Stop Hitting Kids!
A reader in Towson, who found herself in the same situation I've been in a few times -- and that of many other people -- wonders what to do:
I am a disabled person, and as such, I rely on MTA to travel about.
At the end of last week, I was on a bus where I observed reprehensible behavior, to which I responded with deep sadness. I felt so powerless.
I noticed a young mother, with a young child (he was perhaps 2, 2 1/2 years old).
They had just gotten on the bus, and were finding their seats.
The next thing I heard was a terrible smacking sound; the mother yelled at her child:
"You are not going to tell me where to sit"; and then, when the young boy began to cry, the Mother yelled at him, "Shut Up".
I felt so powerless.
I felt so terrible that the young boy was the object of his mother's rage. Could she have stopped before she lashed out at her son?
I know that you have written about scenes such as this that you have witnessed. What can we do as individuals? What can we do as citizens? How do we protect the children in our City from being hurt? How can we protect the Children of Our World?
As silly as it sounds (?), maybe there is a pressing need for Parent Education; i.e. a course of instruction that reaches every mother (and father) who become pregnant, who visit their doctor.
Could/would this help?
I am a person who grew up in a damaged home. My parents were both mentally ill, and my brother and I had to make sense of a world that made no sense. I have spent a lifetime digging out from the rubble of my Mother's self-hatred and my Father's ignorance and neglect.
I weep for children who are mistreated like this young child on the bus.
So much goes on in this world. So much.
How can we change this world? I suppose, One Child At a Time.
I wished I could have said something to the young, troubled mother. Did she know how
she was hurting her son? Would my words have inflamed her more?
I weep when I see an innocent child like this being hurt.
Here's what I say: I say speak up when you see this.
Nothing good comes of hitting kids. Parents teach with their words and deeds. When they
slap a child, they teach violence, and the person who does it in public is
doing much more in private.
Parents think they have a right to beat children - they call it "spanking"
- after they have failed as adults to correct behaviors, or when they are
drunk or high, or when they are tired and angry, or when they just feel like
it. Many adults think it's just fine because they either do it themselves or
because they had the same experience when they were kids. And, in the great
denial that marks human existence, they don't see the
harm in it.
And let's face it: We're jaded. We're suckers for the belief that human
beings will never change, that we are doomed to living with the cancer of
ignorance and violence.
The streets and prisons are full of men and women who were abused as
children, but that fact doesn't stop us from abiding the mistreatment of more
children - either at the hands of their relatives or at the hands of a society
that denies them real opportunities and a chance to rise above poverty and
mediocrity.
In some ways, believing that humans will never change - or that there's
nothing we can do about violence, that it's just in our nature - is
comforting. It means you can live your life and keep your mouth shut. "Mind
your own business!"
I say that's no way to live.
Excuse me for rambling and spouting off.
But I am sick of the cycles - of addictions, violence, stupidity and failure. We can't give up. We have to do what we can do, in our own little corner of the world, while we still have time. We have to speak up.







Comments
Felt a strong need to reply to this post. Wish I had more time to spend on it.
According to endcorporalpunishment.org, these nations have laws against hitting children at home, in schools, or in disciplinary facilities or alternative care settings:
Austria, Bulgaria, Chile, Croatia, Cyrpus, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Greece,
Hungary, Iceland, Israel, Latvia, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Romania
There are of course many, many social and political reasons why USA is not on that list. I think we should be.
I think Parent Education, including how to discipline and shape your child's behavior without hitting, should be taught in schools.
If all your parents ever did was hit you, that's all you'll have in your toolbox.
I too have seen parents hit children on the bus and in other public places, and it always upsets me. I never speak up, because I'm sure I'd be told to mind my own business, but maybe I should start.
I know that life is often unimaginably hard for some of these parents. Having access to a better network of social services, including federalized healthcare, would help. There is more to lifting children up than just making sure they pass standardized tests.
Posted by: A Baltimore Mom | September 23, 2008 1:30 PM
As a former Child Protection worker in Baltimore City I can attest to the devestating impact that physical and verbal abuse has on young children. At an early age they begin to act out in the schools and in the community. Later, usually by the age of 14/15 they become involved in the juvenile court system, where they will be passed through without the help that they need to learn that violence is not acceptable in society. By the age of 16/18 they are time bombs waiting to explode on us, society, who failed to protect them in the first place. When will we as a society begin to address this issue?
Posted by: mary pizzica | September 25, 2008 5:56 AM
I'd rather see parents spank children than let them get away with murder (literally, in our city).
I grew up behaving with manners in public, I respected my elders and teachers, I respected strangers and their property. Why? Because as a child, if I was told to behave a certain way two or three times and did not listen, I would get spanked. I knew that. I wasn't dumb. Didn't take many times for me to listen the first time I was told.
I'm not saying spanking is the only option, but when a child refuses to listen, it should be used as a last resort.
I am sick to death of seeing:
kids hitting their parents
kids crawling through restaurants on the floor
kids getting what they want because they throw a temper tantrum
kids disrespecting teachers, law enforcement, and the public in general
kids having no respect for other people's property
And I'm sorry, but a "Now don't do that" in that sickening sweet voice just doesn't cut it.
Posted by: CH | September 25, 2008 7:01 AM
Parents who hit their children rely on violence to deal with adversity. Hence, if confronted by me, it would be reasonable to expect I too would be dealt with by them via the use of violence. It's great to preach about standing up but our judicial, legal and law enforcement systems make it unlikely I will be fairly treated when I become these tyrants' next victim.
Rather, I suspect I will be blamed for escalating the matter and possibly charged with some crime for protecting myself.
Posted by: greg | September 25, 2008 8:29 AM
I am in no way shape or form in support of spanking young children. I think that from the age of 2-5, tapping them with two fingers on the hand as a last option after telling them to stop is the best way possible to let them know who is the parent and who is the child. You see so many children if not on the bus in public telling the parents what to do or acting like they are in the jungle it is ridiculous.
Posted by: D | September 25, 2008 8:40 AM