Would you use a tummy tub?
Did you catch the Today Show's segment on the "tummy tub," a bucket-like contraption for baby baths that's supposed to simulate the womb? If not, here it is:
Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about the Economy
The thing I noticed was that the babies, while very cute and seemingly happy in the tummy tubs, seemed to be months older than the weeks-old infants who are most terrified (and cold) in the standard infant safety tub. The pro-tummy tub argument on the segment is that babies are warmer and more comfortable in the bucket, which supposedly has an anti-skid bottom. But I would be squeamish about putting a really teeny baby in one. What do you think?
Actually, I think it's terrifying to give a baby his/her first bath no matter what you're using to do it. Terrifying for mom and dad, I mean!









Comments
I watched that this morning... they look dangerous to me, too easy for the little ones to just dunk under !
My wife Stacy had an observation as well... exactly how do you wash them if they are entirely submerged in that confining tube of a tub ?
We'll stick with the baby tubs, even after 4 kids worth of baths :)
p.s. Wouldn't an old 5-gallon bucket be a better option than an expensive designer 5-gallon bucket ? LOL
Posted by: Dave T | May 1, 2009 12:10 PM
It's ...
a baby ...
in ....
a ...
bucket.
I hear that's what Somali pirates use.
Posted by: Dr. Owl Meat Gravy | May 1, 2009 1:13 PM
I think it makes total sense and is a brilliantly simple idea...its just a bucket and you could buy one at your local home depot or buy the "wash pod", another version that I bought...it only cost $25 and seems much more stable/user friendly. Both companies only suggest using from 0-6mos and I have watched some footage on youtube and all babies are either totally chill in it or happy...it similates the womb and keeps the baby warm rather then out in the cool air like other tubs...i think that is half the battle. like any tub you need to be there to support the baby.
Posted by: alex | May 1, 2009 2:50 PM
I didn't see the today show segment but the original use for the tummy tub is to relieve a colicing baby's symptoms. They work very well for that purpose I don't understand why the today show wouldn't have centered the segment around that.
Posted by: Anonymous | May 1, 2009 2:53 PM
Hmmm...Meredith says "I understand babies develop faster in this tub...and are more likely to stand at an earlier age..." and a mom responds with "...that is one of the benefits of the tub..."
C'mon why do so many people seem to be in such a rush for little ones to grow up!!
Interesting point!
Posted by: Laura | May 1, 2009 3:01 PM
"its just a bucket and you could buy one at your local home depot or buy the "wash pod", another version that I bought...it only cost $25 and seems much more stable/user friendly."
Regular buckets don't go through the chemical testing that these do- so who knows what kind of horrible things are in there- phathalates, lead, BPA... I wouldn't want my baby in that!
The Wash Pod is made by Prince Lionheart- a California company. I used it too and agree that it seems much more stable and user friendly- and for half the price!
It's easy to wash them everywhere. Babies are really slippery in the bath- just reach your hand in and wash!
Posted by: Anonymous | May 1, 2009 5:47 PM
These tummy tubs are retarded. I have 12 month old twins and I would NEVER buy these tubs for like $45.00 each...give me a break. Babies are scared of water when they are very,very young not at 9 months as these babies appear to be. Also, there is no way to give a proper bath to a baby in one of these things. So then what!? Oh yeah, pick your baby up and clean him or her and risk them slipping out of your hands and injuring themselves...NO THANKS!! I'll pass..
Posted by: Steph | May 1, 2009 7:20 PM
Not all babies are scared of water at a very very young age. My daughter, who is now 9 months old, has loved bathtime from day one! I wish I would have known about these tubs then. She would love it! And would you really want to wash your baby in a bucket!? They tip over much more easily. Yes, they are a bit pricey for what they are , but so are boppy's and we use them anyway when we could just be using regular pillows. And the fact that they may develop faster is actually a great thing. Because of the risk of sids, babies are spending more time on their backs and developing their motor skills at an older age.It has nothing to do with everyone being in a hurry for their baby to 'grow up'. It just means developing their motor skills a little faster.
Posted by: jennifer | May 1, 2009 8:45 PM
i totally agree my daughter who is now 6 months loves bathtime from day one too. but i do think that they are kind of expensive..
Posted by: moni | May 1, 2009 9:17 PM
I also have 4 children - my youngest is just 7mos. Although these look kind of cute, I usually toss all my kids in the bath together! My favorite thing to bathe a baby is a little seat (plastic - partially reclined - still using for baby #4) that cost about $7 and goes right in the big tub. That, or one of those inflatable duck shaped tubs you can get at Target for $10.
Posted by: Mary T | May 1, 2009 10:02 PM
I think these things are hilarious. The babies don't cry because they are probably confused-- i.e. why did you just put me in a pot, Mom? They do look cozy, though.
Here's another site with Tummy Tub information. It talks about where you can buy them too.
http://www.madnesswithoutmethod.com/2009/05/tummy-tubs-baby-tubs-for-sale-and-in-stock/
Posted by: Chris | May 1, 2009 11:17 PM
Seems a whole lot easier than trying to bathe a newborn in one of those traditional plastic tubs with the little one all moving and slippery and you're trying to keep him/her from slipping out of your hands and under the water...
Posted by: katie | May 1, 2009 11:23 PM
I couldn't resist commenting here, because I just saw these things; and I think they're really dumb. I've taken the liberty of posting a link to this site, because I was glad to see I'm not the only one who is not a fan of these questionable pieces of baby equipment. I don't think they'd be good for newborns, and older babies are, I'd think, past needing a "womb environment".
Posted by: Lisa HW | May 2, 2009 1:51 AM
I got the Tummy Tub for my now 6 month old when she was about 8 weeks because she would get cold in her other tub. I was unsure about this new tub but thought I would give it a try. While you do have to support their heads it solved the problem of her getting cold and the water actually stayed warmer longer. And it wasn't hard to wash underneath her - you just get a cloth and move it down the side of the tub and it slips right beneath her. The Tummy Tub has made bathtime a lot more enjoyable and it's definitely worth the price! While a bucket from The Home Depot may be cheaper it isn't made to prevent tipping and I wouldn't want my daughter chewing on the side of a bucket made to wash floors! I wish I would have had this when my 3 year old was smaller!
Posted by: visalo | May 3, 2009 1:27 AM
I have used the Tummy Tub with two of my three kids and I can't say enough great things about it. My kids were so much happier in this compared to a traditional bath tub and I put them in it at one week old. To address the concerns I keep hearing: They are NOT as prone to tip over as they might look. You decide how full to fill up this tub, so use less water if you are afraid of dunking under. I have found it easier to reach down in to wash my child than to wrestle with a screaming squirming baby in the traditional baby bath tubs. Price, try a less expensive alternative brand if this is an issue. And someone mentioned they would not buy two for their twins...do you bathe them both in infant tubs at the same time now?
Bottom line, you have to use appropriate supervision as with any baby product. And I think you have to try it for yourself before you condemn the product. As someone else mentioned, we used ours often when our babies were excessively fussy and could not be consoled by any other means. The instant they got into that tub, they were calm and relaxed.One final added bonus if you have baby boys, you will not get 'showered' while bathing them in the Tummy Tub.
Posted by: Kathleen | May 4, 2009 11:02 AM
I think the tummy tub is awesome!! I have 4 kids and didn't find this until my last one. I put her in it for the first time when she was 10 days old and she loved it! It is not just a bucket as some say it is. It is specially designed and the babies love it. My youngest is now 10 months old and would prefer the tummy tub to the regular tub.
I say don't knock it until you try it!!
It is not dangerous if you follow the directions, which you should do with anything concerning your children!
Posted by: Laura | May 4, 2009 12:39 PM
I love the Tummy Tub. I have told so many mothers about them.
Posted by: Jamie | May 4, 2009 7:21 PM
Oh my goodness, I've never had any problems washing my babies (and no they weren't ever scared of water) and I never had to buy any sort of contraption, even a run of the mill "baby tub". I just bathed them in the kitchen sink. I can hold/support the baby with one arm (while keeping most of the body warmly submerged) and wash with the other and I don't have to crouch over the tub. And how are you supposed to wash the baby's hair in those tummy tubs? You can't exactly dip their heads backwards in them... People just need to stop spending money on stuff they don't really need. Except for the Boppy. It's waaaaaay better than pillows.
Posted by: Siiri | May 6, 2009 2:07 AM
I just think it's fascinating how this tub has generated more comments than far more interesting topics. Maybe because it involves babies :-)
Posted by: Annelies | May 6, 2009 9:37 AM
Annelies,
What could possibly be more interesting than babies.:-)
Posted by: RayRay | May 6, 2009 10:59 AM
I've never seen a baby "frightened" of water--I think most baby baths are uncomfortable and spooky for little'uns, who don't want to be supine anyway. I've been climbing into the tub with my third since he's a week old--it's a lovely, soothing time for both of us--but I'm going to get a tummy tub just for the photo ops--they look like little sweethearts in a flower pot.
Posted by: Mary | May 15, 2009 2:17 PM