To save the planet, keep your SUV, ditch the pets
Do dogs take a bigger bite out of the Earth than gas-guzzling sport utility vehicles? That's the contention of a pair of academics in New Zealand, who figure that a medium-sized dog has twice the eco-footprint of a Toyota Land Cruiser.
In Time to Eat the Dog, the real guide to sustainable living, Robert and Brenda Vale calculate that it takes roughly 2.1 acres to produce all the meat and grains consumed by a typical medium-sized pet pooch in a year, compared with about an acre needed to produce the energy burned in the SUV.
The pair, architects who specialize in sustainable living at Victoria University in Wellington, don't just pick on dogs, but go after all pets as another form of conspicuous consumption that's taking a toll on the planet. They suggest those who care about living sustainably but just can't live without a pet consider sharing one with others. Or, they add, get pets that serve a dual purpose, of companionship and food, like say, hens.
Hmm, our two Corgis better watch out.
For more on this, go here and here.
Photo: DON EMMERT/AFP/Getty Images







Comments
As well as supplying the energy, how many trees are needed to offset the high amount of carbon dioxide that is produced by the SUV?
Posted by: Graham | December 23, 2009 10:54 AM
I have a strong suspicion that the NZ duo that worked on this dodgy study made the wrong assumption that pet food manufacturers use human quality meat; sadly this is wrong - dog food tends to come from the unfit for human consumption aka waste.
Posted by: Dog Gifts | January 30, 2010 3:23 AM
They suggest those who care about living sustainably but just can't live without a pet consider sharing one with others.
Posted by: zco corporation | June 23, 2010 8:31 AM
I highly doubt the science behind this study as well. It takes fewer resources to manufacture a dog as opposed to an SUV. Also, the consumption issue isn't taken into account - petrol vs. dog food. Besides, I cannot imagine petting my SUV:)
Posted by: Sherman Unkefer | September 10, 2010 3:15 PM
They can take my dog when they pry him out of my cold, dead hand.
Posted by: Robert | September 14, 2010 11:12 AM