« Bracket Busted | Main | Tags, Continued »

Tags, You're Not It

I don't know if I could put it any better than Ken Murray did on the front of this morning's Sun, or John Eisenberg on the front of the sports section. I'm not even from here (yeah, you all know where I'm from), and had I been completely detached from the impact it had on Baltimore, the announcement of Paul Tagliabue's resignation this summer as NFL commissioner still would have left me cold. But throw in the utter disrespect he showed this city, the hypocrisy in dealing with other cities, the overall legacy of franchise free-agency and his generally pompous demeanor, and it's hard to work up much of a glowing testimonial.

OK, give him the nearly 20 years without having lost a game to a labor stoppage; even that little tussle a few weeks ago over the collective bargaining agreement extension was nothing compared to what baseball, the NBA and the NHL went through. And football came back to town on his watch, whereas it had left under Pete Rozelle's watch.

But also consider this:

* Cleveland had to get jerked around in order for Baltimore to get a team  back.

* Cleveland was allowed to keep its team name, colors and history, something that never happened with Baltimore.

* Also deserted callously: Los Angeles (the second-biggest market in the country) and Houston (how do you let Texas lose a pro football team?). L.A. remains unresolved, while Houston got a team back almost immediately, as had Cleveland - again, a reward Baltimore never was offered or considered for. It's all thanks to stadium roulette, which reached its peak under Tagliabue and shows no signs of stopping. Garbage franchises with inept ownership and management get to twist the arms of cities and states for stadiums, with Super Bowls dangled before them by the distinguished commissioner as a carrot. Not to mention Detroit specifically, of course.

* Charlotte and Jacksonville got the expansion teams. No one needs to go into that story again. But Jacksonville is proving more and more every day to be a mistake, no matter how much Tagliabue would like to selfishly convince everyone it wasn't. Meanwhile, Baltimore has been a huge success in every way, even managing one of the smoother owner-transfers ever done. Which, again, highlights the fact that Tagliabue isn't exactly the type to ever admit he was wrong. We've already pointed out here that he's not always on the best of terms with the truth, at least not in public.

Sports Illustrated gave him the big-feature treatment in January; you can see an excerpt here, although the entire story is accessible only to subscribers. His putdown line about baseball is worth the price of a subscription alone, although he (rather weakly) backtracked on it in a letter to the editor in a later issue. It seems to sum his persona up pretty well.

As for the other commissioners: if David Stern resigned today, his legacy would be that he truly saved his league. Gary Bettman nearly ruined his. Bud Selig has presided over so many dizzying highs and disgraceful lows, his reputation will be all over the place.

Tagliabue's somehow has a nice glow on it. It's undeserved. Be happy that while he was in charge, you saw a full slate of games every weekend. Be justifiably angry that, here in Baltimore, you had to wait too long to see games in person.

Comments

Dave,

You hit the nail right on the head with your comments. Keep up the good work. Look forward to your insight. Have a great day.

While I agree that Paul Tagliabue was less than fair to the city of Baltimore by taking so long for an NFL franchise to return, it would be selfish of Ravens fans to not give him his just praise. He created a league that Baltimore is proud to have a franchise in. Although it still bugs me that the Browns kept their jerseys and records while Peyton Manning is surpassing all of Johnny Unitas' records in Indianapolis, Tagliabue created a league where the Ravens became a Super Bowl champion in less time than any other expansion franchise (in my opinion the Ravens started with more of a disadvantage than the new Browns, Texans, Panthers and Jaguars ever did) by creating the salary cap structure and sharing revenue. The bottom line is we have had the Ravens for ten years, we won a Super Bowl before the Indianapolis Colts and new Browns, and the franchise is a model of success, and much of the credit must go to Tagliabue for his overall achievements in the league. Would any of us care if we had a Baltimore NHL team? who really misses the Bullets? Not as many who missed football, and it is because of the quality of the league which Tagliabue helped create. As far as his supposed arrogance, there is a Super Bowl winning coach in his seventh season at One Winning Drive burdened with the same plight.

Tagliabue told Baltimore to build a museum. Well, what do you put in a museum?
Art. So we went out and got Art, and he brought his team with him from Cleveland.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the letter "y" in the field below: