baltimoresun.com

« House and Senate breaking - still much to do | Main | Medical marijuana measures head to governor »

April 11, 2011

Senate quashes transgender equality bill

The Senate has ended debate for the year on a bill that would have protected transgendered people from employment, credit and housing discrimination.

"The Senate’s treatment of this legislation will be remembered for a long time by the LGBT community and Marylanders who believe in equal rights for all," Sen. Richard S. Madaleno Jr. wrote in a statement this afternoon. A Montgomery County Democrat and the chamber's only openly gay member, Madaleno vowed to file the legislation again next year.

Del. Joseline Pena-Melnyk, who sponsored the bill, said in an email that she is "greatly disappointed."

"After going through the painstaking process and getting so close to passage of [the bill], the Senate shamefully voted to not even give the bill an up or down vote," the Prince George's County Democrat said. "By this action, the Senate has allowed housing and employment discrimination against a vulnerable community to go unchecked."

A 27-20 vote to send the measure back to a Senate committee capped weeks of fits and starts.

The House of Delegates gave final passage just before the crossover deadline a little over two weeks ago. But in break from protocol, Senate President Thomas V. Mike Miller sent the bill to the Rules Committee, rather than one that directly vets legislation. Rules did end up moving the bill to the Judicial Proceedings Committee, which in turn passed it along to the Senate floor.

Instead of being debated on the floor this morning, Sen. James E. DeGrange, an Anne Arundel County Democrat, asked that it be sent back to Judicial Proceedings. Miller and other Democrats joined 11 of the 12 Senate Republicans in voting to doom the bill. 

Senators were reluctant to debate the controversial issue on the final day of legislative work. Opponents said the legislation might go to far. For example, they said, schools and child care facilities should be exempted so that parents of young children are not forced to contend with questions about gender identity before they are ready to do so. 

Posted by Julie Bykowicz at 6:50 PM | | Comments (30)
Categories: 2011 legislative session
        

Comments

I think these kinds of issues really show what kind of politicians we have in this state -they do not care about people, they only want to tax us and spend our money. Although overly Democratic, this state can't pass any kind of LGBT legislation of any value. Yet, they are still considering tuition breaks for people that aren't even legally in this country and they want to increase the alcohol tax, which only serves to make the middle class and poor in this state poorer. Not to mention they have yet to amend the gambling legislation to allow table games so all of our neighboring states are light-years ahead of us in that revenue department. I'm pretty sure that one day, I will move out of this state because there is just too much political BS instead of common sense.

So in a Democrat controlled state we have a government that pretty much runs as if we were in a Republican state. Seems the above writer is right, if its a tax issue these democrats sure can muscle whatever bills they want to impose through with little or no problem. .... whoops sorry not taxes, I forgot the new word for taxes are increased fees.

Madaleno and Pena-Melnyk really showed their true colors this year. Doesn't seem like they are really interested the morals of our state. Madaleno, I sure hope that the LGBT community remembers that this is a state with some moral integrity that will fight to keep you from moral corruption. I think it is time to bring back the sodomy laws.

Shame on these politicians who cant even find their gonads enough to pass a bill designed to insure Trans people can have a job, contribute to society, and not be living on the street.

And at this point who knows how the hate groups like FRC, AFA, and maybe even NOM were involved. Along with some "anything but" christians, some of whom are trying to pass a "holocaust the gays" bill In Uganda.

This isn't America, it is AmeriKKKa. We should all be ashamed of the situation in our country, while eg Canada has gay marriage, a gun murder rate 1/7 of ours population adjusted, and guarantees its citizens cradel to grave medical care.

Whats the solutiion- a third party? who knows.

But America as it stands is beginning more and more to look like Taliban AmeriKKKa

Shame on all of us who haven't tried to change it. And this includes some democrats as well.

Shame on these politicians who cant even find their gonads enough to pass a bill designed to insure Trans people can have a job, contribute to society, and not be living on the street.

And at this point who knows how the hate groups like FRC, AFA, and maybe even NOM were involved. Along with some "anything but" christians, some of whom are trying to pass a "holocaust the gays" bill In Uganda.

This isn't America, it is AmeriKKKa. We should all be ashamed of the situation in our country, while eg Canada has gay marriage, a gun murder rate 1/7 of ours population adjusted, and guarantees its citizens cradel to grave medical care.

Whats the solutiion- a third party? who knows.

But America as it stands is beginning more and more to look like Taliban AmeriKKKa

Shame on all of us who haven't tried to change it. And this includes some democrats as well.

Shame on these politicians who cant even find their gonads enough to pass a bill designed to insure Trans people can have a job, contribute to society, and not be living on the street.

And at this point who knows how the hate groups like FRC, AFA, and maybe even NOM were involved. Along with some "anything but" christians, some of whom are trying to pass a "holocaust the gays" bill In Uganda.

This isn't America, it is AmeriKKKa. We should all be ashamed of the situation in our country, while eg Canada has gay marriage, a gun murder rate 1/7 of ours population adjusted, and guarantees its citizens cradel to grave medical care.

Whats the solutiion- a third party? who knows.

But America as it stands is beginning more and more to look like Taliban AmeriKKKa

Shame on all of us who haven't tried to change it. And this includes some democrats as well.

Shame on these politicians who cant even find their gonads enough to pass a bill designed to insure Trans people can have a job, contribute to society, and not be living on the street.

And at this point who knows how the hate groups like FRC, AFA, and maybe even NOM were involved. Along with some "anything but" christians, some of whom are trying to pass a "holocaust the gays" bill In Uganda.

This isn't America, it is AmeriKKKa. We should all be ashamed of the situation in our country, while eg Canada has gay marriage, a gun murder rate 1/7 of ours population adjusted, and guarantees its citizens cradel to grave medical care.

Whats the solutiion- a third party? who knows.

But America as it stands is beginning more and more to look like Taliban AmeriKKKa

Shame on all of us who haven't tried to change it. And this includes some democrats as well.

Transsexual and transgender people in Maryland, and around America, are rejoicing that the unjust H.B. 235 bill has been sent back to the committee. The gay and lesbian leaders and the trans sell outs who follow inEquality Maryland have been shown the door.

Now we will be able to educate the senate why lifesaving public accommodations protections are basic human rights. We thank the senators who publicly acknowledged our concerns. Now Equality Maryland knows they have to enroll our community, via Trans United and Trans Maryland, to get community buy-in. The transsexual and transgender communities own their voices, not the gay and lesbian establishment. Full equality is the only option.

We don't care about it taking years or decades, we represent, we have our voice.

Ashley is not very smart. What kind of trans person wants a voice instead of rights over the next decade. Shocking. I wouldn't follow her lead.

This was a sad day in MD. We can pass a law about dogs in restaurants, we can give in-state tuition for illegals, but we can't take care of our own Maryland citizens???? It's an embarassment.

If You Don't Have Anything Nice To Say About An Oppressor....

"Thank you Equality Maryland and trans sellouts for exhibiting the jacked up leadership that created this screwed up situation in the first place. You can blame 'errbody' else for your failures and try to minimize our role in the process of stopping your messed up legislative overreach, but before you go down that road, take a look in the fracking mirror as to who was most responsible for your twin legislative defeats this legislative session."

"EQ Maryland made the decision to cut public accommodations out of this bill in their double secret meeting in November, and then arrogantly got a 'tude because we transpeople who saw the danger of this horrendous bill passing dared fight them tooth and nail and call them on their crap.

New decade, new rules. You will not get a free ride at passing bills that only benefit your Gay, Inc political agenda and are detrimental to the trans community. You'll also need to talk to a multicultural slice of the community to get a true picture of the discrimination we face.

If you fail to do that and you continue 'bidness' as usual, if it puts us in the position of fighting you and our own sellouts to do so, then it'll be on like Donkey Kong once again..

But the choice for Morgan Meneses Sheets and friends is clear. They can either continue down the road of being problematic trans oppressors or be part of the solution."

http://transgriot.blogspot.com/2011/04/if-you-dont-have-anything-nice-to-say.html

"Ashley is not very smart. What kind of trans person wants a voice instead of rights over the next decade. Shocking. I wouldn't follow her lead."

And follow whose lead instead - 'Equality' Maryland's?

How about just following Ralph the Wonder Slug? Or Ed the Dancing Wombat? Or the dead groundhog out in the middle of the road? All have more sense than 'Equality' Maryland and would not have taken the discourse over putting trans people back to where they should have been in 2001 and poisoned it with the sure loser of gay marriage.

Gotta agree with Ben. It's a shame that these buffoons who were voted in by legal Maryland citizens - gay or straight - are putting the needs of people who are here illegally first. Simply continue to ignore the needs and rights of legal citizens and taxpayers of this state - what goes around comes around. Shame shame shame.

Why spend so much effort for so few psychologically damaged people?
These people are sick and need help not a pass on their sickness.

We do not need mentally damaged people in our schools with our children.

Kat, TransGriot and Ashley- Why/where have transfolk been hiding their power over the last decade?! Odd that you could do it yourselves better but relied on EqualMD to do your bidding, yet you are complainy after having done nothing yourself here in MD! Wait- you and your group have zero political power & developed none over the last decade while EqualMD was doing it? Everyone is ignoring you but me and I'm bored. Internet chatty complainy cathies is all you are. Happy that Ashley at least realizes it will take you decades to get rights on your own. That is SOOOOOO stickin it to Gay INC!!!

I see the same 3 people byatching about this bill. How egotistical are they? Quite naive as well. Comical.

Maryland Democrats are worse than Republicans. They accomplished nothing this session. A total failure in terms of not just social issues, but any other meaningful legislation.

Ashley speaks for most of us as a transgender and not a political lobbyist.. All we want is to be human and not second class anymore.

Not 30 seconds should be spent in the legislature to protect a class of brain damaged people that numbers in the tens.

Trannies are indeed mentally disturbed and should be helped not separated out as a protected class.

Discrimination laws protect all people, not just certain protected classes that these freak Pigressives declare worthy of separate protections.

Not 30 seconds should be spent in the legislature to protect a class of brain damaged people that numbers in the tens.

Tea Klux Klan members?

"Why/where have transfolk been hiding their power over the last decade?! "

I suspect that most have - out of necessity - channelled what power they have into individualized efforts to say alive in a legal regime in which gays and lesbians created a legal status for themselves superior to that of trans people, a status distinction of which anyone with the ability to read or know of the Maryland Code's definition of "sexual orientation" could not be unfamiliar.

Do you also ask the corpses of abused spouses where their power was while they were being beaten to death?

Tea Klux Klan members?

Posted by: TransGriot

Brain damaged freak of nature.

Tea Klux Klan members?
Posted by: TransGriot


No tranny, but those few of you who are so mentally disturbed that you think you are something you are not seems to be the issue.

Your jump that someone who believes trannys and you others are disturbed are TPPM members is most bigoted of you. But with your disability you are forgiven your ignorance.

"Trannies are indeed mentally disturbed and should be helped not separated out as a protected class."

So if some "trannies" who might happen to have some money get together, buy the business that employs you, and decides to fire all non-transsexuals, then you'd be fine with that?

A legitimate trans rights law wouldn't simply allow trans people to sue for anti-trans discrimination; it would allow non-trans people to sue for anti-non-trans-discrimination.

One of many failings of the gay rights industry is that it has never made any real attempt to convey that "sexual orientation"-based civil rights laws don't simply allow gays to sue straights for anti-gay discrimination; they allow straights to sue gays for anti-straight discrimination.

Kat, we do not need the mentally disturbed teaching our children.

As an employee, I would not work for a bunch of mentally disturbed employers.

My business would die if I was forced to hire these freaks of nature as many would.

Being a transsexual is not a civil rights issue, it is a psychological issue.
There are no laws that force the hiring of the mentally disturbed.

Thank God I live in Texas where non-sense like this is not an issue. Whew!

I was just reading the Baltimore Sun's "terms of service" and then I read this thread..

Do not provide User Content that:
* contains vulgar, profane, abusive, racist or hateful language or expressions, epithets or slurs, text, photographs or illustrations in poor taste, inflammatory attacks of a personal, racial or religious nature.
"*Trannies* are indeed mentally disturbed"
"My business would die if I was forced to hire these *freaks of nature* as many would. "

* is defamatory, threatening, disparaging, grossly inflammatory, false, misleading, fraudulent, inaccurate, unfair, contains gross exaggeration or unsubstantiated claims, violates the privacy rights of any third party, is unreasonably harmful or offensive to any individual or community.
"Why spend so much effort for so few psychologically damaged people?"
"These people are sick and need help not a pass on their sickness."
"We do not need mentally damaged people in our schools with our children."

* "flames" any individual or entity (e.g., sends repeated messages related to another user and/or makes derogatory or offensive comments about another individual), or repeats prior posting of the same message under multiple threads or subjects. WARNING: A VIOLATION OF THESE POSTING RULES MAY BE REFERRED TO LAW ENFORCEMENT AUTHORITIES.
"Brain damaged freak of nature." (directed to a single individual)
"No tranny,..."

Why are the moderators violating their own terms of service by encouraging this discussion? The rules apply to all of us.

no civil legislation will salve an ailing conscience, you cannot make people like you...they will hate you for that. Illegal aliens were first thieves and immoral..then it was made illegal. The immorality came first, then the law. Trans/bi/homo/les perversions are all immoral first. I can reject them all and not be phobic or hateful. To believe it is immoral is not hate.

"Brain damaged freak of nature." (directed to a single individual)" Posted by: Michiko

You purposely left out this nice one
Tea Klux Klan members?
Posted by: TransGriot

directed at a single poster!!

Whats good for the goose......

"Being a transsexual is not a civil rights issue, it is a psychological issue."

This smells like it was written by someone who has materially benefited from the political decision to remove homosexuality from the DSM, thereby allowing people to assert that it isn't a psychological issue whilst claiming that transsexuality is.

Kat, it seems that every bad thing that happens vis-a-vis gender identity is the fault of a gay person.

I'm sorry, the only thing I can surmise now is that perhaps you cannot get a date.

I was alerted by Monica Roberts of Trans Griot that someone on this thread had intentionally misquoted me, which is obvious was to stigmatize me and other who feel as I do, therefore trying to discredit me

Someone in this comment thread who calls themselves "Ashley Love" copy and pasted a comment I gave to the Advocate: http://www.advocate.com/News/Daily_News/2011/04/11/Md_Gender_Identity_Dies_in_Senate/

Then, they libelously added their own sentence at the end which they created on their own: "We don't care about it taking years or decades...".
I never wrote that, and I do in fact care if it takes “years or decades”. The politically savvy people I know in Maryland have told me that public accommodations as a stand alone amendment would be near impossible to pass, and it would be easier to pass it if it was with the rest of the protections. Trans United and Trans Maryland oppose the bill w/o PA protections, and I support their stance.

Most transsexual and transgender Americans support the unjust bill being sent back; without public accommodations protections included the message is we’re 2nd class citizens, submitting to fear mongering of “bathroom hysteria” advocates, and that gays via Equality Maryland can make decisions for transsexual and transgender people without community buy-in, however, we’ll accept nothing less than a fully comprehensive bill

Furthermore, it’s unfortunate that Dana La Rocca on this thread, and elsewhere, has made it her new pastime to try to slander and discredit me. I feel the community deserves to know why she is doing this. Dana La Roca's testimony at the hearing had some concerns by many people. She used words like "unMOLEST" in the same sentence where she said she understood why people would be concerned for "your wives and children’s safety", alluding to the ‘trans women in restrooms issue’. Yes, we wanted the bill dead, but for her to play into the far right's "bathroom hysteria" crap to kill it will bite us in the back later; she essentially was spreading their message for them. I simply told her that “molest” was a highly poor choice of words. She couldn’t’ take constructive criticism, which many agreed with, and ever since she has been on a warpath to discredit me and slander me. It’s pretty pathetic and immoral, and only serves her vendetta, not the community. I just thought you should all know the bitter energy you are dealing with.


Its pretty pathetic that whoever impersonated me in the comment section of the article felt so desperate to slander those of us that oppose the bill that they would concoct the last sentence and try to pass it off if I said that. This just goes to show that "the compromise one makes today, will haunt them tomorrow". To pull a stunt like that is laughable. I guess the truth wasn’t enough to debate my quote, so they had to resort to a lie

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Headlines from The Baltimore Sun
About the bloggers
Annie Linskey covers state politics and government for The Baltimore Sun. Previously, as a City Hall reporter, she wrote about the corruption trial of Mayor Sheila Dixon and kept a close eye on city spending. Originally from Connecticut, Annie has also lived in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, where she reported on war crimes tribunals and landmines. She lives in Canton.

John Fritze has covered politics and government at the local, state and federal levels for more than a decade and is now The Baltimore Sun’s Washington correspondent. He previously wrote about Congress for USA TODAY, where he led coverage of the health care overhaul debate and the 2010 election. A native of Albany, N.Y., he currently lives in Montgomery County.

Julie Scharper covers City Hall and Baltimore politics. A native of Baltimore County, she graduated from The Johns Hopkins University in 2001 and spent two years teaching in Honduras before joining The Baltimore Sun. She has followed the Amish community of Nickel Mines, Pa., in the year after a schoolhouse massacre, reported on courts and crime in Anne Arundel County, and chronicled the unique personalities and places of Baltimore City and its surrounding counties.
Most Recent Comments
Sign up for FREE local news alerts
Get free Sun alerts sent to your mobile phone.*
Get free Baltimore Sun mobile alerts
Sign up for local news text alerts

Returning user? Update preferences.
Sign up for more Sun text alerts
*Standard message and data rates apply. Click here for Frequently Asked Questions.
  • Breaking News newsletter
When a big news event breaks, we'll e-mail you the basics with links to up-to-date details.
Sign up

Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com news blogs
 Subscribe to this feed
Charm City Current
Stay connected