Driver sues family of dog he hit
Not long after Fester, a brain-damaged miniature pinscher, was hit by a car and killed in Minnesota, a lawsuit was filed.
By the driver.
Jeffery Ely is asking for $1,100 in damages, which includes the cost of repairs to his 1997 Honda Civic, the time he had to take off from work to get his car fixed and court fees. Pieces of his bumper were propelled into the radiator when he struck the 13-pound dog, Ely said, necessitating a replacement.
According to a story by the Duluth News Tribune, the case will be heard in St. Louis County Court tomorrow.
Fester's owner, Nikki Munthe, said Fester squeezed out the door of her home near Cloquet in January and ran into the street, where he was struck by Ely’s car and killed instantly.
Fester, she said, had suffered seizures as a reaction to vaccines as a pup, causing brain damage. The family named him Fester after the character from the Addams Family because “he really was not that bright,” she said.
Ely said he feels sorry for the family’s loss but feels they should be held responsible for their pets’ actions. He spent more than $600 putting a fence in his backyard to keep his own dogs contained. “I have complete compassion for them,” Ely said. “I know how it feels. I love dogs. But once you get them, they are your responsibility.”
The Munthes have filed a countersuit.






Comments
Yeesh. Won't insurance just pay for the damages without having to sue the family and cause more trauma?
Posted by: Marie | May 8, 2008 10:39 AM
Wow. True dog lover there. Hate to break it to him but that's not anywhere near "complete compassion." Get your insurance to fix it and get over yourself. Or use your tax rebate check to cover it.
I would be absolutely devasted if I hit and even hurt a dog with my car, muchless killed it. I'd be in therapy for weeks! Then again, that may be what this guy needs.
Posted by: Carey | May 8, 2008 1:14 PM
Hopefully both of these suits will be thrown out. I feel for the family whose dog was killed but suing each other sets a bad precedent. If it was done on purpose, that's an entirely different matter. Accidents should be covered by insurance. What do they do when kids run out in front of cars and the car gets damaged? Seriously, I'm asking. Doesn't insurance cover them as accidents?
Posted by: Linda | May 8, 2008 8:34 PM