Kevin Van Valkenburg's post-game analysis of the Saints' 31-17 Super Bowl victory over the Colts.
1. The rush to anoint Peyton Manning as the "Greatest Quarterback Ever" -- especially by some of my brethren -- may have been a bit premature.
First off, Manning didn't lose this game on his own. Let's get that out of the way right up front. The Saints won it, and they did it with some incredibly gutsy calls and a perfect second-half game plan. I've always loved Drew Brees, always thought he got a raw deal in San Diego, so to see him get a Super Bowl trophy felt pretty good. He's proof that as long as you're accurate and you can read defenses, you don't have to be 6-foot-5 and have a Howitzer for an arm. (Although it sure would be nice to see what Joe Flacco could do with wide receivers that big and strong.)
But this Super Bowl will almost certainly be remembered as the one Manning didn't win. Manning was clearly the MVP of the NFL this season, and the Colts wouldn't have sniffed the playoffs without him, much less appeared in the Super Bowl. But the way people were talking about him the last two weeks was shocking, especially when you consider that his entire post-season reputation hinges on what happened in 2006, when he beat a Bears team led by Rex Grossman in a rain-soaked mess. (And he didn't even play that well, despite being named the game's MVP.) In fact, if Bill Belichick hadn't decided to force Tom Brady to play that season with junior varsity wide receivers, I'm convinced Manning wouldn't have even made it to that Super Bowl.
The facts don't lie. Manning's career playoff record is now 9-9. Now, maybe it's unfair to put all of that on him, but I'll go to my grave insisting that if you're going to go down as the best that's ever played the game, you can't throw a fourth-quarter interception in the Super Bowl when your team has a chance to tie the game. That's the kind of play that plagued Manning in every big game in college, and in playoff losses to the Steelers, Chargers and Patriots. In some ways, the Colts are turning into the Atlanta Braves of the NFL. They've accomplished so much during the past decade, but they have just one Super Bowl trophy to show for it.
In three of Tom Brady's Super Bowls, he drove the ball down the field late in the game and put his team in position to win. (Twice it did result in a win, against the Rams and Panthers. The third time, against the Giants, he left a little too much time on the clock, and David Tyree and Eli Manning pulled off a miracle.) Ben Roethlisberger drove his team for the winning touchdown in his second Super Bowl. These iconic moments matter in sports, no matter how many times number crunchers and stat heads tell you they don't. People are merciless on Brett Favre for his playoff shortcomings, and yet he and Manning have the exact same number of rings.
It's a tough subject to dance around because Manning is almost everything you'd want as an athlete. He's studious, humble, he doesn't take himself too seriously and he's never been in trouble with the law. Doesn't matter what your background is, or where you're from, if your kid grew up idolizing Peyton Manning, you'd feel good about it. But strictly from a performance standpoint, I think it's fair to ask: Can we really anoint him as the best quarterback ever, even if he holds every NFL record when he's finished, when he repeatedly comes up small in big moments?
Continue reading "5 Things We Learned From The Super Bowl" »