Looking at the Michael Hayes situation
I didn’t write about the 60-day suspension of Smackdown head writer and former wrestling star Michael Hayes when it was made public a couple weeks ago because I wanted to hear some more details before I commented.
As just about everyone knows by now, Hayes was suspended for using a racial slur when talking with Mark Henry at a WrestleMania after party.
The Wrestling Observer reported that MVP, who is friends with Hayes, jokingly told him, "You're more [N-word] than I am." Later, apparently after drinking at the party, Hayes supposedly was trying to explain to Henry that if he showed more personality, he would get over better. "I'm more [N-word] than you are," Hayes reportedly said to Henry.
Henry complained to management about it, and WWE chairman Vince McMahon made the call to suspend Hayes. WWE subsequently reported on its Web site that Hayes will have to undergo an evaluation before he will be allowed to return once his suspension is over.
There are some in wrestling circles who believe that Hayes should have been fired, while others think he shouldn't have even been suspended. Personally, I think the 60-day suspension was the appropriate action.
In a traditional workplace, what Hayes reportedly said certainly is a fire-able offense. Working behind the curtain in WWE is anything but a traditional workplace, however. There is somewhat of a frat house mentality, and ribbing, hazing and various sorts of politically incorrect behavior -- including racial jokes -- are prevalent. I’m not saying that I condone any of that, but that culture has existed in professional wrestling for a long time.
I have met Hayes a few times in passing, but I certainly don't know him well enough to say with any certainty whether he had any malicious intent. If I had to guess, however, I would say that Hayes probably views racial jokes as just boys being boys in a male-dominated, macho industry. According to The Wrestling Observer, this is far from the first time that Hayes has used racially offensive language in a joking manner.
If he and MVP have the kind of relationship in which they can joke with each other in that way, then so be it. It still has no business in the workplace, but, again, WWE isn’t a traditional work environment. Obviously, Hayes does not have the same kind of relationship with Henry that he does with MVP.
The reality is that Hayes, the former leader of the Fabulous Freebirds who wrestled in the South during the territorial days in the late 1970s and early ’80s, has to accept that it’s a different world in 2008 then it was in 1978. No matter what his intent was in saying such an inflammatory word, he should have used better judgment, especially because he is in a prominent position (he has vice president status) in the company.
WWE is a publicly traded company, and its employees – especially those in management – should be held to a high standard. As I said, however, I don’t believe that Hayes should be fired, because it seems as though he said what he said with no malice, and I think that does matter. Most likely, alcohol played a part in this incident, as Hayes has a reputation for saying offensive things when he's drunk. That problem also needs to be addressed, and Hayes and anyone else in the company who engages in inappropriate behavior needs to be put on alert that it no longer will be tolerated.
I believe in second chances, and I think Hayes deserves one. If he slips up again, however, I don’t think he should get a third.


Comments
Whew ! tread lightly on this touchy subject . I guess if things are said between friends (each of different ethnicity ) , it would be ok , albeit under normal circumstances insensitive and offensive . I was a fan of Michael Hayes and the Freebirds way back when and I'm sure that with his southern , good 'ol boy mentality ( gosh I hope I didn't offend anyone from the south ) that he thought it was ok . HOWEVER , to be in the position he holds he should have enough smarts to NEVER utter ANYTHING that could be deemed degrading or offensive to another . I'd be ok with suspension if 1st time . If indeed there have been other incidents , he should be gone .
RESPONSE FROM KEVIN ECK: Reportedly, Hayes often uses racial slurs, although in a joking way. If he has never been reprimanded before, then I treat this as a first offense. The people who are his superiors chose to look the other way, so, in Hayes can make the argument that what he was saying was condoned.
Posted by: jack in hebron | May 8, 2008 9:47 PM
Thats Bad Street baby!
Posted by: John | May 8, 2008 11:13 PM
This is the first feud involving Mark Henry that's been worth following in about 10 years.
Posted by: Quin | May 8, 2008 11:45 PM
"In a traditional workplace, what Hayes reportedly said certainly is a fire-able offense. Working behind the curtain in WWE is anything but a traditional workplace, however. There is somewhat of a frat house mentality, and ribbing, hazing and various sorts of politically incorrect behavior -- including racial jokes -- are prevalent."
This is exactly why no one takes wrestling seriously. I always hear people whining and crying about how the media hates wrestling, and how people should give wrestling more respect, and on and on and on. The fact is that wrestling is extremely un-politically correct, that they do employ many tactics that would be considered questionable at best in any other industry, and that there's generally not as much concern for things of this nature as there would be anywhere else. As far as I'm concerned, as long as WWE wants to play by its own rules and live in its own little fantasy universe they still can't be looked at in the same light as other businesses.
Posted by: Anonymous | May 9, 2008 3:56 AM
If what the Wrestling Observer reported is true, then someone should have a word with MVP, as well.
Posted by: Christopher | May 9, 2008 2:27 PM
Your comment that a 60-day suspension was appropriate proves that we have not advanced far from to '70's in the South. In that environment, I am sure that there there are a lot of racial and sexual jokes that offend many people. It's okay for MVP to say it but not Hayes? As a black male, I am no longer offended by the word. It is just a word and I am pretty sure Hayes meant no offense by it, as does the others he comes in contact with everyday.
Posted by: steve in germany | May 11, 2008 11:24 AM