baltimoresun.com

« Cummings to discuss security at Old Dominion | Main | Baltimore County school board task force appointed »

June 20, 2011

City Councilwoman signed doc calling county home "primary residence"

A Baltimore City Councilwoman who is suing a local blogger for reporting that she “does not reside” in the city signed a document last year certifying that her primary residence was in Baltimore County.

Councilwoman Belinda Conaway, who lists her father’s Northwest Baltimore home on city documents as her official residence, signed a mortgage agreement last year indicating that the house she bought in Randallstown in 1997 was her primary residence.

Conaway joined the City Council in 2004.

Contacted for a response on Monday, Conaway said: “You know I can't talk about that” and referred questions to her lawyer.

Attorney Thomas J. Maronick Jr. said the councilwoman and her husband signed the document “inadvertently.”

“They shouldn’t have signed it,” Maronick said. He said the couple “didn’t look very carefully” at the papers and called the signing an “oversight.”

“It’s not unusual for people at a real estate settlement to sign documents without reading them carefully,” Maronick said. “There was no attempt whatsoever to defraud anyone.”

Conaway filed a $21 million lawsuit against blogger Adam Meister and the Examiner news organization last month after Meister posted copies of Conaway’s property records online and wrote that she “should immediately resign from Baltimore's City Council since she does not reside in Baltimore.”

In her lawsuit, Conaway claims the posts were libelous, defamatory and intentionally inflicted emotional distress because she “does in fact live in Baltimore City.”

Meister said Monday that a major law firm had agreed to defend him pro bono. He declined to name the firm publicly.

He said he planned to file a motion to dismiss “because the suit inhibits free speech.” He declined to comment further, on the advice of his lawyer.

Conaway is not the only City Council member whose residency has sparked questions.

Councilman Rochelle “Rikki” Spector, who represents Northwest Baltimore, says she has lived in her boyfriend’s Inner Harbor condominium for years. She says she maintains a residence in her district.

Councilman William “Pete” Welch lists his campaign office as his official address, but says he actually lives with his mother at another home in his district.

Councilman Warren Branch lists his mother’s address on official records and says he stays there once a week, but spends most of his time with his girlfriend and their three children at a different address in his district.

Council President Bernard C. “Jack” Young lists one East Baltimore home as his official address, but he says he actually lives around the corner. Young owned a home until 2005 in the Harford County neighborhood of Edgewood. He called it a “vacation home.”

Shortly after he became council president last year, Young led reporters on a tour of the home where he spends most of time. He pulled fistfuls of clothing from drawers, saying, “Do you want to see my damn underwear?”

State law grants elected officials wide latitude in declaring an official address.

In 1998, a court ordered hen-state Senate Majority Leader Clarence W. Blount off the ballot after a private detective showed that he lived primarily in Pikesville, not the Northwest Baltimore neighborhood he was elected to represent. But a Court of Special Appeals judge overturned the ruling.

“The requirement is that one must be domiciled in the district, and domicile is not synonymous with primary place of abode,” Judge John C. Eldridge wrote in his opinion.

The latest documents, posted last week by the website Baltileaks, indicate that Conaway and her husband received an $8,700 line of credit from the Municipal Employee Credit Union of Baltimore on the Randallstown home in January 2010.

The couple signed a statement ‘Under oath and penalties of perjury’ affirming that the Randallstown home “is his/ her / their principal place of residence,” according to the documents, which are posted on a state land records website.

Maronick said that Conaway and her husband, Milton D. Washington, purchased the home in the 9800 block of Southall Road in Randallstown in 1997 and lived there “briefly” with their two children and her mother.

Soon afterward, Maronick said, Conaway moved to her father’s spacious home in the 3200 block of Liberty Heights Avenue in the city, which is closer to her son’s school.

Maronick said Conaway’s mother and Washington live in the Randallstown home.

Baltimore County tax records indicate that Conaway and her husband sought and received a $708 Homestead Tax Credit for the Randallstown home last year.

Maronick said that Conaway would pay back any tax credit that was received improperly.

When a reporter visited the Randallstown home last month, an elderly woman answered the door, shook her head silently and shut the door.

Neighbors reported seeing an elderly woman at the tidy brick home, and occasional visits from relatives.

“I’ve seen an older lady tending to her flowers,” said Laura Blanks, who lives on the other side of the quiet suburban street. “Her roses are beautiful.”

Conaway’s father, Clerk of Courts Frank M. Conaway Sr., her stepmother, Register of Wills Mary Conaway, and brother Del. Frank M. Conaway Jr. all claim the Liberty Heights home as their official residence.

Conaway's husband and her 13-year-old son were at the large brick home on Liberty Heights Avenue across from Hanlon Park when a reporter dropped by last month.

Conaway's father said that his daughter's family occupied one wing of the 17-room home.

“This house has two sides to it and they live on one side,” he said.

Conaway urged his grandson, Xavier Washington, to speak to a reporter.

“I live here,” Xavier said. “I just go there sometimes to visit my grandmother.”

Posted by Julie Scharper at 9:53 AM | | Comments (36)
Categories: City Hall
        

Comments

So the Councilwoman seems to have violated the law and decides to sue those exposing her for violating the law? Yes, Baltimore politics at its finest! So glad I don't live there. My big question is the use of the married name versus unmarried name--does that imply she's claiming two different Homestead credits? Or was I reading into it too much?

What about Rikki Spector? She did the exact same thing as Conoway.

Isn't this tax fraud?

This is far from new in Baltimore, just think about former State Sen Della who lived out in Carroll county and represented south/southeast Baltimore. The good news is that the voters in that district aren't as dumb as the politicians would like to believe, and when he was exposed he lost the election to a complete newcomer who lived in the area.

Lets hope that people in Conaway's district are smart enough to know that when you have to ask if she lives in the area - she doesn't, and use their vote to put someone else in office who lives in and cares about their community.

It's about time that this is starting to get some coverage from the Sun. Conaway seems to be caught red handed and her response is to sue those that exposed her? It seems she is either guilty of tax fraud or some sort of elections fraud for not living within her own district. Either way, it seems like the same old Baltimore politics. It's about time someone cleans it up and it's a shame that it takes a blogger to do the investigations to bring these crooked politicians back down to Earth.

The Conaway family is an embarassment and continues to suckle at the public teat with no visible benefit to the citizens of Baltimore. Frank Conaway running for Mayor is a joke. He can't even run the Clerk's office responsibly. When will the citizens of Baltimore wake up and stop electing these freeloading do nothings.

This woman also took donations from a "former reformed" convicted drug dealer to let him open up a bar in her district, these city politicians are ridiculous. She's a scammer and I am tired of letting corrupt politicians people rip everyone off. I hope i dont get sued for this comment ...

yeah, stuff like this only happens in Baltimore. hahaaaa. that's a good one.

I should expect that the State's Attorney's Office for Baltimore City or Baltimore COunty should be bringing her up on perjury charges for either lying on the real estate forms or the election forms asserting her legal address....

Oh wait that won't happen......

Who do you think you are? Pointing out FACTS like this is dangerous and racist.
I noticed that it is nothing but white people who write for this blogg!

I am sorry, I could not resist.

I am so so tired of all of this. Please black/white, rich/poor and dem/rep, please just be honest and tell the truth.

There are many other cases as well. One from the late 1990's was the case of Sen. Blount.
How about this? Mrs. O'Malley serves as a Judge in the District Court in B. City. To be a judge, you have to live in the district where you are serving as a judge. I would assume that she actually lives with the Governor in Annapolis.

I am thinking about running against Rikki Spector. My campaign slogan would be, "At least I actually live here."

The entire Conaway clan needs to be voted out of office!
Same old same old from our Baltimore politicians.
What a joke.

Obviously this was done in very poor taste but should not, by itself, disqualify Conway from holding office. Tons of people list another home as their primary residence for tax purposes, which of course is wrong. Further, nobody has yet to uncover any evidence that Conway lives in that house as oppose to her city address. So it seems to me, the appropriate remedy here is for Conway to pay the back property taxes plus interest and penalties. But the fact remains that this is a city plagued by population loss, and concerns about quality of life issues that have caused hundreds of thousands of people to flock to the suburbs. It is truly unfortunate that someone whom the people of Baltimore City has bestowed their trust in to lead the city, would do anything to even raise the suspicion that she is not a city resident. If the people of Baltimore City are to have complete confidence that Belinda Conway has their best interests at heart, she should sell the Randallstown house at once, and purchase another home in Baltimore City for her mother.

The issue is that signed and legal document saying she lived someplace she didn't and is suing someone for saying what she already said.
On the books from a 1998 Baltimore Court of Appeals Case: Maryland's state legislators don't have to sleep in the electoral districts they represent -- they just have to work for the people who live there, the state's highest court said.
Here is the Baltimore Sun article: http://articles.baltimoresun.com/1998-10-07/news/1998280103_1_blount-domicile-residency-requirement

The female Marion Barry will be absolved of all wrong doing, re--elected, and probably moved up in the pay scale.

Do we need to see a City Council person MURDER someone to get these people back into the zoo where they belong and out of politics?

I have a friend that lives in Joppatowne. He say he still sees Jack Young, the Coucil President, come and go from Jack's Joppatowne residence.

She should be brought up on federal charges. This is not only tax fraud but mortgage fraud. Such offenses are punishable by fines and/or jail.

It's is only tax fraud if you're a Republican.

Yep, just another Baltimore slimball who thinks she is entitles to evade the law.

Well since I live and VOTE in the city and her district - my VOTES will be cast for other people.

So which is it, Belinda? Perjury or tax fraud? And you have the stones to try to sue Adam Meister for reporting the truth?

I guess your only hope is to make this an issue about race and how your poor family are the "victims." You seem to be good at that.

kudos to the blogger!

If you are going to run for an office in Baltimore City be about the city and not yourself. The Conways have been in the city of Baltimore for years. It's time for some honest persons, to do the city some good, and think about the citizens of Baltimore. New blood not double talk.

As Scooby sez: "Ruh ro!"

I live in Harford County, and NO ONE considers Edgewood a "vacation area".

A former police commissioner was brought down for mortgage paperwork discrepancy involving a gift from Dad that was really a loan from Dad (he paid Dad back) when he signed his mortgage docs. If there is any integrity left with Conaway, she should drop her lawsuit immediately and apologize to Meister and the public. Does she do the same (not read documents) when it comes to business involving the city such as bills and laws. Talk about a family living off the public dole..almost all earn their living from gov't jobs. Oh lets not forget the signage at their house promoting the family.

She needs to do the one thing politicians are not good at: stop lying!

She needs to do the one thing politicians are not good at: stop lying! And using a child? Really?

Nothing personal against West Baltimore, but can we really blame these folks for not wanting to sleep there? I guess the reasoning behind "live where you represent" is that you'd be more likely to BETTER represent.

Since she is a public figure, she would have to prove that the statement was untrue and that the blogger was grossly negligent. There is no way they will succeed in their lawsuit. Hope you got paid upfront, Maronick.

Why is this story being buried in the web and print versions? This family is perpetuating a fraud on the city of Baltimore and the Baltimore Sun has the obligation to "shed light" on issues like this. To bury it in the website as a blog entry and on the back of page 2 in the print version is amazing to me. It shows how influential this family is.

JT,

I don't recall Don Dwyer being prosecuted when he committed homestead tax fraud on his Glen Burnie rental property.

Shelia Dixon's defense was "it wasn't theft, it was bribery"

Belinda Conaway gets to choose between fraud and perjury.

All of these city "leaders" are "living" with their parents... hmmmm, maybe that is part of the problem here?

The problem is that if your residence really doesn't matter (and there may be some case law that supports this view), then politicians need to come out and say so, and not have their campaign staff dress up an empty house with a bed where they never sleep. At the very least, the city council needs to publicly clarify whether you can represent a district you don't live in.

One lie leds to another lie which leads to another lie, pretty soon, you don't know the truth and get caught in your own lie. My father taught me this when I was 7 years old.

This is a shame to all of us who happen to live is this beautiful community of Ashburton. We were featured in Baltimore Sun's hidden gems neighborhood article and to have these Conaway lunatics to represent us is a shame. These Conaway dudes are a disgrace to our community, from the so called Papa Bear, to rest of stupid family bears members, I hope coming next election they all should be voted-out from public office. We need fresh blood in Baltimore city politics and let start by disqualifying the Conaway. I urge the intelligent and progressive people of this district to elect a new face to represent us. I know , coming next election I will vote them out. And this goes to all of these politicians who are in office just because of their family name. Let repeat the Obama magic in our district from nowhere, He now seat in the white house. Nepotism should end in the city of Baltimore.

Without clutch, just after several decades of persecution, Al Capone was caught for tax evasion and sentenced to eleven many years in jail. He was transferred to Alcatraz federal prison and was granted just after eight years parole.
healthy sexy hair

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Headlines from The Baltimore Sun
About the bloggers
Annie Linskey covers state politics and government for The Baltimore Sun. Previously, as a City Hall reporter, she wrote about the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon and kept a close eye on city spending. Originally from Connecticut, Annie has also lived in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, where she reported on war crimes tribunals and landmines. She lives in Canton.

John Fritze has covered politics and government at the local, state and federal levels for more than a decade and is now The Baltimore Sun’s Washington correspondent. He previously wrote about Congress for USA TODAY, where he led coverage of the health care overhaul debate and the 2010 election. A native of Albany, N.Y., he currently lives in Montgomery County.

Julie Scharper covers City Hall and Baltimore politics. A native of Baltimore County, she graduated from The Johns Hopkins University in 2001 and spent two years teaching in Honduras before joining The Baltimore Sun. She has followed the Amish community of Nickel Mines, Pa., in the year after a schoolhouse massacre, reported on courts and crime in Anne Arundel County, and chronicled the unique personalities and places of Baltimore City and its surrounding counties.
Most Recent Comments
Sign up for FREE local news alerts
Get free Sun alerts sent to your mobile phone.*
Get free Baltimore Sun mobile alerts
Sign up for local news text alerts

Returning user? Update preferences.
Sign up for more Sun text alerts
*Standard message and data rates apply. Click here for Frequently Asked Questions.
  • Breaking News newsletter
When a big news event breaks, we'll e-mail you the basics with links to up-to-date details.
Sign up

Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com news blogs
 Subscribe to this feed
Charm City Current
Stay connected