Blum mentoring is back
Lois Blum Feinblatt, who gave money to start a mentoring program for new city teachers a decade ago as a way of honoring her late husband, presented the system with a check for $73,575 at Tuesday night's school board meeting. (Yes, I know I've been talking about this meeting for three days now, but what can I say? It was long and a lot happened.) The money will fund a mentoring coordinator position at the central office for the second half of this school year and the first half of next year. The system has committed to fund the position for the second half of next year regardless of its budget constraints.
The Blum mentoring program has had great success in keeping new teachers in the system and, as evidenced by an earlier discussion on this blog, it is beloved by its participants. It ended this year as money was shifted from the central office into schools. Those schools with a lot of new teachers are still required to have some sort of mentoring in place, but participants bemoaned the fact that mentors would have to report to principals rather than a central coordinator, a structure that helps protect the confidentiality of teacher concerns.






Comments
This is another example of the administration making a hasty decision and then backtracking. Mentors and teachers tried to tell them this back in the spring, but it was clear that they didn't understand what the program was about or what it meant to new teachers. Unfortunately, what was the Blum Mentoring Program will never be the same. The coordinator of the program and the experienced, well-trained mentors have been scattered to the winds. Some have retired, some have taken jobs outside the system and some have been placed in positions that are not utilizing their expertise. For the sake of the new teachers, I do hope that a viable mentoring program can be put into place, but with the loss of the people who made Blum so outstanding, I can't imagine how that will happen.
Posted by: Avalon | December 12, 2008 11:46 AM
Getting rid of the Blum program was our CEO's worst move in a laundry list of things I don't agree with. My Blum mentor saved me time and time again, always offering advice for literally ANY situation or complication I was having. Without the Blum mentor program, I would have left Baltimore years ago... I hope the system realizes the error of its ways and keeps the Program running as it was for many years to come.
Posted by: Brandon | December 12, 2008 11:58 AM
The heading, "Blum Mentoring is Back" is far from accurate here -- as Avalon says, Blum mentors are now scattered far and wide and no one with any familiarity with the program is probably available (or likely) to take the director's position at this late date. Even if someone was to take on this opportunity, (which, by the way, is wonderful of Ms. Feinblatt to provide) there are still many questions. For instance, who does this person actually direct? There are few in our cash-strapped schools who have the position of ONLY being a mentor -- most are mentors/staff develpers or mentors/instructional team leaders. In addition, what principal is going to allow one of his/her staff members to function autonomously under the direction of an off-site "director," when that principal's valuable dollars are being spent on that mentor? While I value the premise of Blum and I believe that it was an incredibly valuable program that should not have been eradicated, I'm doubtful that this skeleton program will do much to ameliorate the problems that Blum existed to address. In a completely site-based management system, it is difficult to see how a program like Blum, even if it had been left in-tact, would function. I do believe, however, that when Dr. Alonso realizes that good principals capable of managing an entirely site-based school will not simply materialize (many will fail and he'll have to get rid of them in order not to engage in the "dance of the lemons"), it is then that he will come back to Blum to help stabilize and improve the City's schools. Hopefully, then, if a skeleton has been kept in place, it will be easier to bring a new incarnation of the program to life.
Posted by: Nico | December 13, 2008 1:19 AM