by Frank James
Sen. John McCain was the first of the remaining three presidential candidates to get a crack at Gen. David Petraeus and Ambassador Ryan Crocker today, as the highest ranking Republican on the Senate Armed Services Committee.
McCain's opening statement distilled points he's made on the campaign trail in recent weeks and months, mainly that there's been progress in the security situation in Iraq and that it would be a critical strategic mistake for the U.S. to withdraw its forces from Iraq as his Democratic rivals, Senators Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton have advocated.
In his questions to Petraeus and Crocker, McCain sounded very much like a commander-in-chief asking his top field commander for a battlefield assessment. That likely was no accident on McCain's part.
But unlike some of his fellow Republicans, McCain also was clearly critical of problems in Iraq. McCain has campaigned heavily on having opposed many aspects of how the Bush Administration conducted the war before the U.S. security surge began last year. His questions today suggested he planned to keep a certain distance from President Bush on Iraq.
For instance, McCain picked up on a line of questioning stated by Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman Carl Levin's who asked Petraeus about reports that the recent Basra violence triggered by the Iraqi government's assault on Shiite forces there was a precipitous action by Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki which caught U.S. officials by surprise.
The senator from Arizona, the winner of the Republican presidential primaries, also asked about the failure of 1,000 of the Iraqi security forces to persevere in that fighting; about al Qaeda in Iraq, and recent attacks on the Green Zone, home to the U.S. embassy.
Here's McCain's exchange with Petraeus and Crocker.
SEN. MCCAIN: General Petraeus, again, news reports said that Prime Minister Maliki only informed you shortly before the operation -- is that correct -- in Basra?
GEN. PETRAEUS: It is, Senator. We had a heads-up in a Friday night meeting where we in fact were planning to resource operations in Basra on a longer-term basis. The following Saturday we had a meeting during which he laid out the plan that he was going to deploy forces,laid out the objectives, the lines of operations that he was going to operate along, and stated that he was moving there on Friday himself -- or on Monday himself.
SEN. MCCAIN: And it was not something that you had recommended.
GEN. PETRAEUS: It was not something I recommended, no, sir.
SEN. MCCAIN: News reports indicate that over a thousand Iraqi army and police deserted or underperformed during that operation. This is four months after Basra achieved provincial Iraqi control, meaning that all provincial security had been transferred to Iraqi security forces. What's the lesson that we're to draw from that, that a thousand Iraqi army and police deserted or underperformed?