« Was it girls? Or was it grills? Swimming odds and ends from Omaha | Main | Ain't no place like a home »

In sports, not everyone deserves a trophy. And that's a good thing.

One of my favorite things about sports is also one of the cruelest things about sports.

Not everyone goes home a winner.

In order for there to be joy, there has to be anguish. In order for an athlete to be thrilled by his or her sense of accomplishment, another athlete has to feel devastated. It is the natural order of competition, and it is also, in many respects, a metaphor for what drives us as a country.

You see it play out every year at the Olympic trials in every sport. For four years, American swimmer Brendan Hansen was the best 200-meter breaststroker in the world. But on Thursday night, for whatever reason, he swam like he was wearing lead flippers, finishing fourth in the final. He'll still swim at the Olympics in the 100-meter breaststroke, but he'll watch his best event on television or from a spot in the stands.

Hansen doesn't find this twist of fate unfair. He won't be lobbying the U.S. Olympic team to make an exception for him based on past performance, and he won't hire a lawyer to file an injunction. He said he'll simply do all that he can to help the two American men who will swim the event in Beijing -- Scott Spann and Eric Shanteau -- win gold.

One of the hard truths most sane people figure out about life is that not everyone deserves to be an all-star. Not everyone should get into Harvard or win a Pulitzer. Cutthroat competition is a good thing, which is why it's so absurd that more and more Little Leagues are eliminating all-star games (like the community of Beachwood, Ohio did recently) or deciding not to keep score, hoping to avoid bruised egos or crazed parents. 

No one can stand the lunatic t-ball manager who coaches a group of 6-year-olds the way Gen. Patton strategized against the Germans, especially me, but on the other side of the coin, there are also important lessons to be taught in winning and losing.

Contrary to the way certain youth leagues are trending these days, not everyone deserves a trophy, and not everyone deserves equal playing time. No one's life is going to be ruined if they're left off an all-county or an all-Metro team. In fact, it might just make them that much more determined to succeed in life and prove the rest of the world wrong.

At every newspaper I've ever worked for, we've gotten calls and emails from angry parents demanding to know why we don't cover junior varsity sports. Or Little League games. "They work just as hard as everyone else," these complaints often mention. "Why can't you mention their names?"

Because, I usually answer, what they are doing is not news. It is, without question, valuable and important and an essential part of the grand experiment we call "community" but that doesn't necessarily mean it's news.

Olympic swimmer Matt Biondi, who won 11 medals during his career -- but is now a math teacher, a coach and a dad -- said something yesterday at the trials that really made sense to me when I think about sports, especially as it relates to kids.

"So many adults want their kids to feel good, so they send them places or buy them things," Biondi said. "They prop them up with value judgments like 'You're such a good boy' or 'You're such a pretty girl.' I realized very early on what kids really want is what's most valuable to you, and that's your time."

Some of the most important moments in my life came when I failed to make a team or earn a scholarship and people didn't make excuses for me. I still remember the score of the football state championship game that I played in and lost: 39-13. I wish I had played better, but I know that failure inspired me to become a better person.

Struggling can be a good thing. Disappointment can be devastating, whether it comes at a young age or if it comes, like Hansen, after four years of swimming laps at 6 a.m. with the goal of making the Olympic team.

The way you deal with it, both in athletic competition and in life, is how we define character.

Hansen photo: AP 

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.trb.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-t.cgi/79751

Comments

Great column. Should be required reading for all manner of folks.

Amen!
At the little league level, when kids are in the earliest stage of the sport, I would encourage not keeping score but once the basics have been taught, winning & losing is part of character growth.

At the youngest levels, they don't often know or care. the first softball game I coached when my daughter was a 4th grader we got beat 26-0 in our first game. 2 of the girls came up & asked if we won not seeming to care. I responded "did you have fun today?" they said yes, so I told them they had a winning day and they never thought twice about it. 6 of those girls went on to be all county players in high school.

A-freakin-men!
Kids that go through their childhood getting rewards and tributes for mediocre results are going to be in for a very pointed surprise once they leave the nest and enter the real world.

Better to learn to win with grace and lose with dignity, at an early age.

The only thing I disagree with is the statement about playing time. I have come full circle on this issue as a youth coach (which I have done a lot of and have always been successful in the win column). Kids need to play to develop and until they hit puberty it is impossible to tell which kids are going to end up being the best players. I think it does a huge disservice to a kid to relegate him or her to the bench with minimal playing time. I've seen kids with huge raw ability but limited skills (e.g. stick handling in lacrosse) relegated to the bench only to give up the sport. At the same time, I've seen many "stars" who play all the time at young ages, but never grow that much and end up being too small or too slow to be one of the better players at an older age.

For in-house teams, every kid absolultely should get to play at least half the time. For travel or other select teams, that should be a goal, but not a hard-and-fast rule. What I ended up doing on travel teams was just not keep a kid on the team if I was not going to be comfortable playing him a significant amount of the time. Sometimes numbers preclude you from keeping an entire team of accomplished players, but, even in those circumstances, a good coach will find a way to get every player involved to some significant extent. I have found over the years that the best teams are the ones that find a way to get something out of everyone.

While I agree with almost everything you said and agree that there are good life lessons in winning and (especially) losing, the fact is that winning should never take precedence over giving each kid the opportunity to do his or her best, develop and learn. They all have to play to do these things.

Helloooo? Have you forgotten about your blog? Or are you blogging elsewhere now?

I just caught your local pride video piece from the Great Wall of China. Ya know, when you're doing something like that for the BALTIMORE Sun, to make the locals bubble with pride over their hometown hero, you should probably consider NOT wearing a Boston Red Sox cap. It really deflates the local pride aspect of the video, which is really its only intent. I'm not saying you have to be an Orioles fan, but should you probably pretend to be one if you're going to write for the Sports section of the Baltimorean paper of record.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the letter "n" in the field below:
About the blogger
Kevin Van Valkenburg is a Montana native who has worked for The Baltimore Sun since 2000. He played football in college, albeit poorly and briefly. Since joining the Sun, he has covered everything from college football to figure skating to swimming in Australia. He likes cold beer, songs about broken hearts, the television show The Wire, hitting a 2-iron off the tee, and literature that keeps you up late at night. In 2005, a piece he wrote for the Sun was anthologized in the Best American Sports Writing series. He and his wife, Jen, live in Hampden and consider Natty Bohs, tater tots and turkey burgers from the Golden West to be the perfect meal.

About this blog
Most Recent Comments
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Photo galleries
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com sports blogs  Subscribe to this feed