baltimoresun.com

« Mayoral oversight | Main | "Wire" conference in Leeds »

November 13, 2009

What can we learn from each other?

Mark and I are brainstorming some things that we saw while abroad. Obviously, I didn't need to travel thousands of miles to know that Baltimore and London are very different cities with very different challenges. But based on your experiences, and the dispatches that Mark and I have posted on this blog, what do you think our cities can learn from each other?

Posted by Justin Fenton at 8:56 AM | | Comments (3)
Categories: Justin Fenton
        

Comments

To me, the number one difference between Baltimore and London and a number of other thriving cities is access to safe and reliable transportation. Say what you will about the Tube and it's numerous service outages, it beats the Baltimore Busses any day. Even if someone wants to work hard and make a future for themselves, they can't get to the jobs. In cities like London, Boston, and New York, they can. Given the choice between getting up at 4 to take two or three busses out to the 'burbs for work, who wouldn't just give up?

I'd like to know how cities like Liverpool and Manchester (which are really better objects of comparison than London) manage to have so little crime and yet have so many of the same socio-economic challenges that places like Baltimore, Philladelphia and Detroit have. Is it the lack of guns? Is there a cultural factor? is it better policing? I'd like an open and honest discussion about this.

To say that "cities like Liverpool and Manchester... manage to have so little crime and yet have so many of the same socio-economic challenges that places like Baltimore, Philladelphia [sic] and Detroit have" is to be unrealistic in assessing the real points of difference.

The United Kingdom does NOT have the same "socio-economic challenges" that American cities do; note the access to public health care systems, the national subsidization of higher education (indeed education in general), and the stark differences in criminal enterprise - comparisons in these respects are moot and reveal a major discrepancy in social welfare - and that solves Rich's conundrum...

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

About 'Crime: A Tale of Two Cities'
When "The Wire" gained popularity in Great Britain, we were contacted by a London-based journalist who proposed a job swap. Mark Hughes, a crime reporter with The Independent, a national newspaper in the United Kingdom, wanted to come to Baltimore to see if the city’s police officers, drug dealers, prosecutors and politicians bore any resemblance to those on show. We agreed to complete the exchange by sending our police reporter, Justin Fenton, to London to compare crime trends. We’ll publish some of their work in the print edition of The Sun, and more observations will be available here.

Local media coverage
• 105.7-FM The Fan: The Ed Norris Show
• WBFF Fox45: London Reporter Greeted with Crime - John Rydell
• WAMU 88.5-FM: "The Wire" Inspires Trans-Atlantic Reporter Exchange



An American in London
Justin Fenton has covered crime for the Baltimore Sun for five years, in suburban counties and Baltimore City. His award-winning work has included coverage of the Amish schoolhouse slayings in Lancaster, Penn.; a 16-year-old boy who executed his parents and two brothers in their sleep; a three-part series about the odyssey of a female serial con artist; and a small town’s crippling baseball stadium deal with a hometown athlete.

Justin's articles from The Baltimore Sun
• Crime and race: A different world (November 27)
• Britons reject likening crime levels to Baltimore's (December 7)

A Brit in Baltimore
Mark Hughes is the crime correspondent for The Independent newspaper in Britain, a national daily based in London. He has covered the goings on at Scotland Yard, and further afield, since 2008. Previous to that he was the paper’s north of England reporter, working from Manchester. He joined The Independent in 2007 after three years working on a regional newspaper in Carlisle.

Mark's articles from The Independent
• Just minutes after I arrived, I was at the scene of a shooting ... (November 7)
• 189 homicides this year – this is The Wire, only real (November 9)
• The trials of 'Baltimore's Boris' (November 10)
• 'Wire' star joins real fight against crime (November 11)
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Baltimore Sun crime coverage
Articles by Justin Fenton
Crime headlines
Blog: Baltimore Crime Beat
A roundup of crimes reported in Baltimore City and Baltimore County
Baltimore City homicide map
Most Recent Comments
Stay connected