baltimoresun.com

« Jon Cardin could start new business | Main | The oldest living Martin employe »

Speed cameras: Welcome to the debate

TODAY ON RADIO 88.1 FM  WYPR  WYPO  WYPF  

LISTEN LIVE     RODRICKS FACEBOOK    

TWITTER MIDDAYRODRICKS

 

12:00-1:00 pm Eastern: Is the labor movement finished? We'll talk with journalist Philip Dine about the state of the unions and whether organized labor can gain any traction during the recession..

1:00-2:00 pm: Are speed cameras "Big Brother run amok," or simply a necessary public safety measure?  We'll weigh the pros and cons of using this technology for law enforcement with Dan Morhaim, the emergency room physician and member of the Maryland House of Delegates from Baltimore County, and Dave Schwartz, director of the Maryland state chapter of the conservative Americans for Prosperity.


Comments or questions: 
midday@wypr.org

Posted by Dan Rodricks at 7:43 AM | | Comments (4)
        

Comments

Please ask Dr. Morhaim what traffic safety measures the legislature has considered that don't involve the state receiving revenue from citizens, and whether, in an economic environment where 1 out of every 10 eligible workers is unemployed and many more are underemployed, such measures might be preferable to, never mind more effective than, speed cameras.

* The registered owner is the driver only 72% of the time, so the wrong person is cited more than 1 in 4 times! If the police arrested the wrong person that often, there would be outrage, but evidently if it's just a speeding fine no one cares if the wrong person gets cited that often.
* Cameras malfunction and issue erroneous citations. The sensitive electronics and sensors are exposed to the element and heat and cold 24/7. The vendors will NOT publish their accuracy and error rates!
* There is no regular proposed government oversight or routine audit program to ensure the contractor is honest and equipment is working properly. They have said that once per year a third party will check them. That is not sufficient. Why can't the police check them more often? What about auditing the vendor and the process?
* There have been no engineering studies done in "problem locations" to determine if lack of enforcement really is the cause of accidents. For that matter, the city has been lax in providing stats about the number of *injuries* and *fatalities* caused by exceeding the posted limit in these school areas. Are they even needed?
* The effectiveness of sending a ticket to someone weeks after they've done something is also very ineffective. Try punishing your kids two weeks after they do something wrong and see how that works.
* Lots of people are exempt from these machines, and they are easy to avoid: People who tow trailers, have bike or wheelchair racks, or temp plates, or other plate obstructions or covers renders them immune to photo enforcement.
* Equipment vendors such as Redflex are dishonest and have been caught falsifying court documents, using uncertified equipment, and shortening yellow lights.
* Some studies show that injuries and fatalities INCREASE where cameras are installed.

A person who speeds through a residential area or school zone has no regard for others, not even children. Nothing will slow him except the likelihood that he will be caught and punished. Without speed cameras, there is no such likelihood, so the speeding continues.

Patrick K. Lackey

We should put cameras everywhere and watch everybody at all times. Crime would vanish and society would be much safer, especially for children.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Please enter the letter "s" in the field below:
About Dan Rodricks
Jan. 8, 2009, marked 30 years for Dan Rodricks' column in The Baltimore Sun. Over three decades, Dan has won numerous regional and several national awards for his reporting and commentary -- in print and on the air. "I've had opportunity to write a column and work in both radio and television, never having to leave my adopted hometown of Baltimore to have those experiences," he says. "I consider myself very fortunate." In addition to writing a twice-weekly column for The Baltimore Sun and his Random Rodricks blog, Dan is currently the host of Midday, on WYPR-FM, National Public Radio in Baltimore. An artful story-teller and social critic, he has observed local, state and national political and cultural trends for three decades, and has a lot to say about almost everything.
More on Dan Rodricks
Dan's Facebook page


Midday with Dan Rodricks
Follow @middayrodricks on Twitter
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Dan Rodricks' columns
Recent columns Rodricks talks about his column on NPR
Dear drug dealers
Dan Rodricks' campaign to help Baltimore residents "get out of the game."
Most Recent Comments
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com news blogs
 Subscribe to this feed