Tween Tuesday: Reading lists with gender bias
Liz Atwood brings us this week's Tween Tuesday:
The new Twilight movie is out, but I won’t be going. I’m not really into vampires and my sons think the whole Twilight phenomenon is ridiculous. I guess it stands to reason that tween and teen boys will wonder why girls would be so enthralled with vampires.
A recent article in the Louisville Courier Journal noted the gender bias in today’s movies. The Twighlight movies are for girls. Transformer movies are for boys. This isn’t really new, but I do wonder how teen-agers going out on a date ever find a movie they both can agree on.
Really, I’m more concerned about what strikes me as gender bias in the summer reading lists. Neither one of my boys is fond of reading, but I try to encourage them to read every day. Now that the older one is heading to high school, summer reading is no longer an option, but required. In his case, he must read a book on mythology (OK, that seems fine for boys or girls), but then the suggested reading lists for extra credit strike me as tween girl fare. The choices are Little Women, The Secret Life of Bees, The Bean Trees, Cold Mountain and Stones in Water.
The first three books are novels about girls coming of age, confronting new love, lost parents and freedom. Cold Mountain, a Civil War tale, is told from both a man and a woman’s point of view, although I would argue the heroine is the more interesting character. My son started that, read about 30 pages, and refused to go on. That leaves Stones in Water—about a boy taken captive by the Nazis. I’ve ordered it from Amazon and hope this will be tolerable.
Have you noticed a gender bias in your children’s summer reading lists?









Comments
I think reading lists are skewed towards girls because about the time the guys hit 6th grade they start reading nonfiction material about subjects they are interested in. Girls, meanwhile, are still reading novels. So, by default, reading lists of novels are more likely to have stories girls will like. Whoever made your son's list goofed, also. Girls will read books with a male protagonist, boys will not read a book with a female protagonist. One year I got a book on tape of my son's summer reading assignment and we listened to it on our summer vacation. It worked very well. Good Luck.
Posted by: Mary Clark | July 7, 2010 6:48 AM
The real issue is that girls are able and willing to read books with male protagonists but boys find female main characters unappealing. By continuing to re0nforce this, boys lose out and girls continue to excel in reading and school in general. Perhaps if boys were able to "get into" a book with female main characters they might understand the perspective of girls/women more. A good book is a good book regardless of the gender--or gendered traits--of the main character. Isn't that the rationale behind the traditional canon of dead white men?
Posted by: peg | July 7, 2010 8:59 AM
The short answer is, "Yes summer reading lists are skewed toward girls." This shouldn't be a shock. Most English teachers are female as are the school board functionaries that publicize such lists. Since you are talking about extra credit reading, calling and asking for an alternate title may be appropriate. Or, you can skip all that and just take him to the library.
Posted by: rick | July 7, 2010 11:03 AM
I second Peg's comments. Why are girls expected to read books about men, but boys are not expected to read books about women?
Posted by: Bradley | July 7, 2010 2:47 PM
Meanwhile, boys are reading books about cars, wars, airplanes, astronomy, science, history, computers, video games, sports, and many other subjects. Their reading is different than girls'. They may not read a whole book, just a part that has the information they need. They will read something which may be technically higher than their reading level because they are interested in it. We do them a disservice by primarily using novels and poetry to get them to read. I admit, Harry Potter came along when my son was in the third grade and we used the breaks between books to read the Narnia series, the Redwall series, the Golden Compass series, and even some of the Tolkien books. Note that most of these books are considered pretty good literature but they are all adventures. When you are trying to make a life long reader of a child, you fit the reading to what interests him, then when you have 'hooked' him, you can expand his horizons.
Posted by: Mary Clark | July 7, 2010 9:21 PM
As Peg and Bradley both noted, girls are more willing to read books with protoganists of both sexes but boys will not. Perhaps you should encourage your son to expand his horizons?
This sounds like the BCPS reading list that my daughter had for her GT freshman class last year. If so, all I can say is good luck with the Once and Future King. I know it's a good book, but it's long and even I, a vociferous reader, had trouble wading through that one with the older style of writing. The good news is that the sophomore list is broader; my daughter is currently reading "Of Mice and Men". She read the other required book, "To Kill a Mockingbird" in her 7th grade English class at a private school, so she just needs to look that one over.
Posted by: Mar | July 9, 2010 12:19 PM
The book readings are less among the boys. Many of them are not willing to read books and they likes to watch movies or to go out. But most of the girls are reading books now.
Posted by: good luck charms | July 10, 2010 2:17 PM