baltimoresun.com

« The best (and worst) Maryland schools (updated) | Main | More about Anne Arundel MSA results »

July 23, 2010

In letter to community, Alonso addresses test investigations

Baltimore City schools CEO Andres Alonso wrote a letter titled "Learning from our results" to the city school community today, where he discussed the city's 2010 Maryland School Assessment results -- which were released Tuesday -- and highlighted some successess and pitfalls in student achievement.

The CEO then went on to address the investigation into Abbottston Elementary School, whose scores plummeted in some grades from 100 percent this year. We broke the story last night that Alonso, who rarely ever will address speculation about a specific school, confirmed that the drop in scores raised red flags.

Read the CEO's letter below:
 

Dear City Schools Partners and Friends,
Earlier this week, I wrote to you with the news of Baltimore City Public Schools’ 2009-10 Maryland School Assessment (MSA) results. These results are both encouraging and important. They show continued growth, especially among student groups with a history of low achievement, a narrowing of the gap between elementary and middle school outcomes, and a doubling of the students performing at the highest level of performance in both reading and math over the past three years. They also highlight the critical role of attendance in student success in school.

This year’s MSA results show that of students who attended school regularly in 2009-10, 75.2 percent scored proficient or advanced on the reading MSA, compared to just 59.6 percent of students who were chronically absent, meaning missing 20 school days or more. In math the achievement gap was larger; of students who attended school regularly, 70.5 percent scored proficient or advanced on the math MSA, compared to just 48.9 percent of students who were chronically absent. And these gaps were even greater between students who attended school regularly and those who were truant or suspended.

The significance of attendance in City Schools has never been clearer: When our kids are not in school they do not achieve. And the responsibility of the City Schools community has never been starker: We must work to ensure that our kids are in school.            

This year’s MSA results also highlight the performance of individual schools, and today’s news made public an investigation of test results involving Abbottston Elementary School, one of our highest achieving elementary schools in recent years. The investigation—which includes an inquiry by City Schools as well as an investigation by the Maryland State Department of Education (MSDE) at City Schools’ request following intensive monitoring of test administration and significant drops in test scores at Abbottston this spring—is an indication of how seriously we take the need to ensure the integrity of our results.


City Schools has clear protocols in place to monitor testing; to respond to, and where necessary investigate, allegations of impropriety; and to take quick and firm action when there is the slightest evidence that alleged improprieties have occurred. We will not look the other way when there is any evidence of behavior that reflects a lack of faith in our kids, and compromises the integrity of us all. And as a result of this commitment, we will sometimes investigate schools where no wrongful or intentional action has taken place.


This process takes time and absent hard evidence, no one should make assumptions about our students or any school or school community and their hard-earned gains. As I have said repeatedly, I believe strongly that the overwhelming majority of our educators, partners and families are working incredibly hard for our kids, and they deserve huge applause. Those who try to game the system are the exception, and deserve to be exposed.


As vital partners in our students’ success, I hope you will join me in keeping the conversation alive about where we need to focus our efforts in the months ahead to keep our kids moving forward. Let’s work together to get them to, and keep them in school. And let’s be sure to lift them up as we go.


Thank you for all that you do for our students and our schools.
Sincerely,
Andrés A. Alonso, Ed.D.
CEO, Baltimore City Public Schools

Posted by Erica Green at 6:23 PM | | Comments (6)
Categories: Baltimore City
        

Comments

No Child Left Inside @ AAA City Schools

I receive via email all AAA PR community letters sent to ED partners. BS paper InSide Ed blog focus on City Schools CEO letter, “Learning from Our Results." What’s omitted mention by the district school system own internal operations failures a laser-like-focus on the micro-education classroom teaching and learning? That we do receive in our primary school PreK-5 is poor executive director leadership from Irma Johnson and more... The new Network Office executive director Landa McLaurin has not shown to have increased outcomes in area schools productivity and field support to principle/ teachers citywide in our area district school system teaching and learning in primary/ secondary schools are suffering and more...

The Office of Information Technology director Mike Pitroff network cyber education portal systems resources are severely-severely- underutilized by all the City School executive officers, directors, principals and teachers if any office deserves increase budget funding to produce immediate academic increase to lower the City Schools district academic achievement divide for all of our students it would be in the IT office network systems.

I agree that the IT office is underutilized but are all people involved ready to work with the education portals that are currently available? Unfortunately, the answer is no. Top that off with the lack of computer access in most schools and we are going to continue to be behind in training students how to survive in the current century. Our students are woefully behind in computer access and training. I don't know the solution but we have to do something to get back up to speed.

I honestly feel that all administrators and staff that participated in these violations should be exposed and let go. It is apparent that they will go to any method to be the top school when it comes to testing that they will compromise their own personal integrity. My son was violated in this testing situation at school #330 and I spoke with every administrator possible , the disability law center and they all teamed up with the school to protect those involved while no one protected my sons rights. I took it as far as the office of civil rights and they evaded the issues as if they turn a blind eye and deaf ear to it and it is sad that this is just escalating to other schools like an epidemic. I want justice for all kids who have been violated by this . Speak up parents if you see any suspicious scores rise higher than what your kids are used to getting on standardized tests. We have to be there advocates , because in the hands of these schools in question, we are all they have and can trust.

With all of the questions about test scores it seems odd that Ben Fieldman was "retired" last night at the school board meeting since he was a major part of investigating the data that showed when and where cheating happened. Ben was and remains a good person doing a good job. I hope the new person is as well qualified, but given the number of cheaters who have been caught it seems like it would have been worth it to ask him stay on to head an investigative team.

We have a number of kids who have come from schools where cheating was the norm. Some have come to us with scores that are clearly out of whack with where they are (kids who literally in 6th grade cannot identify letters in their name who somehow score advanced) and others who said during the tests asked why we weren't providing the answers like their other schools had done. I have been clear with my staff that no one is going to lose their jobs over a test. We are not going to be involved in anything that might stink of cheating. Anyone who thinks that this should go another way will be reported.

I agree with the other poster who said that anyone who was involved should be exposed and fired. I don't give a crap if a higher up says to do it and that's the excuse, everyone signs a paper accepting the rules. These folks are an embarrassment to the rest of us and they do a disservice to the kids. Dump them.

Here's the "thing" folks need to know about the MSA, AYP @ the whole "NCLB:
1. If you look closely at the schools that had a decline in test scores, remember a few things...the third graders are always new to testing (they're coming from second grade--and by the middle of first quarter of the second grade, they are just being exposed to those dreaded BCRs--in some jurisdictions they are working on BCR's in first grade) and forget the fact that they're mere babes expected to perform, because they've got to get ready for the big test next year; the fourth graders of 2010 were the third graders of 2009--if they were at 100% in 2009 and then dropped to 50% in 2010--that would raise a flag. The fifth graders of 2010 were the fourth graders of 2009--did their scores plummet as well? Then that is an additional flag.
2. Students don't forget that much from one year to the next--or do they?
3. I think the alleged test scandal is really bigger than we all think--and believe me---it is not just in the city. Out of over 500,000 plus students in the state jurisdications-do you really think in each and every high performing school that over 80%95% are proficient/advanced? And does every single jurisdiction have that many highly qualified/execellent teachers capable of advancing students every year? Especially when you have job fairs and get at least 10-20% new staff every year. And you know what folks want to say about teachers--those who have lower GPA's become teachers--which incidently is degrading.
4. It is difficult to get students to the mastery of state standards (which are not really teacher or parent friendly) in seven months don't you think---it is more like a mix of teaching to the test and ......(you can figure out the rest)
5. Has anyone really examined the definitions on MDs report card site for AMO, confidence interval, safe harbor, etc.?
What do they mean in layman terms really? Pay attention to the ratings given MD in Ed Week on the Teaching Profession section, MD got a C
Bottom line....NCLB, AYP needs to be fixed, because at the end of the day in 2014...when everybody is supposed to be at 100% ....what will come next--are we just satisfied that we've reached that target--after that what is the next expectation--especially for those that aren't at 100 by 2014--and folks that is just around the corner.

Questions about the Abbottston investigation:
1. Why wasn't the school investigated when the school had 100% of its students scoring proficient or advanced on last year's MSA? It seems to me that would have made more sense than investigating the current scores.
2. Also, what were the factors that were different from last year that might have contributed to the decline? Just wondering...

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "j" in the field below:
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

2011 Valedictorians and Salutatorians
Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
Education news
• InsideEd's glossary of education jargon

School closings and delays
Baltimoresun.com's school closings database is designed to provide up-to-date, easy-to-access information in the event of inclement weather.

Find out if your school is participating and sign up for e-mail alerts.
Sign up for FREE local news alerts
Get free Sun alerts sent to your mobile phone.*
Get free Baltimore Sun mobile alerts
Sign up for local news text alerts

Returning user? Update preferences.
Sign up for more Sun text alerts
*Standard message and data rates apply. Click here for Frequently Asked Questions.
Spread the word about InsideEd
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com news blogs
 Subscribe to this feed
Stay connected