baltimoresun.com

« Kids and traumatic brain injuries | Main | Sleep: Who needs it? »

November 10, 2010

More attachment parenting debate

Novelist Erica Jong's take on modern motherhood and attachment parenting has generated plenty of debate, including on this blog.

Check out the New York Times Motherlode blog, where supporters of attachment parenting respond to Jong's essay.

In turn, Jong responds.

Posted by Hanah Cho at 2:53 PM | | Comments (3)
Categories: Monday reads, Parenting in general
        

Comments

I didn't realize that Jong is 68 years old. So I do think her perspective is different from someone who is currently mothering an infant. And it also reminds me of how Margaret Wentz (I think...) recently said that she can't believe women today purposely choose the shackles that women fough to be rid of--making homemade baby food, line drying cloth diapers, etc. In both cases, it seems like these women know what would make THEM feel victimized or downtrodden and can't comprehend how someone else would CHOOSE to do those things.

That doesnt mean Jong or Wendt have invalid viewpoints. But it is ridiculous to apply those viewpoints to every mother out there.

It's time to stop criticizing the choices of other parents. One point of the feminist movement was for women to be able to choose to work or stay home.
I choose to work and will not criticize another woman's choice to stay at home.
I chose to breastfeed, but not use cloth diapers. I co-slept but did not make babyfood. I tried but could not do the cry-it-out sleep method.
I used methods that worked for us, and it's up to everyone to figure that out. Jong shouldn't criticize the choices mothers make. If 'attachment parenting' wouldn't have worked for her, fine, but criticizing others doesn't add to the discussion.

What MadCow said. I can't say I parent by ideology. In fact I doubt anyone could. Women should support other women. Don't judge!

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

About Hanah Cho
Hanah Cho joined The Baltimore Sun in 2003, just a few years out of college. While covering everything from education to workplace issues to financial services, she also got married and became a first-time mom in December 2009. Now, she’s trying to juggle work and life demands without losing her sanity.

She lives in Columbia with her husband and infant son.

Kate Shatzkin authored Charm City Moms until June 18, 2010.
Follow @charmcitymoms on Twitter
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

My Maryland Family
Most Recent Comments
Photo galleries
Stay connected