There were many responses to yesterday's column. Here are three that are representative of the mail.
Your column today was bitter, and I agree with every word of it. I saw
the Bush interview with Jim Lehrer and was sickened by the reply Bush
made about people suffering while watching the war news on TV. I am 77;
I hope the day comes when I can stand up and say I'm proud again of this
country. Where are the protesters? Who really cares? Well, I do. I
have grandchildren coming to their teens. I want them to be as proud of
their country as I was at their age. Forgive my rambling.
Genevieve
I'm not in college anymore (3 years out), but while I was there
continuing through today I've had friends that have served in Iraq.
One took Falujah the first time and then re-took it. Two are
currently there and one just returned. You do no service to yourself
or the Baltimore Sun saying college kids don't care. The college kids
I knew cared and had friends there. You have that tendency to say
that one nugget of information must represent the whole and that is a
dangerous precedent in my opinion.
Sincerely,
Bryan Shuy
Mr. Rodricks,
I am relieved that someone finally spoke their mind about the growing
trend in materialistic affluence affecting the 20-30 and even early 40
something's in this country. Two ideas in your article was of particular
interest to me; first which I agree with, is the idea that there is a
growing divide in our culture, the military vs. the civilian and the
spinoffs of that idea. The second idea I don't agree completely with
you, but you're not far off. Its the idea that the affluent and
privileged aren't recruited and actually join the military.
As per the first, I really related to your idea of looking out of a
HMMWV (High Mobility Multi Wheeled Vehicle) and seeing the Iraqi
landscape or the Beltway. But however, lets take a lesson from politics
that most colleges, including my own, adopt but hypocritically do not
exercise. It could be summarized 'hate, love, but love America's
Soldier's." This my friend, is bullshit. I went to Saint Michael's
College of Colchester, Vermont probably the most liberal "hippie" campus
in the nation, and my entire career I was constantly supported, but when
I was taking bids to anyone to receive my blog (more like periodic e
mails) I had 2 responses, out of 200 "friends". I think its true in
America that people say what others are saying and generally never have
a true original thought, and unless they are forced to live it, as the
Vietnam generation, then they won't care, as evident in the apathy
towards the violence in Iraq. There will be no rallies, no protests, no
petitions, no one getting arrested for non-violent social disobedience,
simply because it does not affect them. We have a very bad tendency, in
liberal arts education, to say we study the past to shape the
future, but then only use it to aggrandize our positions in life and
chastise those who are the difference makers, my Soldiers.
That brings me to my second point, the targeting of the least privileged
amongst us. I don't know if this is true or not, but judging by the
superior character both intellectually and morally from the more than
soldiers I am responsible for managing, I think I have the cream of
the crop. My soldiers, some on their third tour in Iraq, travel the
streets, conduct force protection, execute missions on a moments notice
and never question orders. Granted these soldiers may not come from
privileged backgrounds, but I have to ask you, who do you think is
better, the one who is making something of their lives AND IS OUR
NATIONAL REPRESENTATION THROUGH NATION BUILDING, or someone who was born
with a silver spoon in their mouths? Mr. Rodricks, I think if one
compares an 18-year-old Harvard physics major to an 18-year-old 11B
Infantryman walking through Mosul (the most dangerous city in Iraq),
there is no comparison. Doing is different from criticizing, and to me, I want the people who stand up and do by my side and not those who are the affluent.
I may be the prime example of two American cultures, but I want you and
all of our fellow Baltimoreans (I am from Dundalk) that even though our best and brightest
academic's and elected officials are squabbling about the best course of
action in Iraq, my soldiers simply say "If can and I will and if I
can't, I will figure it out." Don't you worry Mr. Rodricks, our Country
is in good hands, even if it appears that those hands belong to the poor
and uneducated.
1st LT Jason McLaughlin