She's a he!
Little J. has been mistaken for a girl, most recently at a restaurant earlier this week.
Most times, I laugh it off and politely say, "she's a he."
But it has happened more than a few times that I'm beginning to feel a little offended.
How did you deal with mistaken gender identification? I'm looking for some clever ways to respond.









Comments
"Prettiest boy i know" comes to mind, said with a smile.
Posted by: Baltimocker | September 17, 2010 7:18 AM
That's when my son got his firs thaircut, when he was mistaken for a girl, despite the obvious boy clothes. And when my baby girl, dressed head to toe in pink and wearing a shirt that said "Daddy's Girl" was mistaken for a boy, I didn't know what to say or do.
My MIL says her third boy was always mistaken for a girl and she eventually just started saying thank you (to compliments about how pretty "she" was) because she got tired of correcting people.
Posted by: Kayris | September 17, 2010 7:54 AM
Everytime that someone says "Oh, isn't he cute!" about my daughter, I just smile and say, "Yup, he is!" It's not worth the hassle to argue or tell them they're wrong. I've even had people do that when she was covered in a bright pink outfit with hearts and flowers. People don't always think or look before they speak.
Posted by: Heidi | September 17, 2010 8:39 AM
When my daughter was a baby she didn't have a lot of hair and she was mistaken for a boy quite a lot (eventhough she was dressed in pinkish colors). My husband would get very annoyed and he would point out the mix match. I wasn't bothered by this and sometimes I would say something and sometimes not. Now with my little boy is the same thing (his hair is a little longer)! I guess people are just a tiny bit superficial an they don't pay attention to details. It will pass...
Posted by: barbie | September 18, 2010 2:53 PM
What are you dressing the poor kid in?! Get your son some boyish-manly clothes!!!
HC//I swear, I'm dressing him in some cute boy outfits.
Posted by: minpinmama | September 22, 2010 12:55 AM
My boy is 5, very boy-ish and he still gets it. But now he's old enough that I'm off the hook. He replies very matter of fact "I'm a boy. My name is Julian." He doesn't get defensive or offended like I would, he handles it much better than me!
Posted by: Cara | September 22, 2010 9:27 PM
Ignore the boy or girl comment, just focus on the fact that you have a cute kid. Their identity will soon reveal as the get bigger. Cherish these moment and comments, it will be gone forever before you know it.
Posted by: 4 leaf clover | September 23, 2010 3:36 AM
Most of the time I don't correct them, and just thank them for the compliment. My girl gets mistaken for a boy more often than not. Who can tell when a baby is small, unless they are dressed according to our societal gender codes? I am not going to dress her in pink every day just so that a stranger knows she is a girl when delivering a compliment. If I do correct them, I'll just reply with the proper pronoun inserted, and if they are embarrassed about the mistake I reassure them that there is no way they could be expected to tell the difference. I think it is a shame that people feel they have to worry about such things so early.
Posted by: Anne | September 30, 2010 10:57 AM