baltimoresun.com

« Lots to comment on | Main | At last, education debated »

October 15, 2008

Two takes on the Patterson evacuation

I received an e-mail today from a teacher at Patterson High School about the hectic evacuation of the school yesterday amid the explosions of two chemical-filled bottles. I'm posting it here, along with a reaction from the principal.

We were evacuated out of the building at 12:05. Not 11 as your article states. We sat outside for almost an hour and 45 minutes with no explanation or anything other than what we saw happening with all the police, fire trucks, helicopters, hazmat, etc. We were NEVER given any direction from a single administrator about what to do. Granted it was a confusing situation, but we had 1000+ students outside and teachers with no idea what was going on.

When the word finally came to send the students home, they were NOT initially let into the building at all. Students had bags, bus tickets, and other valuables simply left inside. There were some administrators saying we could go in to get kids stuff, others said no. Others said we could get the stuff for them.

It was never clear after most of the students had gotten onto various buses what the staff was supposed to do. We got absolutely no direction about what our role was.

AND MOST EGREGIOUS OF ALL was the response this morning. No faculty meeting to discuss the incident, no assurances that steps were being taken to ensure safety at all. All we got was a trite announcement that we were "back to business as usual" and a letter was going home to parents of students. What about us as staff? By not being given any information, we are totally in the dark about this all. Is this intentional or just another signal of the lack of interest in protecting staff? I want to be safe in my workplace, and if incidents happen that compromise this safety, I think assurances would be a GIVEN!!!! The climate of fear and lack of attention to staff/student safety is appalling.

I am holding out hope that during tomorrow's PD (professional development), things can be discussed further, but it seems as though it's just another little incident to be dealt with by saying "no big deal" and let's move on. But at the same time, this matter should have and was NOT dealt with immediately in terms of information flow and assurances to us-the people that keep this place going!!!

I asked the school system about the teacher's concerns. Here is an e-mailed response from Patterson Principal Laura D'Anna:

I had a message in the bulletin and sent a letter home to the students and community about it.  We could not compromise the investigation or the crime scene.  We followed directions from the Police and Fire Dept.  Students were escorted into areas that were not crime scenes.  Speculation would have caused panic.  This morning we had to administer the PSAT and had Senior inauguration.  Mr. (Roger) Shaw (the system's executive director of secondary schools) came to the building to talk to the administrators. We still do not have any solid information as to what was in the bottles. No teacher was held against their will.  They left with the students and therefore could not be told what happened.  Telling it on a parking lot was certainly not appropriate when we didn’t have concrete information.  Teachers do not arrive until 8:35 when the children arrive.  Therefore no time was available since students come in for homeroom.

Posted by Sara Neufeld at 4:59 PM | | Comments (8)
Categories: Baltimore City, School Safety (Or Lack Thereof)
        

Comments

This has happpened, to a lesser degree, at my school several times in the past few years. Each time, the teachers are treated as if they are being nosy and are told in not so many words to mind their own business. I understand that the "investigation can't be compromised" but situations like this occur enough in baltimore city that at the least there should be some sort of protocol so that teachers and students aren't standing outside clueless for an indefinite time period.

That is a pile of crap from the principal!
She could have either emailed everyone and given them a BRIEF accounting of what happened, or, sent a memo through their mailbox.
Principals do not treat their staff with respect. It is another example of a principals condescending attitude towards teachers and staff. (You are not as important as me: you don't need to know).
When will they ever learn that the truth is always less dangerous than rumors?

To be very honest, I am not shocked by the (lack of) events that took place the day after explosives were found at Patterson High School. As a teacher in the system (not at Patterson), I have found that we often have no idea what is going in our own schools. Are teachers not to be trusted with information that affects them? Are the safety issues of teachers not equally as important as it is for students? I am quite certain that if explosives of any kind were found at city hall, or at a business, that the employees of said business would get a full debriefing the next day.

It really frustrates me that the employees of a school did not get a full rundown of what happened in their place of business-it is their right to know the truth when it is something that greatly concerns them! “Business as usual” at Patterson yesterday? Come on, explosives were found inside the school-that caused one employee to go to the hospital-that merits more than just the old company line.

Once again I am reminded of my worth here in Baltimore City. Another question I had after reading this, why the two different accounts-if the evacuation started at 12ish, why would the school system report 11....?

I can understand not revealing the details of an ongoing investigation, however teachers should be prepped on what to do in the event of an evacuation regardless of the cause.

It is inexcusable to send mixed messages about reentering the building.

Finally, it's understandable that in such a chaotic atmosphere mistakes are made, but at the very least those mistakes need to be addressed with the staff so that they're not repeated.

D'Anna's response focuses on a peripheral issue because that's the only place where she's justified. Her primary responsibility of ensuring safety through preparation of the staff and sending a clear unified message to the school was unfulfilled.

Having worked at numerous schools where similar evacuations have taken place, I can tell you that what the teachers and students experienced is S.O.P for BCPSS and has been for years. There is no standard emergency plan that has been given the schools and few schools have established an effective one on their own. We carry on, in the dark, trying to keep order and protect the students as best we can. In this day and age it's criminal that there aren't policies in place that can be implemented the minute a dangerous situation arises.

Just thought I'd share something that Fairfax County in Virginia has. It's quite impressive.

http://www.fcps.edu/emergencyplan/

http://www.fcps.edu/fts/safety-security/publications/cmw.pdf

The building was evacuated at 12:05, as the teacher said. I don't know where the 11:00 information came from in the article, but it seems wrong.

Different teachers, depending on where they were standing during the time outside, may have had more or less information than others. What follows was my experience. Similar to the teacher who e-mailed, I did not receive an explanation in the time outside, but I did receive instructions from administrators. When students were told they could go home, they were clearly told they could not go back in the building at that time: they were given the choice of waiting to get back in to get their belongings, or traveling home without them. Most went straight home and collected their belongings the next day, before or after PSATs were administered.

Wednesday 10/15 there was a memo in our mailboxes (in the daily bulletin), as Principal D'Anna mentioned, contrary to Susan's point above. Later in the day, all students and staff received a letter about the incident as well. This morning, all school systems employees received an e-mail from Dr. Alonso about the incident. Finally, discussion of the incident is on the agenda for academy meetings during Professional Development today.

While it would have been good to know what was going on while we were standing outside and seeing the helicopters and Hazmat trucks, I don't think the handling of the incident is as poor as some suggest.

The school system acknowledges that it gave media the wrong time of the incident. The first explosion occurred around noon, as the teachers said.

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "a" in the field below:
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

2011 Valedictorians and Salutatorians
Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
Education news
• InsideEd's glossary of education jargon

School closings and delays
Baltimoresun.com's school closings database is designed to provide up-to-date, easy-to-access information in the event of inclement weather.

Find out if your school is participating and sign up for e-mail alerts.
Sign up for FREE local news alerts
Get free Sun alerts sent to your mobile phone.*
Get free Baltimore Sun mobile alerts
Sign up for local news text alerts

Returning user? Update preferences.
Sign up for more Sun text alerts
*Standard message and data rates apply. Click here for Frequently Asked Questions.
Spread the word about InsideEd
Blog updates
Recent updates to baltimoresun.com news blogs
 Subscribe to this feed
Stay connected