A video quiz: Who should be caged?
(A) Pit bulls
(B) Humans
We bring you two videos today (for best results, play them simultaneously) -- on the eve of a council meeting in Baltimore County to discuss a proposal to require pit bulls be muzzled in public and caged in private.
The proposed "breed specific legislation," as it has become known, provoked the most comments ever received on this blog, all of which, as of today, have been passed on to all seven county council members via email. The council's work session is scheduled for 2 p.m. tomorrow in Towson.
Almost unanimously, those commenting here -- including several from jurisdictions that have passed such laws -- agreed that the proposed legislation is a foolish pursuit.
When a pit bull, or any dog, behaves violently, it's almost always because that behavior was instilled and encouraged by a human -- and if anyone belongs in a cage, it's the latter.
I would even go so far as to say a pit bull -- raised with love -- is a much more predictable animal than a human.
As a society, we've never been much for looking into the causes of violence. Politicians prefer grandstanding; with or without the facts at their side, which is one reason for my earlier tongue in cheek proposal that they, not pit bulls, be caged and muzzled.
Once we get that accomplished, we might want to move on to professional athletes.






Comments
This is a classic example of what I've begun to think of as "junk legislation." The legislators (at whatever level) get to use their powers to enact grandiose, sweeping laws that make them feel good and score a few points with some of the voters. Careful research and rational thought are optional. The rest of us are then left to deal with the mess.
I feel certain that all the illegal dogfight operators, dog abusers, and negligent owners in Baltimore County will rush to comply with this law if it's enacted.
Posted by: Anne | October 8, 2007 9:32 AM
I'm not entirely comfortable with your comparing black athletes to animals.
Posted by: David | October 8, 2007 10:10 AM
So insightful. Isn't it interesting how in the video's of the humans, the author focused on members of the society we idolize? Is it any wonder this country has so many of the problems we have?
And we wonder why "dogs misbehave". They act like their owners. Violent, undisciplined, unrestrained, and spoiled rotten.
Wake up, grow up, and take responsibility! It's the owners.
Posted by: Thad | October 8, 2007 10:39 AM
David,
Off base as you were, I decided not to throw your comment out. I didn't keep a tally, but the sports video didn't seem to focus on "black athletes" -- just athletes, many of whom, despite being well fed and cared for, can become unpredictably violent without warning. Not all of them, mind you. I'm not making any blanket statements. But I think some of them need to chill out, or maybe stop and smell the tiger lillies
Posted by: john | October 8, 2007 11:07 AM
Thank You John for your great articles. It would be very refreshing to think that the city council would apply common sense to their legislation but for some reason I still have a bad feeling in my stomach about this vote. This will be like most other laws that are passed the responsible citizens will be hurt, while it is business as usual for the criminal element.
Posted by: Tim Chamberlin | October 8, 2007 9:36 PM
You didn't see the white athletes in there, too? This is as much a race issue as it is a breed issue. (Read: it is neither.)
Another spot-on column. I sincerely hope the proposed legislation is defeated.
Posted by: Lindsay | October 9, 2007 12:43 AM
Thanks so much for your continuing support of pitbulls, and dogs in general. I actually know the owner of the dog from the video you posted through an online group, and Roxy is the the most obedient, well trained dog, with an equally devoted mom!
Posted by: Emily | October 11, 2007 1:07 PM
I love that first video.
Mine used to start his day off by sniffing the Peace Lily House Plant each morning.
If only the Pit Bulls could introduce legislation and pass Bills,
I think perhaps it would be a better world.
I didn`t notice the color of the athletes when I watched that video.I went back and watched it when I read David`s comment.
I think David needs to stop and smell the flowers.
The 1st brings tears of joy to my eyes.
The 2nd video is just plain sad.
I really think it`s time for worldwide responsible Pit Bull owners to just take a stand and defy all these legislators.
They won`t listen to Science and facts and there seems to be almost no commonsense.
I wonder what it will take before we all just stand up and say NO to them.
Posted by: MG | May 14, 2008 10:58 PM