs and websites work. It's the same reason The Baltimore Sun covers the Ravens and Orioles like crazy, and other sports not so much. Numbers don't lie.

I just wanted you to know Kevin I am having a wrestling match in my living room next Saturday night. Open challenge to anyone. Will you cover that? It is wrestling, right? =D

I rag on you for not promoting the show and you come back with the argument that you posted about the women's tag match?

OK, fair enough I suppose.

I appreciate your position a little more than I did a couple of hours ago. But still: I suggest undertaking a new rule. If it's a wrestling iPPV with a national company, like ROH or Dragon Gate, it should be watched.

Thanks for posting this, Kevin. After writing it, I can actually sympathize with your position more than I did before, since it was a fair bit of work.

If you're able to watch and cover iPPVs from ROH and/or Dragon Gate when they're shown, though, I really do encourage it. You'll probably enjoy them more than the average TNA pay-per-view, and perhaps even more than WWE's product. If you don't have the time, though, I'll be more than willing to do this again.

I'm also posting because I realized that I made a mistake when writing about the Homicide/Daniels match. When taking notes during the show, I somehow got Homicide's finishers mixed up and said he won with the Cop Killer (Gringo Killer during his time in TNA) when he actually won with the Ace Crusher. Would it be possible for you to fix that?

RESPONSE FROM KE: I'd love to have you do more of these. Great job. I'll make the fix.

Roy, most people don't care about ROH, and correct me if I'm wrong, but it's not Kevin's job to promote it.

i've been wanting to do ROH for a while now. Kevin, do you think you'd actually make the trip for one of their shows? I think they have one coming up in Philly soon (I'm sure you could convince some of the regulars to come with!)

RESPONSE FROM KE: Believe it or not, I exchanged e-mails with Dave Lagana of ROH about going to the New York show last Saturday. Unfortunately, I work most Saturdays in the fall and winter and there was no way I could make it. I'm sure I will get to another ROH show at some point. I did go to an ROH show in Glen Burnie, Md., back in 2003 when Samoa Joe and CM Punk were with the company.

I agree with Roy Montes Kev. You should have to watch and report on EVERY national company PPV. I suggest walking out on your family and quitting your job, there can be no outside distractions. Then you will need to set up a word press account and somehow convince the Baltimore Sun to promote your personal blog on their site and also spend tons of money to get position on google search.

This all should only cost you about $300 a month, not including any fees & settlements from your divorce, new home rent. You might think this sounds expensive and emotionally/physically draining but if you really took wrestling as seriously as you claim you do, it wouldn't be a sacrifice at all.

RESPONSE FROM KE: LOL.

I was at this show, my first ROH experience, and I almost wrote up a review to send you, eck. Now I'm glad I didn't because this one was excellent.

A few thoughts:

1. The show was unbelievable overall. Easily the best wrestling show I've ever been to.

2. The Colt Cabana match had exactly ZERO spots. They literally just wrestled and it was extremely entertaining.

3. The six-man tag was booked superbly. The non-wrestlers played their roles to perfection. The crowd was at least 50% behind KOW, maybe more.

4. The title match did have too many false finishes, but was as stiff as you could ask for. A performance worthy of being the main event.

5. The best match of the night (excluding the "match without honor") was the tag match that opened it. The crowd was so hot after this match that it was tough for Cabana/Perkins and the women to build any momentum.

6. Let's put it this way: when Homicide vs Daniels is the worst match on the card, you're doing something right.

7. If you haven't seen the Steen/Generico feud (I hadn't until I bought tickets to this event), you need to. Steen played his role brilliantly, and this match was absolutely superb.

ROH has earned a fan in me. I'd almost forgotten what great wrestling looks like.

I sure hope the boys in Stamford were watching this card because it's everything that WWE is not right now.

* A nearly year-long blood feud which they managed to keep fresh all this time through great writing and planning. Steen and Generico were amazing and Steve Corino and Colt Cabana also performed well with them throughout this feud.

*Women actually wrestling with some intensity instead of being fluff.

*Tag teams that do innovative spots instead of doing fingerpokes to win matches.

*Performers showing intensity in the ring instead of selling crappy storylines and 10 year-old silliness.

WWE just finished their biggest storyline where they fired a guy and never had him off the air but then had his antagonists off the show for a week. Huh?

I hope people continue to tune in to ROH. As a wrestling fan, I tune in to WWE because I have to. I watch ROH because I want to. Keep up the fantastic work, Mr. Cornette!

Roy, I don't know if the Sun pays for Kevin to be able to watch WWE and TNA pay-per-views. Do you?

If they don't, are you willing to spend the money and help him find the time to review something most people don't really pay any attention to?

Let Kevin Eck blog about the big wrestling companies and its escapades. Let Rated Eck blog about the real stuff.

Totally agree with Roy. It's sort of like a great food critic who talks about Burger King and McDonalds day after day. The gourmet restaurants might not get as many customers, and the food might not always be wonderful, but when it's done well, it's the best around.

"It's the same reason The Baltimore Sun covers the Ravens and Orioles like crazy...."

___________________________________

What? No equal coverage for the Baltimore Buccaneers?

NFL marks.

In the great tradition of wrestling heels, let me say that I am impressed by the willingness of readers of this blog to accept mediocrity and laziness in reporting.

RESPONSE FROM KE: Labeling something mediocre is fair since that is a matter of opinion and I can respect that. I do, however, take issue with the laziness comment, because you are making a statement based on something you know nothing about.

I think it's laziness to run a wrestling blog and not cover all major wrestling pay per views. That's all. I understand that it makes more business sense to cover the national promotions and i don't think you should be covering every indie, Mexican Lucha shows or puro, but Ring of Honor Final Battle and other iPPVs are much more than that. Your readers miss a major part of the narrative of the wrestling scene today, which is a failing as a reporter or microblogger, in this case. (Microblogger meaning you're a blogger on a very specific topic, not as a term of disrespect.) And the wrestling business suffers.

Roy, speaking in the great tradition of wrestling fans, "Shut the f up (clap clap clap-clap-clap)"

in other news, I am glad to see ROH pay-per-views reviewed; I'm always interested in what's going on in areas of rasslin I don't follow. I have been very impressed with what ROH I've seen, although I find their grim, stark overall visual aesthetic a little off-putting.

Some people just don't want to face the facts. Here's one: ROH does not hold major wrestling PPV's. They are not available on most cable systems in much of the US. Although some names are well known (and should be), much of it is because these entertainers wrestle in other promotions around the country.

You might as well ask for the "Attitude" era back. It ain't happenin'.

Roy, believe it or not I sort of understand where you're coming from. When I first e-mailed Kevin asking about whether it would be possible to post a review, I said that it was partly because of his TNA-related posts that I began following TNA, and that I thought a review of Final Battle could only help ROH. So yes, I do think it deserves coverage.

That being said, there are problems. For one thing, as he's said in the past, Kevin does not get HDNet. I don't either. I had been following the show on YouTube back when ROH allowed the show to be posted there so that people without access to HDNet could follow it, but since they've changed their mind about that I was unable to watch a lot of the buildup to Final Battle. If ROH gets a better tv deal that gives it more exposure, or if HDNet expands to the point where it's available in as many places as USA or Spike, then I'm betting Kevin will start covering ROH.

Now, you might respond by saying "Okay, that might be a valid reason for not covering ROH On HDNet, but how come he couldn't write something about the PPV, which is accessible to everybody with $15, a computer, and a credit card?" Well, he could...but he wouldn't necessarily know what any of the matches were about because he would have missed the buildup. If you noticed, I mentioned the buildups several times, talking about the history between the wrestlers involved and how the match between them came about. Kevin wouldn't have been able to do that, and since ROH pulled all the videos of past shows from YouTube, he wouldn't have been able to do any last minute research.

PWG is another great indy promotion that not only features many of the people from ROH, but also a lot of other impressive talent. But the only way to follow that promotion is by spending money on DVDs of past shows or attending live events, so you can't realistically expect somebody covering WWE and TNA--both of which are available just by picking up the remote--to cover PWG just as thoroughly, since that would be a lot more trouble and cost a lot more money. It's pretty much the same thing with ROH; if you don't live in a place where you have access to HDNet, you have a hard time covering it.

Roy, in order to be a "major wrestling pay per view," you can't be only broadcast via internet. As I posted I am hooked on ROH, but those two are kinda mutually exclusive.

I don't always agree with Eck's opinion, but I appreciate his effort every week, the lack of popups and ads on this site, and the comments section very much.

I was always taught growing up, if you are going to criticize someone for not doing something right that you had better be able to do a better job of it yourself. With that said Roy, where is your all inclusive wrestling blog? If you can do it better let's see it. Other than that, great review and I like the idea of outsourcing reviews from loyal ringposts followers.

Shut up, Roy. You are just being an ungrateful brat. This is the only wrestling blog from an established newspaper anywhere in the world and the only reason why it even exists is because Kevin happens to be the assistant sports editor at the Baltimore Sun. He isn't getting paid to write a wrestling blog but he does it nonetheless in his own spare time. I've disagreed with him many times before - eg. his infatuation with HBK; his faith in Dave Meltzer - but at least I appreciate what he does. He obviously doesn't have the time to watch every wrestling PPV out there. He doesn't even have time to watch every TNA PPV, let alone ROH's. I've actually suggested to him before that he should stop watching TNA in favor of ROH but it is his prerogative to watch whatever he wants to. All you are doing is complaining like a spoilt and ungrateful brat. Who the hell are you to dictate what a wrestling blog should be like? Why don't you start a wrestling blog yourself while juggling a full-time job? You probably won't even last three months, let alone three years.

Jesus, Roy, if you don't like it, and feel a niche needs to be filled, write your own damn blog for Pete's (not the Schmuck's) sake!

So much bitching and whining on the internet from people who get so much for free.

RIDICULOUS!!!

Roy, why don't you go start your own little blog and cover the things you wanna see covered so badly? You obviously are very passionate about this, so are you just lazy?

Eck is under no journalistic oath to cover every event under the sun, he covers TNA & WWE because they're on national cable TV and constitute "the big two" wrestling companies, and with something in the neighborhood of 10 hours a week that these take up, 12-14 for PPV's sometimes, its easy to see that it would be hard for the guy to still contribute to the other professional duties he has and be any semblance of a family man if he added more wrestling to his plate.

Plus if you love ROH so much, why would you want someone that can really only follow it thru other news outlets critiquing it and its performers? Wouldn't you rather hear it from someone that follows them intently?

So my advice is to stop being such a whiny scrooge and enjoy the ROH coverage secondhand that Eck has said he will happily use here, and if you truly have such little interest in WWE & TNA maybe not frequent a blog that covers them.

Kevin -

Thank you so much for posting this review.

I quit watching WWE a few months ago. Nothing but ROH since then, and it's easily been a decade or more since I've been this satisfied with a wrestling product. Thanks to Ring of Honor, I can honestly say that I'm proud to be a wrestling fan again.

ROH is now doing what WWE has failed to do (excepting HBK/Taker) for the last 5 years: Elevate pro-wrestling to an ART form that it's fans can let themselves become emotionally invested in.

I can't wait until Eck starts covering ROH TV and PPV. Until then, I'm content reading articles like Rob's admirable work here.

Hey, Kevin! I like your blog, whatever company you're reporting on. I have seen some ROH matches on the net and really enjoy them I have a question, though. The crowds are pretty small, and I'm curious what the wrestlers in ROH and other non-WWE or TNA organizations make $$-wise. Do you have a ballpark figure? Do they have other jobs or wrestle multiple promotions? Thanks! Keep up the good work, and tell your family "Thanks" for letting you watch and write so much!

RESPONSE FROM KE: I don' think anyone in ROH is making six figures, but the stars can make a good enough living on the indy scene that they don't have to have "real jobs" in adidtion to wrestling.

I'm glad to see the Eck family is out in full force.

...no, seriously: I have a commenter criticizing me in the "great tradition of wrestling fans" while professing ignorance of ROH? Here's something controversial: you can't be a great wrestling fan or claim their tradition if you only follow both or either of the "Big Two." Which seems to preclude you from being a "great wrestling fan" or from claiming their tradition.

...another commenter compares ROH's relevance to modern wrestling with the Attitude Era? Nonsense, not because the products are completely different (although they are) but, uh, well, you can figure it out for yourself. And Marko?

..."Although some names are well known (and should be), much of it is because these entertainers wrestle in other promotions around the country." Er, not really.

...Rob Brown, your points are well taken, though I think you're giving too much credit to the excuse that HDNet is unavailable or that good indy wrestling is mostly accessible via DVD. That's true enough, but reading the ROH preview for Final Battle isn't exactly as much of a challenge as reading Dostoevsky.

...tom, your point is fair enough, though I find it narrow-minded and wrong.

...@Bryan S., thank you for the non-sequiter. Whoever taught you that was wrong.

...Anonymous; I'm reluctant to engage someone calling themselves "anonymous," but I would like to say that Meltzer is the only real journalist in pro wrestling. And I don't mean that as a personal attack on Eck or anyone else: I'm just saying that Meltzer is a fine wrestling journalist, and even though he covers MMA and seems to love it more now, that's what he is and what he'll always be. People who hate him are typically people who "read" his "stories" when they're "credited" and distorted by other wrestling news sites.

...Curtis: See Bryan.

...Mechanical Bull: Thank you for adding nothing new to the conversation. Bravo.

I've said my piece.

Mr. Eck, I think you do a fine job recapping shows. I think you do a lousy job covering pro wrestling with any depth, not just because you don't dig into the independent scene (I would argue, incidentally, that ROH is not an indie at this point but a legitimate #3) but because you mostly just do TV show reviews, which could be a lot more insightful, important and impactful. But I'm just some dude.

No, Roy. You aren't just some dude. You are a spoilt, ungrateful brat who clearly has no appreciation of how difficult it is to write a blog for free with a quality good enough to be associated with a newspaper and to do so consistently for over three years. Your grasp on reality is clearly warped. ROH is not an indy? You're just being stupid. So get off your high horse, smack yourself in the face and wake up to the fact that you're just a bitter, pathetic loser. Stop whining and get a life.

At least Roy is well spoken. I may not agree with him, but he certainly isn't your typical internet troll with horrible grammar, spelling and immature commentary.

He sounds like a great heel though. I'm thinking perhaps he and Kevin should step into the ring and settle their differences MCW style!

Or, at the very least, I'd love to see them cut some video promos on each other...that would put asses in the seats! Well, at least asses in front of their computers...

Roy, and thank you for brushing me up on "retorts that do a poor job of hiding the fact that someone got butt-hurt about what people said about them". I hadn't heard anyone use one since junior high.

I like a funny argument, and was really pleased to see Dostoyevski referenced on this blog...that said..,
Man, I was really happy to see this review. Started watching roh on when I dumped comcast for fios. It's really pretty great. Jim cornette is a purist and genius. I'd look forward to any other guest roh ppv reviews. Keep up the great work, Kent....uh, Kevin.....I read your blog regularly.

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "y" in the field below:
About Kevin Eck
The Baltimore Sun's Kevin Eck blogs about professional wrestling.
E-mail Kevin.
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Cast your vote
Most Recent Comments
Photo galleries
Sign up for FREE local sports alerts
Get free Sun alerts sent to your mobile phone.*
Get free Baltimore Sun mobile alerts
Sign up for local sports text alerts

Returning user? Update preferences.
Sign up for more Sun text alerts
*Standard message and data rates apply. Click here for Frequently Asked Questions.
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com sports blogs  Subscribe to this feed
Charm City Current
Stay connected