Cardin deal gets Bay cleanup bill out of committee
Sen. Benjamin L. Cardin's proposal to strengthen cleanup of the Chesapeake Bay cleared the Senate Environment committee today with bipartisan support, but not before the Maryland Democrat made concessions to Republican opponents.
The revised measure, which still faces a very steep climb in this election year, no longer codifies a Bay-wide pollution limit, or "Total Maximum Daily Load" (TMDL) for nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment, that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency is developing.
Environmentalists had considered that provision a key element of the Cardin plan, which is designed to strengthen the federal Clean Water Act by giving EPA the authority it needs to enforce a cleanup of the Bay's waters by 2025.
A lobbyist for the Chesapeake Bay Foundation, a leading backer of the measure, said the legislation is still very strong, despite dropping the TMDL language.
The changes give it a chance of gaining approval by the full Senate before the current session of Congress ends.
The House has still not acted on a companion measure, sponsored by Democratic Rep. Elijah Cummings of Baltimore, and the odds of the legislation making it to President Barack Obama's desk this year are not good. Also still to be considered: funding for the measure, which has a price tag in excess of $2 billion over five years, much of it to help state and local governments and farmers deal with pollution runoff.
Agriculture interests are strongly opposed. They contend Cardin's plan would impose a crushing new financial burden on farmers in the six-state area that makes up the Bay watershed. The committee voted down several amendments by Republican Sen. John Barrasso of Wyoming, including one that would have given state and federal agriculture officials a bigger say in regulating pollution from farms.
Republican Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma, who agreed to drop a series of amendments that could have weakened the measure, said he was still concerned that the Bay bill could become a "template" for regulating bodies of water beyond the Chesapeake Bay. But the conservative senator praised Cardin, a liberal, for being willing to consider his objections, "even though we come from really different philosophies."
Cardin said his proposal was designed to treat everyone fairly, including farmers, developers and managers of wastewater treatment plants, by letting states decide how to meet pollution limits and "not dictate that from Washington." He said the changes he agreed to would not weaken EPA's ability to set Bay-wide pollution limits.
The Cardin measure would give EPA new authority to withhold federal funds under the Clean Water Act as way to prod states into implementing their pollution-reduction plans. The measure would also impose new conservation restrictions on commercial and residential development in the Bay watershed to limit stormwater runoff.