Horrible choice for new Smackdown color commentator
If you haven’t already read it elsewhere, Jonathan Coachman was introduced as JBL’s replacement at the Smackdown/ECW tapings in Richmond, Va., last night.
This decision is mind-boggling. Whatever it is that WWE sees in Coachman as an announcer, I sure don’t see it.
Coachman did a fine job conducting backstage interviews during the early part of this decade, and he showed some personality when interacting with The Rock in several memorable segments. However, every attempt to transition him into a spot at the announce table has failed.
At one point, he was being groomed to replace Jim Ross as the lead announcer on Raw. Then, after a heel turn, Coachman sat alongside Joey Styles (who had replaced Ross) and color commentator Jerry Lawler as part of a three-man announcing crew on Raw. Both stints were panned by fans and wrestling journalists.
Now, instead of bringing in a former wrestler or wrestling personality with charisma and a gift of gab, WWE turns to Coachman — again.
I could think of a dozen people off the top of my head who would be better choices. In fact, I wrote about them last week. The funny thing is that I was going to put Coachman on the list as a joke, but I opted to make Funaki my humorous pick. Come to think of it, even Funaki would be more entertaining than “Coach.”







Comments
You're so right about this move. Even "Mr. Excitement" Ken Resnick would be an improvement. Gorilla Monsoon must be turning over in his grave. ( and Lord Alfred Hayes as well ). Why not Sunny?
Posted by: david elzey | December 31, 2007 6:28 PM
Coach is terrible. The quality of SmackDown just dropped a notch. What are they thinking?
Posted by: Norman | December 31, 2007 6:57 PM
Totally agree. I like Coachman but not as an announcer. There are many others who would have been better choices. Hopefully he'll surprise us all.
Posted by: Kate Ramunni | December 31, 2007 9:42 PM
Khali would have been better. At least he has wrestling experience. I can deal with Coach as Vince's assistant, but I want a real wrestler as the analyst.
Posted by: John | January 1, 2008 7:34 PM
I agree as well. After seeing Coach for a few weeks now you begin to see how great the teaming of JBL with Cole was. JBL's taunts and loudmouthed insults of Cole made the show better even when it was lackluster in terms of matches or wrestlers..
Posted by: WWE Characters the Blog | January 21, 2008 9:01 AM