Barbaro, cont.
You might have noticed that our paper has gone full blanket coverage on Barbaro, and that has annoyed a lot of people quite a bit. Personally - and I say this not necessarily as an employee of the Sun and someone who probably is going to be writing about him again eventually - I think it's appropriate. If horse racing overall isn't overwhelmingly popular, the Kentucky Derby is a huge deal, and if the winner of that race goes out in the next Triple Crown race and blows out his leg that graphically, in front of a crowd that big and on national TV, and has his life in danger because of it, it's tough to argue that it isn't big news.
Then again - the fact that so many people are saying, "It's just a horse! He's not the president! Give us a break!'' might very well indicate how much trouble racing really is in. The odds are good that people wouldn't be yelling, "It's just Cal Ripken!'' or, "It's just Ray Lewis!'' if he suffered a grotesque, near-fatal injury on a stage that big. Baseball is baseball, football is football, and racing is racing.
Another sign of trouble: the news, in Sandra McKee's story today, that a fund has been set up to aid the veterinary hospital center in Pennsylvania that's treating Barbaro - to "provide a lasting resource to help care for animals.''
I'm no psychic, but based on what I've heard since the accident from people who really dislike the mega-rich, elitist aspects of the sport (which those people mostly don't consider a "sport''), that's going to rub the masses the wrong way. And this tidbit won't help: the one-day look I had of the facility left the impression that it's doing just fine, and that the horses and other animals there are getting better treatment than, say, most residents of Baltimore.
I like animals as much as the next guy, and am more in awe of thoroughbreds now (and feel a little more sorry for them) than I was before Saturday afternoon. But if it were me, I'd sleep better sending that check to the trauma centers at, say, the University of Maryland hospital or Hopkins or the like, the ones that treat shooting victims. There are probably people sitting around ERs in town right now, wishing they had gotten hurt in the 10th at Pimlico Saturday afternoon instead of on Edmondson Avenue today.
Heck, even if your fellow human citizens don't move you to sympathy, the local vet hospital/animal shelter situation isn't exactly looking flush with resources, I'd imagine. Send a check there, and help out an abandoned animal that isn't set to stand at stud at $100,000 a pop.
But we digress.
To sum up, though, I'm thinking that column colleague Peter Schmuck's view and mine don't exactly mesh on this. My thought is that the "very casual race fan'' he mentions is exactly who's at stake here, and that the hardcore fan base is way too small for this incident to blow over. Besides, the more furious reactions to this are coming from those real, in-the-know fans.
Then again, you might not want to listen to me. I'm the one who wrote Tuesday that Charismatic was one of the famous horses who suffered a fatal injury in a race. Bad mistake - he was injured, but survived. A case of thinking about writing something without actually writing it - I had "near-fatal'' in my mind as I wrote, and inadvertently left out "near.'' I apologize.
The unintended consequence of the status of this story? I've got to hold off for another day to talk about the playoffs. I haven't completely digested Game 7 of Mavs-Spurs, and here came Heat-Pistons Game 1 last night and Game 1 Mavs-Suns tonight. Not to mention the season finale of "Lost,'' speaking of shooting victims.
I'll just leave you with this: since the Heat-Bulls first-round series was tied 2-all, with the Bulls having won two straight at home to tie the series, and with everybody in America writing off Shaq as being too old, the roster being totally mismatched and Pat Riley being the master screw-up of a potential Finals team ... the Heat have gone 7-1, won two series and stolen home court from the two-time defending conference champ and the team with the NBA's best record.
If they win it all, and pull out the no-respect card in the post-game celebration locker room, they'll be more entitled than almost any other team ever. (No. 1 on that list, of course, is the Texas football team after the Rose Bowl.)

Comments
Ah perspective. Don't forget all those people who likely drove past food banks to bring plenty of apples and carrots to a horse instead of feeding their fellow man.
Posted by: T.F. | May 24, 2006 12:23 PM
I dont have a problem with the coverage. What is the saying... any publicity is good publicity? Hopefully that will be the case. Anyway, another factor that I am sure is playing in the amount of coverage that the sun gives this is that it happenend in baltimore. If this had happenend a few weeks back in kentuky I doubt there would be this much coverage from the sun.
Posted by: Nick | May 24, 2006 12:31 PM
T.F. -- Did it occur to you that it is possible to do both? Having only one cause does not make your dedication to it better than that of someone who chooses to spread their good fortune around. As a life-long horse racing fan, I am quite happy to drop off carrots which are going to be shared among many animals (some experimental, not necessarily those owned by the wealthy) on my way home from Goodwill with my latest clothing donation.
If you feel people are starving in the US, you might try agitating for governmental change rather than relying on charity.
Posted by: aphra | May 24, 2006 1:13 PM
I can tell you why we little folks care so much about a horse. I was recalling Secretariat. In a spring when there was nothing but Watergate and criminal activity in the news, a horse that loved to run and ran well was the most honest thing there was. He appeared on the cover of every major news magazine that spring. It was amazing . . . for awhile we all forgot the mess the country was in. I think it is the same with Barbaro. He is like an injured pet. He doesn't have his own agenda. He was doing what he loved and he can't do it again. I agree that the center doesn't need the money but I think an honest animal always touches the heartstrings. You can't help but hope he survives and has a pain free and happy future.
Posted by: Marilyn Neenan | May 24, 2006 1:14 PM
Personally, I would much rather see news on Barbaro than on George Bush. Lest we forget, without animals, mankind CANNOT exist, and they WERE here before us. Another thing, this is America, the citizens of this country can choose to donate to whatever they want and good for the person who donated a large sum of money to create the Barbaro Fund; maybe this will help other horses from needlessly being euthanized. Maybe the government should take the money that is spent supporting millions of Illegal Immigrants and put it to helping the unfortunate, homeless, and hungry citizens of this country.
Posted by: Sherri Stearns | May 24, 2006 1:22 PM
As a spectator at the Preakness on Saturday I don't think there has at all been too much coverage on this event. It was devestating to all who love the sport of racing and horses alone. Coverage on Barbaro and his progress is GOOD NEWS that should be reported on! 'Just a horse' as if humans are superior to all other creatures on earth - my ass...tell that to the millions who know this animal like the back of their hand.
Posted by: Kelly | May 24, 2006 1:27 PM
Horses are hard-coded into my DNA, so my anguish over Barbaro's injury was completely expected, but I am blown away by the overwhelming response from the public! It's gratifying, and I wish him well.
I also wish that the people who are sending flowers, apples, cards, and donations would think about the horses and humans who try to eke out a living at the smaller bush league tracks scattered all over the US. Many of these horses are forced to run in poor condition, ignoring injuries, poor nutrition, foot problems, etc. in hopes that a small payoff will help pay the bills. Horses that are too slow, too old, or too sore to run are bought by killer buyers for $350 - $500. They are slaughtered and exported to Europe and Asia where it sells for $17 a pound.
Last fall I bought a Thouroughbred who was destined for the slaughterhouse. For $500 I bought a malnourished horse with bad feet. The vet said he had poor conformation, meaning he should never have been put into training. He's recovered well and is fat and sassy, enjoying his life of leisure. I looked up his pedigree and discovered that he is a distant relative of Barbaro...does anyone want to send me money to help with his upkeep?
Posted by: Mac | May 24, 2006 1:29 PM
I think the coverage we've experienced so far speaks volumes about our society...in a positive way. If you're looking for a way to justify the financial support that has been sent to the facility at New Bolton, then perhaps you should consider the fact that medical advances made in veterinary medicine are frequently transferrable to the treatment of humans. As for me, I'd rather think that there are members of our society who were just plain moved by what we all saw on the track that day. Donations to food banks in our part of the US frequently contain items for pets. What about yours?
Posted by: AHT | May 24, 2006 1:40 PM
I attened the Preakness saturday with a friend from Washigton, yes, I left feeling sick and a strange longing for something I couldn't reach out for, there is a strong bond between man and horse, here is a magnificent creature out there for our pleasure and he is almost destroyed, gives me a heavy heart to say the least..
Posted by: Dorothy Brooks | May 24, 2006 1:41 PM
It all depends on if you are a horse person or not. I have watched the news everyday wanting more information on Barbaro.. Is he ok, will he live, will his leg heal, and if it does will he live a pain free life, thank God the owner has the means to help him through his crisis or he would have been put down. That said-- the facility that I have been looking at in all the stories I have read looks like it has plenty of funding, and if you feel the need to donate funds to help animals, send it to New Orleans to help the Horses, dogs, cats, cows etc. that have been homeless since Katrina. I am sure they will appreciate it... As for Barbaro I wish him well and sincerely hope that he can recover. Maybe he can help produce the next Secretariet Who Knows....
Posted by: Tracy Upton | May 24, 2006 1:44 PM
It all depends on if you are a horse person or not. I have watched the news everyday wanting more information on Barbaro.. Is he ok, will he live, will his leg heal, and if it does will he live a pain free life, thank God the owner has the means to help him through his crisis or he would have been put down. That said-- the facility that I have been looking at in all the stories I have read looks like it has plenty of funding, and if you feel the need to donate funds to help animals, send it to New Orleans to help the Horses, dogs, cats, cows etc. that have been homeless since Katrina. I am sure they will appreciate it... As for Barbaro I wish him well and sincerely hope that he can recover. Maybe he can help produce the next Secretariet Who Knows....
Posted by: Tracy Upton | May 24, 2006 1:46 PM
While it’s likely true that the Barbaro story will delay Mr. Steele’s playoff coverage for a day, it’s also true that no amount of grousing about the passion Americans have for animals is going to stop it. The great stallion limping to an ambulance triggered an outpouring of generosity and support that some argue should be going to humans. But you can’t dictate people’s charitable urges, and you can’t dictate who their heroes are. With so few uncorrupt human heroes left it’s no surprise people rally around a fallen animal champion. Barbaro’s long walk to the breeder’s shed is also breeding compassion and generosity. What on earth could be wrong with that?
I’ve visited the Penn vet hospital too. It's a teaching hospital. If a few people giving a few bucks means a few more animals get a chance to see the good vets there, and their people get to keep them around, I say let’s celebrate the generosity of the American spirit, and the animals who inspire it. While we're at it, we might want to let go of the notion that generosity is finite.
Posted by: Susan | May 24, 2006 2:15 PM
This horse does not pay taxes, but his very existense provides gainful employment for many; furthermore, his performance creates tax dollars. What is your problem--just that he is an animal?
Posted by: DD | May 24, 2006 3:05 PM
So which is it? Should the sport do more to help injured animals like Barbaro, or should they put the animals down because money is allegedly needed at food banks in a society where human obesity is a much larger real problem than hunger.
There's some real perspective.
Posted by: Michael | May 24, 2006 3:28 PM
We are interested both from a science standpoint and from a humane standpoint about the progress Barbaro makes, though we don't need more rehash of the accident and what everybody was thinking/doing when it happened. I would say I have learned more about horses in the past week than in the previous 10 years.
Posted by: Cathy | May 24, 2006 3:38 PM
I feel that the coverage has gone a bit overboard, and I say that as a person that owns 3 ex-racehorses and understands and empathizes with everyone involved with Barbaro.
Your comments about the donations to New Bolton however, were way off base. The fund being set up is designed to help save animals that otherwise would have less of a chance of living. Not everyone who owns horses is wealthy. There are many many older horses in use giving riding lessons to children or providing therapeautic rides at a handicapped riding center than there are being owned by rich elitests. These horses are too old to qualify for insurance that would pay the hefty vet bills should something happen to them. Shame on you for putting down such a fund. The great thing about America is that you can choose where to donate your money, and whether you would rather feed a horse or a homeless person.
Posted by: Melanie | May 24, 2006 4:18 PM
Yes, T.F., because people who have compassion for animals NEVER have a drop to spare for humans. *rolls eyes* Having worked in many charity events for both humans and animals, I've found that most people who love animals also love their fellow man. I've also found that those who complain about charity for animals almost never give any money or time to ANY causes.
Posted by: Lover of horses AND humans | May 24, 2006 4:44 PM
Every cause has its champions. Homeless people, homeless pets, kids here in the US, kids overseas. You name it, someone cares about it. If all those someones cared about the same thing, the level of misery in this world would skyrocket due to all of the other unattended needs.
The causes an individual supports are individual choice. One shouldn't compare one against another, or worse, impugn a person for supporting one over the other.
It's perfectly OK if someone would rather write a check to restore a wetland, versus feed a kid. Someone somewhere else is making the opposite decision. Charity in all of its forms is noble and shouldn't be judged.
Posted by: sarah reschly | May 24, 2006 5:13 PM
David,
You've completely and utterly missed the point. The reason people are making donations to that fund -- or to the equine medical center -- is because of the pleasure they've received from Barbaro, whether it is through watching him compete, betting on him, etc, etc. It's completely understandable for them to give something back to the horse for the joy he has provided them. It is absolutely no different from hundreds of other charities in this country -- some of which you might consider silly or unworthy.
Posted by: Tony Bleill | May 24, 2006 8:34 PM
Can anyone tell me where I can find the current condition of the horse.I'm not a race fan and don't care to debate the who or what deserves most, junk.Every living creature is very special and should be helped when needed.With the outstanding odds against this animals survival we all can learn from him.If we will work for our own causes with the strength and class this animal has shown to survive then there will be plenty of help for all needy,human or animal,rich or poor
Posted by: James Flowers | June 8, 2006 2:17 PM