baltimoresun.com

« Hauschka blames himself | Main | Practice notes »

November 12, 2009

Does a quarterback have to be vocal and outgoing on gameday to lead?

Flacco%20arms%20crossed.jpg

One of my favorite Joe Flacco moments of his young career came earlier this year, and it had nothing to do with his play on the field. Flacco just so happened to show up as a surprise guest on Terrell Suggs' WBAL radio show, an appearence that was the result of repeated badgering from Suggs. Suggs, as most of us know, is one of the funniest, most playful players in the Ravens locker room. He understands the media game, and seems to enjoy it. He gives candid answers and makes people laugh, so in many ways, he's perfect for radio. On this particular night, however, it was Flacco who made me laugh with his deadpan answer to one of Suggs' questions. I'm not going to put it quotes because I don't remember the exact exchange, but it went something close to this:

How come there isn't a Joe Flacco reality show? Suggs asked. We need to sign a deal for you so people can see the real you!

That sounds like the most boring show ever, Flacco responded.

In a sentence, that's the Ravens second-year quarterback. Laid-back and chill, funny but not outwardly so. It seems to be one of his greatest strengths as an athlete. Even on those rare times when his heart might be racing, it looks like he could be reading a book. He is the ying to Ray Lewis' yang. You'll see Flacco on American Idol before you'll see him jump up and down and thump his chest, or scream encouragement in a teammate's face.

I think we're still not sure what to make of this. It's human nature to try and read body language, and sports writers (perhaps foolishly) do it as much as anyone. But fans do it too. We've been trained over the years to have certain expectations for athleltes, especially quarterbacks, who are supposed to lead. We want them to be angry when things aren't going well. We want them to bark at their teammates when someone screws up and lead their team to victory through sheer force of will. We feel confident calling Ray Lewis and Peyton Manning and Tom Brady leaders because we can physically see them barking out orders and gesturing like generals every Sunday.

That's simply not who Flacco is, and it clearly perplexes some people. It seems like every week after a loss, some media member asks him if he feels compelled to "take a more vocal role" in what's going on with the offense. His answer never varies: Not really, because that's not really my personality.

So the natural question becomes: Does that matter?

Does Flacco have to become that person just to match our expectations? Because I admit, those thoughts crossed my mind watching him during the Ravens loss to the Bengals. Why does his body language seem so passive at times? Would it make a difference if he got outwardly angry? Or was I just buying into a myth about leadership? After all, these are professional athletes. Why do we assume they need someone out there to play General Patton?

When I asked Flacco about it, he gave what I thought was an interesting answer:

"There is definitely a time for it, but if I just did it out of nowhere, I think [teammates] would feel like it wasn't real," Flacco said. "I'm not like that. There are times when I'll say things to people, but I don't need to make it known to the public that things are going on. That's not the way I am and it's not the way I'm going to be. My job is to lead these guys and get them to play well, and make everybody play better, and myself better, than we actually are. The bottom line is we didn't do that on Sunday."

Eli Manning had to deal with some the same concerns from fans and from the media early in his career, the idea that he wasn't showing us he wanted it badly enough, and that he was being pushed around by dominant personalities like Jeremy Shockey. (The New York tabloids love to push the angle that a player isn't earning his paycheck if he's not pumping his fist and imploring those around him to follow his lead.) But Manning seemed to prove that was mostly nonsense during the Giants Super Bowl season. Just because someone doesn't put on a theatrical show for us doesn't mean he's not respected or inspirational in times of doubt.

It's probably a little foolish to blame the Ravens recent slow starts on something as ridiculous as Flacco's slumped shoudlers when he's walking to the sidelines after a first quarter three-and-out. But this is going to be his team going forward, especially in years to come, and players are going to look to him in times of doubt.

Does it matter that he doesn't want to hoot and holler with the cameras on him, and would prefer to just play?

The next eight games might provide us with the best answer.

Posted by Kevin Van Valkenburg at 1:23 PM | | Comments (5)
        

Comments

Since you have obviously misremembered all that outstanding teaching you received in communications class, allow me to illiterate: body language and posture are just as, perhaps even more, powerful than verbal communication. It is instinctual for human beings to read non-verbal communication to assess the auditory communication and putit into context.
Your professor thanks me in advance.
Flacco played like crap on Sunday and every game in which the Ravens get less than 30% on 3rd down conversions in the first half, the team has lost. He needs to read How to Win Friends and Influence People before the 2010 season. It should help Flacco lead the Ravens against all the other 3rd place teams they'll be playing :-(

This is an excellent question to ponder and I've podered it a bunch myself regarding QB's and coaches alike (Tony Dungy - I'm lookin at you).

I played football for 8 years and I loved the Ray Lewis types - I loved to scream and yell and get fired up - but some guys most certainly do not, and that doesn't hurt anything a bit.

Because in the end, true leadership comes from a guy who you know is going to do his job. Nobody cares much about a teammate's personality when the ball is about to be snapped. All they care about is whether or not you're going to do your job.

If you will, then guys believe in you, and of course they naturally believe in themselves - so everybody is inspired to do their jobs to the very best of their ability - and that's what makes a great leader and a great team.

Twitter @GridironGeneral

Well Johnny U wasn't a chest thumper and he didn't do too bad.

I would like to point towards two Baltimore quarterbacks who were all-time great field generals and leaders.

John Unitas and Steve McNair.

Both inspired supreme confidence from their teammates, and lead their teams through times and doubt.

Neither of them raised their voices or scowled their eyes in doing so.

Joe will grow into his leadership role with this team. So long as he stays true to who he is, he will be just fine.

Joe is fine. He had a bad day, the team had a bad day, geeze the city of Baltimore had a bad day.

He's a pro and he has a burning desire to be good, no not good, the best. He's pretty young and in truth still inexperienced. He'll bounce back and he is the leader of the offense. Sometimes its not what you say its what you do. Joe will lead with his play.

Heck he's already about 5x better then anybody expected. Lighten up.

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "t" in the field below:
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
Top stories
Mike Preston's columns
Welcome to The Baltimore Sun's Ravens game story database. Use the search prompts below for access to Baltimore Sun stories for every game in Ravens history.

Buy Sports Tickets from the Baltimore Sun Store

Photo galleries
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com sports blogs  Subscribe to this feed
Stay connected