EPA leans on Amish farmers in Pennsylvania
Maryland farmers aren't the only ones getting closer scrutiny from the feds these days. It turns out that inspectors from the Environmental Protection Agency have been paying calls on Amish farmers in Lancaster County, PA to impress on them the need to keep manure from their livestock out of the rivers and streams that feed into the Chesapeake Bay.
Lancaster is farming country, and is a leading source of runoff of the nitrogen and phosphorus that produce dead zones in the bay every summer. As The New York Times reports, EPA checked 24 farms in Lancaster last September, 23 of them run by members of the Plain Sect who shun modern technology and can be frequently seen traveling the roads there in horse-drawn buggies.
Seventeen of the farms checked were not handling their manure properly, EPA inspectors found, contaminating their own wells in many cases as well as polluting nearby streams. Farmers were advised to take steps to handle their manure better, and offered help applying for government grants to pay for storage pits and other practices designed to curb runoff.
It's a jarring change for the Amish, who normally want nothing to do with government. But as the story noted, Amish farmers control more than half the farms in Lancaster, so it would be impossible to clean up without them.
More than 500 farms in Maryland applied last year for discharge permits after EPA officials advised that runoff from around their chicken houses and other livestock operations could subject them to enforcement action. Some farmers in Pennsylvania and Virginia are getting less-gentle reminders from EPA. The agency announced recently that it had cited an egg-laying farm in Pennsylvania and two farms in that state for allowing nutrients from their animals' manure to wash into nearby streams, which ultimately feed into the Chesapeake.
The Pennsylvania egg-laying farm, with 36,000 hens, also had 80 cows, EPA said, and both operations were discharging to Chickies Creek, a tributary of the Susquehanna River.
In Virginia, federal inspectors found large piles of uncovered poultry manure at a Linville farm with 100,000 chickens, and evidence that nutrients from the piles were getting into a stream that feeds into the Shenandoah River, a tributary of the Potomac River. Inspectors found similar runoff problems at another farm in Timberville with more than 500 cows and nearly 23,000 turkeys.
Both were ordered to stop the discharges, get federal permits for their operations and submit compliance plans for curtailing their pollution.
(AP photo, 1998)







Comments
Go EPA! These Amish are a menace. After you nail them for polluting how about going after them for their disgusting puppy mills?
Posted by: Ron | June 9, 2010 4:58 PM
I first read about the Chesapeake Bay's problems concerning Amish farmers seventeen years ago in National Geographic magazine. The plight of the Bay was the cover story. Let's just say that making constructive adjustments can lead to good things, especially when it comes to restoring the Bay back to good health.
Posted by: Attila the Hon | June 9, 2010 5:14 PM
Just what we need, more bureaucratic harassment of the productive. Unlike the EPA, the Amish actually produce something of value.
Posted by: R686ST | June 11, 2010 2:29 AM
As Attilla the Hon pointed out - this action is long overdue. Good work, EPA.
Posted by: Johnny Oyster Seed | June 11, 2010 7:08 AM
You would think that EPA would give the Amish a break… after all, their carbon footprint can’t be that high. They use renewable energies (wind and water). But I guess not…
Frankly the environmental community looks every day to be nothing more than the Luddite movement revisited. They want us all to live like a bunch of hobbits… burrowing into the ground, and any technology is anathema to them. That is the root of their dislike of the Amish. The Amish standard of living is too high, and they will have to be brought down a notch or two by their betters in the EPA.
TW: The Amish surely do use less electricity, but that's not the issue. It's the huge amounts of manure generated by their livestock. It's getting into local streams and the bay because of Inadequate storage and overapplication of it to crop fields.
Posted by: Radagast | June 11, 2010 12:46 PM
Get Real EPA! How about heading to the Gulf and going after BP and their Oil Gusher! Go after the real bad guys> BP. and leave the Spiritual Farmers alone.
The Amish carbon footprint has to be much lower that even a traditional farm with gas guzzling machinery.
God Save us from ourselves!!!!
TW: Read the post, SRP. The issue with the farmers is not their lifestyle, or their carbon footprint, but the runoff from their farms of manure from their livestock operations. There's such a concentration of farms there with inadequate manure storage and overapplication of manure to fields that it's a major source of pollution in the Susquehanna River - the Cheaspeake Bay's main tributary.
Posted by: S.R.P. | June 12, 2010 12:09 AM
I wish some of these "libertarians" would take a deep breath. They seem to let their ideology get in the way of actually solving some problems. I'm sure they wouldn't hesitate to call the authorities (government) if someone backed a truck full of manure to dump in their swimming pool!
Posted by: James Meredith | June 14, 2010 7:24 AM