Teachers work-to-rule
Hundreds of Baltimore County teachers yesterday participated in a work-to-rule job action to demonstrate how much the system relies upon the time they put in beyond their contracted hours.
One teacher, Natalie Avallone of Patapsco High School, wrote an open letter to her fellow teachers about why she decided to work-to-rule. Here's her letter, which she has given us permission to share:
"Why I will work to rule.
What’s the point? It’s not like it will make any difference to lawmakers, right?
I’ve heard this opinion from my fellow peers too many times to count. The sad thing is that it’s true. Jim Smith isn’t going to care one way or the other if I walk in at 7:00 am, when I usually arrive, or 7:30 when I am contractually required to be here. No delegates or board of education members will be watching as I leave the building at 2:30 with a stack of papers still to grade on my desk.
But, I wouldn’t be writing this now if I thought working to rule was totally useless. In fact, I think it is essential that we commit ourselves to this symbolic gesture because it isn’t the lawmakers we are trying to educate. Sadly, the only lesson they seem to be interested in learning is how to get re-elected.
As teachers we are dedicated to the lives and education of our students. Who among us would truly jeopardize that in the name of money? We came to this profession because we are passionate about learning, not about the paycheck. We are willing to accept a sub-standard professional salary because we believe in what we do and that it makes a difference. Yet, we deserve better. It is not fair that children should have to pay the price for the fiscal woes of the education system or the government that funds it. Most of our students do not even have the ability to control what their teachers make, not having the franchise to elect officials that would better support our teachers and educational system. And maybe that is why schools, year after year, struggle financially through fundraising to support the “extras” like publishing the school paper or purchasing athletic uniforms.
So, if I can’t sway the lawmakers by working to rule, who exactly am I trying to influence, you may ask? The voters. Yes, it all comes back to democracy. And you can thank your 8th grade social studies teacher because you knew my answer already – didn’t you. When I walk in at 7:30 am on April 1st, I hope the community surrounding my school is watching because it is them that I am trying to educate. And if there are teachers walking in to every Baltimore County school at 7:30 am on April 1st it isn’t just the neighbors that will notice, but the media. The parents and grandparents, aunts and uncles, friends and neighbors of our students need to understand why we deserve a fair salary so that when they step into that election booth each November, America’s future is first and foremost in their minds.
I want the voters of Baltimore County to realize that despite that “seven hour contract day,” there are teacher’s cars parked in the lot long before 7:30 am and well after 2:30 pm, every day, and not just on week days. That even though our contract grants us a half an hour duty free lunch, most of us spend it with our students. That even though we work ten months of the year, school runs through the summer and many teachers must work in order to offset the fact that for two months we don’t get a paycheck. That even if I pull out of the lot at 3:30 pm on a typical day to pick up my daughter at daycare, I do so carrying a bag of papers I still have to grade. That even though I have nine years of experience, a Master’s degree and National Board Certification, I have chosen to remain in Baltimore County because I love my school and not my paycheck.
With the third highest turnover rate in the state, quality teachers are leaving this district for better pay and more respect. My hope is that our “students” are paying attention on April 1st, because it is the state of the Baltimore County School System that is on the line. And as a teacher in that system, I want it to be the best school system that it can possibly be.
That is why I will work to rule on April 1st and you should, too."
***
Anyone else care to share whether they are working-to-rule and why? Drop us a line here at InsideEd.






Comments
Ms. Avallone writes a very well-stated letter. Bravo! In a nation as wealthy as ours, we absolutely must support our most critical segment of society.
It is common knowledge that we can gauge the number of prison spots we will need 25-30 years down the road simply based on current literacy rates. Imagine the money we could save on punishment down the road, if we invested it in EDUCATION now. Seems like a no-brainer to everyone...except our elected officials. What a pity.
Posted by: Artie | April 2, 2008 12:54 PM
Jim Smith keeps saying that there is no money to give cost of living raises to any County employees - it's just not responsible. Does he get a raise this year? What about the superintendent, Dr. Hairston? Rumor has it he is to receive quite a hefty salary increase next year. What's fair is fair - why does doing what is "fiscally responsible" only apply to those of us not making six figure salaries or the money decisions??? If teachers, police officers, firefighters, school nurses, etc. get nothing, neither should anyone in the county government!
Posted by: Sharleen | April 2, 2008 3:08 PM
I did the work to rule yesterday. I left for school at 7:20. It was really nice I even ate ate breakfast with my fiancée . I gave myself 45 minutes to get to school. It normally takes 20 minutes. I was so scared that there might be an accident and I would end up late so I gave myself plenty of time. I then taught my classes. I had to use my planning time to call parents because I knew that I wanted to leave on time at 3:05. I left at 3:10.
Normally I arrive at 6:30 in the morning. I usually leave between 4:30 and 6:30 at night. I spend at lot of time preparing supplies so that my students can work on interesting extensive projects. I take photo's of their work and post them on a website. I set up field trips. I do three different afterschool clubs. I spend an hour or more a week contacting parents, sometimes trying five different phone numbers that are no longer working.
I think I might work less now. I can just go to work. I can make the lessons less elobrate. I can cancel afterschool clubs. I do not need to call parents as much.
I also found out today that my positon will only be .7 next year. Last year I had to find a new school because I was excessed. This makes me wonder where all the money is going. I teach 5-6 classes a day. The school is not getting smaller. The class sizes will grow and teachers will get paid less to teach more.
Posted by: Anonymous | April 2, 2008 3:35 PM
I joined many of my colleagues yesterday, and plan to reduce my hours as much as possible without inconveniencing MYSELF.I arrived at work and was on duty at 7:30 AM, and left at 2:30 PM. Generally, I work such long hours that I actually felt like I was cutting school by leaving on time!
I know of at least six teachers who have finally had enough and are actively seeking jobs in other counties.
Once more, feel the need to say it: no raises for higher-level employees (notably Joe Hairston) if there is no money to fund raises for all county employees. Either everyone takes the hit, or the hypocrisy is recognized for what it is.
Posted by: Mary | April 2, 2008 7:55 PM
As a high school teacher whose students were openly curious when they saw their classroom teachers in the parking lot instead of in their classrooms at 7:10 and exiting the building en masse at 2:15 for the past two days, I am positive that there have been conversations taking place at family dinner tables and on car rides home over the past two days as work to rule is a highly visible reality for our school communities. I urge all Baltimore County families to take their conversations to their neighbors and friends. I hope many of you will consider voicing your desire to Jim Smith and the school board for pay that will help attract and retain top notch educators for Baltimore County.
Also, I really hope that Anonymous' comments are somewhat tongue in cheek. After just two days of working to rule, the pinch of what is missing is already being felt by students and teachers at my school as our time together is at a premium. I believe a truth magnified by this exercise is how our school community thrives on interactions and activities beyond the end of day bell. The conversations with parents and students are essential and the tutoring and coaching and creating that takes place after hours is frequently the gem of the educational experience for many kids and educators alike. Baltimore County teachers want to continue to provide this kind of environment for our students and deserve a fair wage as we do it.
Posted by: Heather | April 2, 2008 10:04 PM
Working to rule was extremely difficult for me- as I usually arrive at 6:30 and leave around 4:30, working 7:30-2:30 was nearly impossible. I went to a meeting today and was asked why I was "working to rule". The meeting was with some community members as as well those involved in education within the district. I simply asked- "what time does your day start?" "8:30" was the reply. I asked "what time to you get in each morning?" "usually around 8:30" was the reply. I said- " you work to rule"
The fact is- I feel it is impossible to work to rule and get my job done. I am so frustrated with ignorant people and a blind county executive that I can do nothing more than focus on getting the word out at this point.
Fact finding reports have revealed what TABCO has been saying all along- why can't the public and the county executive see that he is hiding money!
This has nothing to do with being fiscally prudent- this has to do with telling lies and denying the truth in order to "be political".
The public needs to realize that QUALITY teachers DESERVE QUALITY salary. Teachers (especially those who teach my subject) are leaving for other professions where they can make twice as much money. These teachers are good teachers- teachers that are not only qualified but teachers that are respected within their schools and communities. It is sad to see education become more and more undervalued each year.
Posted by: Anon E Mous | April 3, 2008 6:07 PM
I am doing my best to work-to-rule--hours-wise, anyway. I have an intern who needs my support in order to plan her lessons. I am being compensated by her university, so I'm cutting myself some slack when it comes to running out the door at the exact end of my contracted hours. However, I will not meet with or talk to parents, unless they are available during my planning time--or the handful of minutes between afternoon bus duty and "quittin' time." And that's only AFTER I've had a chance to use the restroom! I won't spend my own money on anything for school unless it's a direct benefit to me--like my favorite overhead pens, for example. I'm ashamed to admit that I will continue to grade tests at home. If I graded student work at school--and only during my planning time--I would not have time to do anything else. Grading 25 second-grade math tests takes about an hour and a half. I get 50 minutes of planning time each day. When would I plan tomorrow's lessons? When would I make the copies? When would I go look for the books I need to teach those lessons? When would I type up notes I need to present at a team meeting tomorrow? For that matter, when would I write the sub plans for the substitute who will cover my class while I am at the team meeting? And what if some of my little charges act up while they are at art or music? Even if the special teacher "handles" the problem, the classroom teacher always ends up involved somehow.
Basically, my version of work-to-rule is more like planning-time triage. Activities most critical to my own functioning in the classroom will be handled first. Everything else will fall after that on the to-do list. When my contracted time runs out, so will I! All teachers know that I will be LUCKY to rustle up a couple of resources, fill out a form or two, quickly confer with my teammates about our field trip, and make 2 or 3 sets of copies in my 50 minutes. {What is she, crazy?? Doesn't she realize that the server is down, the copy machine needs toner, we are all out of paper, and someone threw out those books she's looking for back in the '90s! She's gonna fill out a form, talk to the ONE of her teammates who is not on the phone with a parent or currently in the restroom, and then spend the remaining 30 minutes of her planning time wrestling the copy machine and machete-chopping her way through various dusty, funky, mouse-infested closets looking for the non-existent books!}
I hope I--and all of the other caring BCPS teachers--have the willpower to stay "on-task" with this work-to-rule. We must show the consumers (taxpayers/parents/registered voters) what they would REALLY get for the money the county pays us. Our jobs CANNOT be performed in the time for which we are paid. The vast majority of us are more than willing to work many hours for free. The consumers will not realize the value of our collective charity until we stop providing it. When our customers begin to miss all the value-added service we have been providing for free, maybe they will support us in our quest for adequate compensation.
"Don't know what you got till it's gone..." (from Cinderella, 80s hair band)
Posted by: Kathy | April 3, 2008 7:43 PM