baltimoresun.com

« Obama's interfaith holiday greeting | Main | Priest accused of U.S. abuse still working in India »

April 5, 2010

On Easter, a 'papal pep rally'

It was the Catholic calendar's holiest moment -- the Mass celebrating the resurrection of Christ. But with Pope Benedict XVI accused of failing to protect children from abusive priests, the Associated Press reports, Easter Sunday also was a high-profile opportunity to play defense.

"Holy Father, on your side are the people of God," Cardinal Angelo Sodano told the pontiff, whom victims of clergy sexual abuse accuse of helping to shape and perpetuate a climate of cover-up. Sodano, dean of the College of Cardinals, dismissed those claims as "petty gossip."

The ringing tribute at the start of a Mass attended by tens of thousands in St. Peter's Square marked an unusual departure from the Vatican's Easter rituals, infusing the tradition-steeped religious ceremony with an air of a papal pep rally.

Dressed in gold robes and shielded from a cool drizzle by a canopy, Benedict looked weary during much of the Mass, the highlight of a heavy Holy Week schedule. But as he listened intently to Sodano's paean, a smile broke across the pope's face, and when the cardinal finished speaking, Benedict rose from his chair in front of the altar to embrace him.

The pontiff hasn't responded to accusations that he did too little to protect children from pedophile priests, even as sex abuse scandals threaten to overshadow his papacy.

Sodano's praise for Benedict as well as the church's 400,000 priests worldwide cranked up a vigorous campaign by the Holy See to counter what it calls a "vile" smear operation orchestrated by anti-Vatican media aimed at weakening the papacy and its moral authority.

Sodano said the faithful came to "rally close around you, successor to (St.) Peter, bishop of Rome, the unfailing rock of the holy church" amid the joy of Easter.

"We are deeply grateful to you for the strength of spirit and apostolic courage with which you announce the Gospel," said Sodano, who sought to assure Benedict that the scandals were not costing him credibility among his flock.

"Holy Father, on your side are the people of God, who do not allow themselves to be influenced by the petty gossip of the moment, by the trials which sometimes buffet the community of believers," Sodano said.

The cardinal also rushed to the defense of all the Catholic priests who "generously serve the people of God, in parishes, recreation centers, schools, hospitals and many other places, as well as in the missions in the most remote parts of the world."

Benedict, who turns 83 on April 16, was holding up well against the campaign of "deceitful accusations" against him, Venice Cardinal Angelo Scola said in an interview on Italian state TV Sunday. Scola said he recently had dined with the pope, who was drawing on his "usual spiritual energy."

Easter Sunday Mass was the last major Holy Week appearance by the pope in Rome for the thousands of faithful who have poured into the city. On Monday, he will greet pilgrims in the courtyard of the papal retreat in Castel Gandolfo, a lakeside town in the Alban Hills south of Rome.

Worshippers cheered Benedict at the end of Sunday's two-hour-long Mass in the cobblestone square bedecked with daffodils, tulips and azaleas.

After the Mass, Benedict moved to the central balcony of St. Peter's Basilica to deliver his "Urbi et Orbi" message — Latin for "to the city and to the world" — which analyzes humanity's failings and hopes.

He singled out the "trials and sufferings," including persecution and even death, of Christians in Iraq and Pakistan, and of people in Haiti and Chile, devastated by earthquakes. He hoped for peaceful coexistence to win out over criminal violence in Latin American countries plagued by drug trafficking, and promised to pray for peace in the Middle East.

His speech ignored demands by victims that he shoulder some responsibility for a common practice by bishops in the past of shuffling pedophile priests from parish to parish rather than sullying the church's reputation by defrocking clergy who raped, sodomized or otherwise sexually abused minors.

The accusations against the pope stem from his leadership as archbishop of Munich, in his native Germany, before he came to the Vatican three decades ago, as well as his long tenure in Rome leading the Holy See's office dealing with a growing pile of dossiers about pedophile priests.

Sodano's words irked a prominent advocacy group, the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests.

"When we speak up and tell how our childhood innocence was shattered by sexual assaults by priests, it is not 'petty gossip,'" SNAP president Barbara Blaine said in a statement.

In the pope's homeland of Germany, which has been rocked by a widening abuse scandal, police said they arrested a man who attacked the Roman Catholic bishop of Muenster with a broom handle during an Easter service in the city's cathedral.

Bishop Felix Genn, 60, defended himself with an incense bowl and was unharmed. After the incident, he continued celebrating the Easter service. The man's motive was unclear, police said.

Germany's top Roman Catholic cleric, Archbishop Robert Zollitsch, urged Catholics in his Easter homily not to break with the church even as they face "the heinous crimes, the dark sides of the church."

So far, the Vatican's counterattack to beat back the scandal accusations already backfired in one high-profile attempt.

Jewish leaders, and even some top Catholic churchmen, were angered after Benedict's personal preacher, in a Good Friday sermon, likened the growing accusations against the pope to the campaign of anti-Semitic violence that culminated in the Holocaust.

The preacher, the Rev. Raniero Cantalamessa, told Corriere della Sera daily in an interview Sunday that he had no intention "of hurting the sensibilities of the Jews and of the victims of pedophilia," expressed regret and asked for forgiveness.

He was quoted as saying that the pope wasn't aware of what the sermon would say beforehand, and that no Vatican officials read the text before the Good Friday service.

The apology satisfied one Jewish leader, Elan Steinberg, vice president of the American Gathering of Holocaust Survivors and their Descendants.

"Now that he has apologized and the Vatican has distanced itself from those remarks, the matter is closed," Steinberg said in a statement.

Paris Cardinal Andre Vingt-Trois told Le Parisien newspaper that he understood the "violent and indignant" reaction that Friday's sermon provoked in Jews and pedophilia victims. Still, the French churchman denounced what he called a campaign of "denigration and slander" against the pope and said he shouldn't resign.

Washington, D.C., Archbishop Donald Wuerl joined those defending Benedict, writing in an opinion piece in Sunday's Washington Post that the pope has supported U.S. bishops' commitment to child protection policies.

In Milwaukee, where one priest was accused of assaulting some 200 deaf boys, at least a dozen churchgoers told The Associated Press they were not closely following a scandal that has engulfed the church. A canonical trial was initiated against the Rev. Lawrence Murphy years after the alleged abuse, but a Vatican office led at the time by Benedict, then Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, halted the proceedings. Murphy died soon after.

Tony Pisani said he was frustrated by what he was hearing in the news but he is waiting to hear the reaction of the pope himself.

"I haven't seen too many statements from him," the Milwaukee man said. "I'd like to see what safeguards he's implemented to make sure something like this doesn't happen again."

One angry parishioner was 68-year-old Jackson Spears, who said the church should have taken strong action from the beginning.

"I think the pope should have been more aggressive and he should have done something sooner," Spears said. "The church shouldn't condone these things and should have years ago done something about it."

Posted by Matthew Hay Brown at 5:00 AM | | Comments (10)
        

Comments

It is hard to change a church if that church is so steeped in traditions that arent mandated by God, but instead are mandated by men. The Catholic church needs to get rid of Roman authority and allow priests to marry. The highest authority besides God for any Catholic church should be the local priest and church commitees. The rest of the system needs to be disbanded and the word of the bible should be more strictly followed. If the bible doesnt tell you to do it, then dont. Do this and I wouldnt mind attending a Catholic church myself and neither would many others.

Clay,

So... you "wouldnt mind" attending a Catholic church ... so long as it abandoned anything that distinguished it from your own faith tradition. How very ecumenical of you.

If we eliminated tradition, priestly celibacy, Papal authority, and let local priests and church busybodies determine doctrine then all we would have left would be the Most Precious Body of Christ, the Eucharist.

No thanks Clay.

"If the bible doesn't tell you to do it, then don't." Is another theory that doesn't work for Catholics. The notion of free will is central to our faith. The catechism says "The more one does what is good, the freer one becomes. There is no true freedom except in the service of what is good and just."

Not every cause of good and justice are listed in the bible. Men and women of good will may disagree, too, concerning what is good and just. That is where Catholicism begs us to take charge of our own spiritual destinies.

We learn, at an early age, the "examination of conscience" where we consider our actions and thoughts in light of our discernment of God's will. Entire books have been written on this subject and are a part of our tradition. Again, if we give up tradition we lose an essential part of what it means to seek the fullness of truth.

Still, Clay, the door is open. You are welcome anytime.

"The highest authority besides God for any Catholic church should be the local priest and church commitees"

Clay, what exactly is that based on?

Anonymous, are you not familiar with Paul's Epistle to the Washingtonians wherein he describes in Talmudic detail the organization of church committees?

Clay - You muddy up a more serious issue with your own personal bias. Besides the obvious that if it weren't for God working through the Catholic & Orthodox Churches the New Testament as you know it would not even exist. The early church also tried your idea of letting local churches run independently and the result was problems with heresy. That was precisely why authority was centralized. Do you recall the dispute in the Acts of the Apostles over forcing Jewish Law on Christian Gentiles. That was resolved by the central authority of the apostles. How many different interpretations exist among Protestant and Evangelical Christians today? I'm not going to go through again listing the rest of the errors in your post. Simply restate advice I gave you long ago. Educate yourself about the Church as you do not have the proper understanding of it and follow the words of Christ and remove the log from your own eye before worrying about the splinters in someone else's.

As to the topic of the story, the Church needs to open up and make public all records of what was and was not done during the time of these various acts. The only way to even start any kind of healing and reconciliation and end the stories is removing the shroud of secrecy surrounding the actions of Benedict prior to his Papacy and the Vatican’s actions and inactions as well as the bishops when & where these horrific acts occurred.

Clay, on priestly celibacy, read Matthew 19: 10-12 where regarding celibacy, Jesus himself says, "He who is able to receive this, let him receive it." I would highly recommend that you pick up a little, easy to read book called Where Is That In The Bible? by Patrick Madrid or for a little bit longer read, Why Do Catholics Do That? by Kevin Orlin Johnson, PhD. Both will help you to understand how many of these Catholic traditions DID originate in Biblical texts.

Jesus prayed that we would be one and of the same mind and judgment. Allowing each and every local church to be their own authority for interpreting scripture is why there are now well over 33,000 individual protestant denominations (ref: World Christian Encyclopedia, David B. Barrett, et al, 2001, Table 1-5, vol 1, page 16.)

Yes, I am aware of what the new testament says about staying unmarried if possible. Thats just it though, if you can. I think that priests in general would be better off if they were allowed to marry and wouldnt have to listen to Rome for anything but good pizza. Thanks.

Now we find out why Clay is such an intransigent Bible-Nazi. It gives him the perfect rationale for not being able to find a woman, especially one that will meet the narrow and subservient demands that fundamentalism requires of their barefoot and pregnant lesser halves. I think he may have an innate fear of sex to begin with, or possibly he is repressing urges that are best covered over by remaining self-righteously celibate.

Besides..I think Naples is known for its pizza much more than is Rome.

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

About Matthew Hay Brown
Matthew Hay Brown writes and blogs about faith and values in public and private life for The Baltimore Sun. A former Washington correspondent for the newspaper, he has long written about the intersection of religion and politics. He has reported from Africa, Asia, Europe, Latin America and the Middle East, traveling most recently to Syria and Jordan to write about the Iraqi refugee crisis.
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
Religion in the news
Charm City Current
Stay connected