Uh, about those milestones ....
There was a lot of talk at Mount Vernon on Tuesday about "a new day" dawning in the long struggle to restore Chesapeake Bay, with President Obama declaring the bay a national treasure and states agreeing to short-term pollution reduction plans, aka "milestones." Virginia Gov. Timothy M. Kaine, head of the bay Executive Council (pictured at right), called it a "turning point," though he acknowledged there was still a lot of work to do. The cleanup effort now is being ramped up and is going to be much more accountable, we were told.
But take a look at those milestones, at least the two-page summaries handed out to the press and now posted online. They skimp on key details, especially on what the backup plans are in case those measures fall short, and on what the consequences will be if the states blow these new milestones. We'll have to wait for those information gaps to be filled, we were told.
Next, look at the graphs showing how much nitrogen and phosphorus pollution each state promises to eliminate. The graphs start at several million or tens of millions of pounds. not at zero. Had the graphs had a scale that showed how far pollution ultimately has to be reduced by the "end date" of 2025, the divergence between past reductions and future promises would have looked a lot smaller.
Then there's the case of the mysterious missing information on a few of the states' milestone statements. The two-page outlines of cleanup efforts for the entire six-state bay region and for Maryland, Pennsylvania and Virginia showed graphs with two diverging lines, depicting pollution reductions already in progress and even greater efforts those states were committing to make by 2011. The graphs projected accelerations of cleanup ranging from 52 to 502 percent.
But the summaries handed out Tuesday for Delaware, the District of Columbia, New York and West Virginia showed only one line on their graphs. Each graph depicted the pollution reductions that were being pledged through 2011. Missing was any line projecting the rate at which pollution would go down based on efforts already under way.
Drafts of the milestone documents circulated only a few days before Tuesday's summit did show current and future rates of cleanup. The District, New York and West Virginia all were shown making less progress in the next few years than they had been making up to now. That's right - negative progress. For New York, the drafts showed a 15 percent backslide on the rate of nitrogen reductions, and for West Virginia a 61 percent slippage in nitrogen and a 45 percent decline in phosphorus removal rates.
The graph lines and calculations showing negative progress were missing from the final milestone documents handed out Tuesday at Mount Vernon. What would George Washington think?


Speaking last week in Washington at a preview of a documentary about pollution in the Chesapeake Bay and Puget Sound, Jackson said because of Supreme Court decisions "there is murkiness" now about whether the EPA or states have any say over filling or draining many wetlands, which filter out pollution naturally.
In a report released last week, the task force set up by Gov. Martin O'Malley called for the state to close loopholes in the 17-year-old forest law and take other steps to achieve "no net loss" of woodlands. You can read a release about the report and download a copy of it
The federal and state governments are seeking feedback from the public on whether to introduce an Asian oyster into the bay, to revive the Chesapeake's flagging oyster industry and restore its depleted population of bivalves capable of filtering the water.
About 100 farmers, including chicken growers and crop cultivators, turned out for a public hearing on the rules Monday night in Salisbury, according to an MDE spokesman. About 15 spoke, with some objecting that requiring buffers along streams and drainage ditches to keep manure out of the water would take valuable land out of production. Others disputed that their farms were causing any problems for the bay. Still others, though, thanked agency officials for listening to their concerns, according to the MDE spokesman.