baltimoresun.com

September 6, 2009

Should AP photo of dying Marine be published?

On Friday, I was interviewed on CNN's "Situation Room" for a story about the AP distributing a photograph of a seriously wounded Marine in Afghanistan. The Marine, Lance Corporal Joshua Bernard, died on the operating table not long after the bloody picture was taken. He had been hit by a rocket-propelled grenade.

I am not posting the picture here, nor is the "Sun" publishing it in the paper. CNN also has chosen not to show it. In the CNN interview, I said that if I was an editor of a newspaper, I would not publish the picture. But I also said it is a complicated issue, and that I understood AP's argument for distributing it. 

Here's is a link to the "Situation Room" transcript. Here is a link to an online site where you can see the image of the wounded Marine if you want. But before you click to see the image, you should know the Marine's parents asked AP not to publish the picture -- and now strenuously object to the news service's decision to do so.

UPDATE SUNDAY MORNING: You can read the comments of Corporal Bernard's father, John, on the issue in reaction to this post by clicking on comments below.

I want to know what readers think -- especially men and women who served in the military.

Continue reading "Should AP photo of dying Marine be published?" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 7:31 AM | | Comments (42)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

September 2, 2009

Fox News soars in ratings -- Bill O'Reilly rolls on

The August ratings are out, and once again, the ratings for the Fox News Channel are phenomenal.

Rather than throwing a million pieces of data that every channel is spinning into madness, I ask you to consider just this one: On Sunday night, the third episode of AMC's highly-publicized and much-discussed series, "Mad Men," drew an audience of 1.6 million viewers at 10 p.m. when it debuted. Throughout the month of August, Fox News Channel averaged an audience of 2.29 million viewers during every single hour of prime time. And some nights, Bill O'Reilly drew an audience twice as large as that of "Mad Men."

My question for this news-savvy group of readers: Why? How does Fox News Channel keep running these kind of numbers? (And by the way, what about the relatively small size of audience for "Mad Men"?) 

Continue reading "Fox News soars in ratings -- Bill O'Reilly rolls on" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 6:21 AM | | Comments (84)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

August 18, 2009

Robert Novak on cable TV: A Polarizing Presence

novakI will leave it to his colleagues in Washington to place Robert Novak, who died Tuesday at age 78, on the political and journalistic map.

But it is my job to talk about his TV presence over some 25 years -- most of it on CNN.

Novak titled his 2007 memoir, "The Prince of Darkness," and he was indeed a very dark force in cable TV news contributing mightily to the toxic culture of confrontation, belligerence and polarization that so defines cable TV and American political discourse today. There is no way to be nice about his impact on cable TV during its formative years -- and his contributions for the worse to the tone and style of what passes for political conversation today.

(AP Photo of Robert Novak from 1958)

 

Continue reading "Robert Novak on cable TV: A Polarizing Presence " »

Posted by David Zurawik at 1:21 PM | | Comments (161)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

August 7, 2009

Glenn Beck: Let's hope ad loss makes a difference

aaaWhile I admit to having serious concerns about advertiser boycotts, I am starting to think that things have gotten so far out of control with some of the cable hosts on the so-called all-news cable channels that maybe sponsor pullout is one of the only actions that can make a difference.

I'm talking about TV Newser's report that three advertisers have distanced themselves from Glenn Beck's show on the Fox News Channel in response to Beck calling President Barack Obama a "racist" who holds a "deep-seated hatred for white people."

Beck is only one of several out-of-control hosts who traffick in innuendo, slander, smears and outrageous comments like the ones about Obama.

(Los Angeles Times Photo by Carolyn Cole)

Continue reading "Glenn Beck: Let's hope ad loss makes a difference" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:07 AM | | Comments (98)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

July 17, 2009

Cronkite's death spurs flood of words, memories

As I said in my obituary of Walter Cronkite, in person, he could come off as formal, stiff and even somewhat self-important. But those who worked with and knew him said he had a sense of humor and uncommon kindness.

I saw a bit of both sides of the man over the years in my encounters with him. Let me briefly recount one of those memories before sharing some assessments of Cronkite that didn't make it into my obituary of the legendary newscaster. They come from a Who's Who of television news.

In 1996, he and I sat down at CBS headquarters to talk about a book he was just about to publish, A Reporter's Life. I had been kept waiting a long time while ABC anchorman Charles Gibson posed for publicity pictures and chatted with Cronkite following their interview.

Cronkite, meanwhile, who was already 80 years old at the time, had been running late all day, hadn't eaten any lunch and was not in the best of moods, according to an assistant.

As we sat down, the interview had trouble written all over it. 

Continue reading "Cronkite's death spurs flood of words, memories" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:43 PM | | Comments (13)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

July 14, 2009

ABC's Bob Woodruff says he's off to Afghanistan

ABC News anchorman Bob Woodruff was not able to report from Iraq as planned and is now on his way to Afghanistan, according to an on-air conversation he had from a military transport plane with co-anchor Chris Cuomo on Good Morning America Tuesday.

Woodruff, who is traveling with  Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, was able to land in Iraq Monday. But a sandstorm prevented him from visiting the frontline medical personnel on whom the ABC anchorman had intended to report, according to what Woodruff told Cuomo.

The landing marked Woodruff's return to the country where he was seriously injured by a bomb blast in 2006 shortly after he became anchor of World News, the network's signature evening newscast. Charles Gibson now anchors the telecast.

Continue reading "ABC's Bob Woodruff says he's off to Afghanistan" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 7:30 AM | | Comments (0)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

July 13, 2009

PBS Shines, CNN stumbles in Sotomayor hearings

judyIn my run-up to the Senate Judiciary hearings on Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor, I singled out PBS and CNN, the two TV sites most committed to fact based news and information, as places to turn for TV coverage.

By the end of the morning session, a clear pattern ion the coverage had emerged: PBS was doing an outstanding job, while CNN was offering some of the worst and most distracting coverage anywhere on TV or online. Talk about overproduced and misguided as to where the focus should be, CNN seemed to think its talking-head analysts mattered more than what was happening in the Senate hearing room.

CNN cut away from the opening statements in the hearing room for talk among its experts more than any other news channel -- and when they weren'tcutting away for what was frankly not a very illuminating discourse, there were the commercials. I am glad to see any news outlet make money these days, but if you have to break for commercials, don't keep breaking back to the news set for talking-head chatter during what should be your coverage of the event. (Pictured Judy Woodruff)

Continue reading "PBS Shines, CNN stumbles in Sotomayor hearings" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 10:57 AM | | Comments (8)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

ABC's Bob Woodruff goes back to Iraq

ABC News anchorman Bob Woodruff has reurned to Iraq where he was seriously injured by a roadside in 2006 shortly after becoming anchor of World News.

His first report from Iraq was scheduled to air Monday night on World News with Charles Gibson, but a sandstorm interfered with satellite transmission, according to the network, and the piece is now scheduled to air on Tuesday's Good Morning America. Woodruff is traveling with Admiral Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.

In a blog post written before he left, Woodruff explained his reasons for returning to the conflict that almost took his life.

Continue reading "ABC's Bob Woodruff goes back to Iraq" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 9:38 AM | | Comments (1)
Categories: ABC, Cable and Network News
        

Where to turn for TV coverage of Sotomayor hearings

Wouldn't it be nice if American television cared as much about the composition of the Supreme Court as it did Michael Jackson?

Sadly, that's not the country or the media universe we live in, but the two most reliable sources of news and information in American TV will be on the case Monday morning when the Senate confirmation hearings on Judge Sonia Sotomayor begin.

Cable channel CNN and the NewsHour with Jim Lehrer will offer live coverage, and that means everyone with a TV set will have access. For Maryland viewers, the good news is that Maryland Public Television says it will carry the NewsHour coverage -- local carriage is not an automatic, as local PBS outlets can opt out.

Continue reading "Where to turn for TV coverage of Sotomayor hearings" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 6:00 AM | | Comments (1)
Categories: CNN, Cable and Network News, MPT, PBS
        

July 11, 2009

CNN, PBS offer full coverage on Sotomayor hearing

Wouldn't it be nice if American television cared as much about the composition of the Supreme Court as it did Michael Jackson?

Sadly, that's not the country or the media universe we live in, but the two most reliable sources of news and information in American TV will be on the case Monday morning when the Senate confirmation hearings on Judge Sonia Sotomayor begin.

Cable channel CNN and the NewsHour with Jim Lehrer will offer live coverage, and that means everyone with a TV set will have access. For Maryland viewers, the good news is that Maryland Public Television says it will carry the NewsHour coverage -- local carriage is not an automatic, as local PBS outlets can opt out. 

Continue reading "CNN, PBS offer full coverage on Sotomayor hearing" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:09 AM | | Comments (14)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

July 10, 2009

President Obama gives CNN "exclusive" access

I admit it, I get edgy every time I see an email from a network or cable news division that boasts of President Barack Obama granting "exclusive" access to an anchor, correspondent or the news division itself.

It signals that the Obama administration is up to one its oldest and most masterful games of selectively granting access to try and get flattering coverage. I wrote about it when NBC's bowing anchorman Brian Williams was allowed into the White House for a highly-rated two-night special, and in advance of ABC's "town hall" meeting on healthcare at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.

And now, comes this email from CNN with the headline: "Anderson Cooper 360 with Exclusive Access to President Obama."

I've been wondering when Team Obama was going to try to work its game on CNN. Et tu, Anderson?

Continue reading "President Obama gives CNN "exclusive" access" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:10 AM | | Comments (17)
Categories: Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

July 3, 2009

No holiday for TV channels chasing Sarah Palin news

You can tell a lot about a news operation by how it responds to a breaking news story on a holiday or weekend when the A-Team is away.

I first wrote that in November about cable coverage of the Mumbai attacks and the sorry performance by MSNBC, which mainly stuck to its canned lineup of prison documentaries while CNN and Fox scrambled to cover the story live.

Well, Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin dropped a political bombshell late Friday afternoon in announcing that she would resign only two and a half years into her term, and it was fascinating to watch the 24/7 channels already in holiday mode chase the story.

MSNBC responded this time. Even though the program guide had a prison documentary slated for the 4 p.m. hour, MSNBC had Alex Witt at the anchor desk and such analysts as A.M. Stoddard, of The Hill, dissecting Palin's resignation.

Continue reading "No holiday for TV channels chasing Sarah Palin news" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 5:42 PM | | Comments (24)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

July 2, 2009

No spin, just the facts on a slumping Keith Olbermann

MSNBC's Keith Olbermann took offense to a post I wrote Saturday that referred to him as "slumping." He didn't dispute any of the facts in my piece, he just went on the attack with his usual innuendo, slurs and bombast over my characterization of his performance in the ratings. 

Here are two graphics from tvbythenumbers.com tracking Olbermann's ratings the last six months. Read them and judge for yourself whether the adjective "slumping" applies.

No spin, just the facts. Especially note the one that shows him down 50 percent since the last quarter of 2008 in the key news demographic of viewers 25 and 54.

 

Continue reading "No spin, just the facts on a slumping Keith Olbermann" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 5:37 PM | | Comments (35)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

July 1, 2009

Fox News -TV's White House watchdog soars in ratings

Two weeks ago, I praised Fox News for being one of the only TV news operations seriously questioning the administration of President Barack Obama as it pushes an agenda of massive social change not seen since Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal.

Whatever the reasons for Fox's tenacity, I said, it is the one channel that seems absolutely committed to being a watchdog on the White House -- a job crucial to any notion of press responsibility. My post was inspired in part by Obama's petulant sounding complaint about Fox made in an interview with CNBC.

Now comes the ratings data this week showing that Fox, which has long ruled in cable TV news ratings, has entered another league altogether of near-total dominance. I believe this current ratings surge is related to the relentless watch Fox News is keeping on the White House. Viewers are responding to Fox as the cable channel speaking most effectively to citizen questions and concerns about the breakneck pace at which American life is being tranformed. Meanwhile, few hard questions are being asked of the administration elsewhere on television.

Continue reading "Fox News -TV's White House watchdog soars in ratings" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 9:14 AM | | Comments (20)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

May 28, 2009

So, now I'm one of Olbermann's targets -- big deal

So, now I am one of Keith Olbermann's worst persons in the world. Big deal. Too bad.

But I suppose I ought to respond. I would have done so sooner, given that he went after me on his Tuesday night show. But I didn't hear about it until Wednesday morning, and I was busy all day writing a story for the Thursday paper.

That is one of the things journalists do, write stories for Page One. But Olbermann, being a cable host who scabs items out of newspapers and off other peoples' Web sites (stories that they reported) and then bloviates about them, wouldn't know about that.

Continue reading "So, now I'm one of Olbermann's targets -- big deal" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 12:51 PM | | Comments (27)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

May 25, 2009

Angry talk on MSNBC and Fox is bad for the nation

Since an exchange I had on CNN's Reliable Sources Sunday is being batted around elsewhere on the Web, I suppose I should weigh in on it -- or, at least, try to get in on some of the traffic.

The headline is that Lauren Ashburn, managing editor for USA Today Live, and I said that MSNBC and the Fox News channel are bad for America. Here is the way my colleagues at newsbusters.org characterized it. Howard Kurtz hosted the discussion, with BBC America anchorman Matt Frei as another of the panelists.

Continue reading "Angry talk on MSNBC and Fox is bad for the nation" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 12:57 PM | | Comments (36)
Categories: CNN, Cable and Network News, Fox News, MSNBC
        

May 23, 2009

CNN's Reliable Sources: I'll be there Sunday

This probably won't seem as big a weekend programming note as the return of Jon & Kate Plus 8 Monday night at 9 on TLC, but I'll be a guest on CNN's Reliable Sources Sunday morning at 10.

The topic: the way channels that describe themselves as all-news, like MSNBC and Fox, have moved in the direction of all-opinion. I think I referred to MSNBC's Keith Olbermann as a "Bizarro Planet, cartoon version of Edward R. Murrow," but I am not sure. I tend to get rather agitated on this topic as readers of this blog know so well.

But it's a serious matter with profound implications for our democracy, and I thought it was a sound and spirited discussion. Thanks to the Washington Post's Howard Kurtz for hosting it at his lively Sunday morning media salon.

Continue reading "CNN's Reliable Sources: I'll be there Sunday" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 9:31 AM | | Comments (6)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

May 17, 2009

MSNBC missing in action on Obama at Notre Dame

Where was MSNBC Sunday while its two rivals, CNN and the Fox News channel, were at Notre Dame for President Barack Obama's commencement address?

Notre Dame was Ground Zero for a day in America's culture wars, and you have to wonder how a organization that calls itself a news channel would miss it.

Worse, just as MSNBC showed canned specials last November as CNN and Fox covered the Mumbai massacre, so did MSNBC Sunday abrogate its news responsonsibility by showing the canned special, A Killer in the Family. The program featured an interview with Anne Bird, the half-sister of Scott Peterson, who was sentenced to death for killing his wife. The interview was at least two years old.

Continue reading "MSNBC missing in action on Obama at Notre Dame" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 3:40 PM | | Comments (13)
Categories: Cable and Network News, MSNBC
        

May 11, 2009

Jim Lehrer's PBS newscast to get co-anchor, new look

Jim LehrerAfter 14 years of going solo at the PBS anchor desk, Jim Lehrer is expected to announce Tuesday at a programming conference in Baltimore that The NewsHour wth Jim Lehrer will return to a co-anchor format in the fall.

Lehrer, who will turn 75 on May 19, will be joined at the anchor desk by a rotating cast of correspondents including Gwen Ifill, Judy Woodruff and Jeffrey Brown.

The dean of network anchormen underwent a heart valve procedure last year that kept him away from the show for several months. But Lehrer told the Sun he was in excellent health and felt fit as ever as he prepared to moderate a presidential debate last fall. And while he has occasionally been absent from the anchor desk of The NewsHour during the last year, he has been a strong on-air presence through the election and the inauguration of President Barack Obama.

Continue reading "Jim Lehrer's PBS newscast to get co-anchor, new look " »

Posted by David Zurawik at 7:57 PM | | Comments (0)
Categories: Cable and Network News, PBS
        

May 9, 2009

Study finds newspapers trounce TV in self-reporting

As a TV critic writing for a newspaper, I have long argued this case. But I never had evidence like the data gathered by group of University of Pennsylvania scholars who compared the ways in which newspapers covered their declining readership versus how TV news reported (or didn't report) on declining viewership.

Newspapers are far more conscientious in reporting their own bad news than TV is in telling viewers about its loss of audience. Across a nine year span, the Penn researchers found 900 instances of newspapers reporting the story of declining readership. On TV news, meanwhile, only 22 stories appeared.

You do the math, and form your own conclusions about which medium has been more trustworthy in handling a hard story.

Continue reading "Study finds newspapers trounce TV in self-reporting" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 10:22 AM | | Comments (3)
Categories: Cable and Network News, Network TV, Newspapers
        

April 28, 2009

CNN shines in instant coverage of Arlen Specter story

CNN's Dana BashDoes anyone on cable TV cover real breaking news like CNN?

Tuesday when Senator Arlen Specter dropped the bomb that he was switching to the Democratic side of the aisle, CNN was all over it. From Dana Bash (left) reporting the story on Capitol Hill to a team of reporters gathering instant reaction around Washington, while Ed Henry and Bill Schneider offered on-the-run political analysis, this is the way a major story should be covered.

A note to some of my colleagues: Let's stop blindly celebrating the ratings successes of the cymbal-clanging chimpanzees named Olbermann, Maddow, Hannity, Beck and O'Reilly on MSNBC and Fox, and pay some attention to the last real journalism being done on cable TV by the folks at CNN. They did some fast, sound and fine work again on a huge political story -- delivering the journalistic goods once again so that the sit-on-their-butt partisans on Fox and MSNBC will have something to actually talk about Tuesday night.

Continue reading "CNN shines in instant coverage of Arlen Specter story" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 1:13 PM | | Comments (17)
Categories: CNN, Cable and Network News, Fox News, MSNBC, TV and Politics
        

Swine flu: Are media spreading concern or undue fear?

Commuters wear protective masks on the Mexico City subway

As our TV and computer screens fill with more and more images of people wearing masks and commentators looking gravely concerned, it is not too soon to start asking what kind of job the media are doing of covering the swine flu story. Are they responsibly alerting people to dangers and precautions that can be taken, or are they unduly alarming the audience?

Monday night at 10 right after 24, a series that has told its own share of stories about biological warfare and threatened pandemics, area viewers of WBFF's newscast were told that the disease has not yet spread to Maryland, "but experts say it is coming." Viewers were further told that every day "there is more and more to fear" in connection with the spread of the disease.

Dr. Sanjay Gupta, the CNN and CBS medical correspondent, was reporting from outside a hospital in Mexico City using such terms as "ground zero" and "chaos" to describe the situation.

Tuesday morning, on NBC's top-rated Today show, Dr. Nancy Snyderman, the show's health expert, was reporting "a couple of unconfirmed cases in New Jersey."

Continue reading "Swine flu: Are media spreading concern or undue fear?" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 8:17 AM | | Comments (15)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

April 23, 2009

100 days: Obama will mark it in TV sweeps prime time

President Barack Obama wants some more prime-time real estate from the networks Wednesday night, and he doesn't care if it is May Sweeps. Wednesday marks the end of his first 100 days in office, and he's not going to let the TV pundits have the field all to themselves in judging his performance.

The White House Thursday announced an 8 p.m. press conference for Wednesday, and it would be a surprise if the networks and major cable channels did not cover it in some fashion. So far, none has made their plans known, but how could ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN or Fox News not be there no matter how much it might cost the networks in May sweeps ad dollars. (Sweeps are the months in which audiences are measured and used to set future advertising rates.).

Continue reading "100 days: Obama will mark it in TV sweeps prime time" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 5:21 PM | | Comments (2)
Categories: Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

ABC's Stephanopoulos charges on with Ahmadinejad

Mahmoud AhmadinejadLast week in writing about the tight ratings race on Sunday mornings, I used the term "hard-charging" to describe George Stephanopoulos and his ABC show This Week. The charge continues this week with the one-time senior aide to Bill Clinton scoring an interview with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

Stephanopoulos raced off to Tehran when the call came through that Ahmadinejad would be willing to talk -- showing exactly the kind of hustle I believe the healthy competition among the top Sunday morning public affairs shows is generating.

Stephanopoulos also delivered an engaging blog post about the interview and his trip. I wonder how the other Sunday shows will compete with this. This is one ratings race that so far, at least, seems good for journalism.

Continue reading "ABC's Stephanopoulos charges on with Ahmadinejad " »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:32 AM | | Comments (1)
Categories: ABC, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

April 22, 2009

MSNBC's Rachel Maddow suffers big audience loss

Rachel MaddowMSNBC show host Rachel Maddow has suffered some steep audience erosion in recent months, down more than 40 percent in viewership from her peak last fall during the election.

According to the Los Angeles Times, Maddow's audience has gone from a high of 1.9 million viewers in the fall to just over 1.1 million in March. That's a big drop.

Readers of this blog know I am just as troubled by Maddow's brand of ideologically driven partisan propaganda as I am by that of Bill O'Reilly and Sean Hannity on Fox. Maddow was at her worst last week, falsely minimizing the tea parties held across the country as "the fizzle in the drizzle" and mocking the participants.

Continue reading "MSNBC's Rachel Maddow suffers big audience loss" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 10:17 AM | | Comments (124)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

April 20, 2009

Stephanopoulos, Gregory, King: A new golden era?

ABC's George StephanopoulosI started out looking for a story about a Sunday-morning, public affairs ratings race between NBC's longtime leader, Meet The Press, and ABC's hard-charging This Week with George Stephanopoulos. And there is a good ratings battle going on.

But after several weeks of digging into the Sunday morning lineup, I stumbled on what I believe is a larger insight: We are living in a golden age of some exceptionally fine Sunday morning, public affairs, TV programs. And, as much as some critics say an emphasis on ratings often comes at the expense of good journalism, I think this ratings competition is making each of the two top programs better. That and new competition since the start of the year from John King with State of the Union Sundays on CNN.

"When they're going my way, I don't mind talking about ratings at all, " Stephanopoulos said jokingly last week when the subject of Nielsen numbers was raised during a telephone interview.

"But here's why they're important and why I'm not apologetic about paying attention to them: Because what we do, I think, does matter," he added. "And to the extent that it's easier to do that because we see that there's an audience for this kind of journalism, for this kind of serious approach to the issues, is incredibly gratifying. And it makes me optimistic not only about the show, but the future of this niche of journalism."

Continue reading "Stephanopoulos, Gregory, King: A new golden era?" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 7:00 AM | | Comments (3)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        

April 17, 2009

CNBC's Jim Cramer loses it on air -- again

This might be getting a little old for some viewers, but it is nevertheless remarkable that NBC has so little pride in its CNBC brand that it keeps letting Mad Money host Jim Cramer flip out on air.

Here is the latest with Cramer bursting on the set of another show to scream at a guest who questioned the cable channel's "In Cramer We Trust" catchphrase.

 


Posted by David Zurawik at 4:40 PM | | Comments (6)
Categories: Cable and Network News, NBC
        

April 13, 2009

Commander cites Annapolis training in pirate mission

The commander of the Navy ship that rescued an American captain from Somali pirates cited his Annapolis training and a conviction that such kidnappers only understand force in an interview with NBC's Brian Williams Monday night.

Here is some of what Commander Frank Castellano, commanding officer of the USS Bainbridge, says on the NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams Monday:

Williams: Have you had any contact with the Commander-in-Chief other than receiving orders indirectly from him on engagement in this matter?


Castellano: I can tell you I had the pleasure of receiving a phone call from the President last evening. And we had a very wonderful conversation in which he wanted me to pass on to my crew that they did a wonderful job and he was very proud of them and it was a job well done.

Continue reading "Commander cites Annapolis training in pirate mission " »

Posted by David Zurawik at 4:36 PM | | Comments (2)
Categories: Baltimore Television, Cable and Network News, NBC
        

March 31, 2009

MSNBC beats CNN in prime time - and Fox wins it all

For the first in the history of cable TV news, MSNBC has drawn a larger prime-time audience than CNN. And Fox continues to build the largest audience of all from 8 to 11 p.m. each night, the most lucrative part of the broadcast day.

That's the news from the March ratings period, and as much as I would like to be dispassionate about it, I just can't. That's because I know how dangerous a trend we have here with viewers flocking to fiercely-partisan, ideologically-driven opinion-based programs as they abandon productions that seek to provide down-the-middle coverage, verified information and analysis that explores all sides of issues.

In this time of national crisis, it is no small matter that viewers are choosing the bombast and posturing of Keith Olbermann on the left, and Bill O'Reilly on the right  just when sound information is needed more than ever.

Continue reading "MSNBC beats CNN in prime time - and Fox wins it all" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 8:01 PM | | Comments (11)
Categories: CNN, Cable and Network News, Fox News, MSNBC, Ratings
        

March 29, 2009

A focused Schieffer pushes Obama on Afghanistan

Bob SchiefferCBS News has been soft on President Barack Obama in its 60 Minutes interviews by Steve Kroft. But the network's veteran Washington correspondent Bob Schieffer Sunday won back some respect for the news division with a focused and vigorous quizzing of Obama.

Schieffer performed several of the basic interviewing tasks that Kroft inexplicably failed to do last Sunday during the 60 Minutes conversation. With only about 25 minutes of airtime, the host of Face of the Nation asked hard-nosed follow-up questions and even politely cut the president off when he tried to filibuster answers with campaign-mode rhetoric.

But by far, the wisest choice Schieffer made was to focus his interview at the start on the president's announcement late last week that he was sending more troops into Afghanistan. Given the economic crisis, it is perhaps understandable that the press did not pay that much attention to the announcement, but for those who can remember the lessons of Vietnam, it seems like a huge development.

Continue reading "A focused Schieffer pushes Obama on Afghanistan" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:47 AM | | Comments (7)
Categories: CBS, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

March 28, 2009

Why GOP's Michael Steele should stay off TV - way off

Every time Michael Steele goes on TV, it seems as if he says something that makes him seem like a bigger fool.

You would think that after the kind of disastrous TV appearances he has experienced since becoming chariman of the Republican National Committee, he would figure it out and stay as far away from the medium as he can.

But not Steele. Here's a great blog post today from Charles M. Blow, of the New York Times, on Steele's most recent TV embarrassment. Under the heading, "Steele Ridiculous," Blow explores the wacky exchange Steele had with CNN interviewer Don Lemon:

Michael Steele is the gift that keeps on giving. His latest entrée unto the absurd comes in the form of an interview with CNN’s Don Lemon. Steele now wants us to believe that his wayward ramblings are part of an elaborate ruse – some sort of Jedi mind trick. Really?

Continue reading "Why GOP's Michael Steele should stay off TV - way off" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 12:57 PM | | Comments (10)
Categories: Baltimore Television, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

March 27, 2009

President Obama will be back on CBS this Sunday

scAfter a TV blitz that ended with a prime-time press conference Tuesday night, President Barack Obama will be back on the tube Sunday morning chatting with CBS News Chief Washington Correspondent Bob Schieffer on Face the Nation.

The interview will be Obama's first Sunday morning talk show appearance since his inauguration. Last Sunday night, Obama was featured on another CBS News program, 60 Minutes, where he was interviewed by correspondent Steve Kroft.

Obama, who once again proved his ratings magic by driving 60 Minutes to a Top-5 Nielsen finish last week, has seemed to be favoring CBS among the three networks.

Let's hope Schieffer is a little tougher on the president than Kroft was last week. Nationally, Face the Nation is the lowest rated of the network Sunday morning shows, so the appearance by Obama on Sunday is good news for CBS.

Posted by David Zurawik at 2:06 PM | | Comments (0)
Categories: CBS, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

March 26, 2009

Baltimore doctor named CNN Hero of the Week

zeA Baltimore trauma surgeon, Dr. Carnell Cooper, was named "Hero of the Week" by CNN today. He will be interviewed on Larry King Live at 9 tonight. Dr, Cooper will also be profiled Friday on CNN's American Morning.

CNN sent the following information in an e-mail explaining why Dr. Cooper, of the University of Maryland Medical System, was judged to be one of its “ordinary people doing extraordinary things.” 

Dr. Carnell Cooper is a Baltimore trauma surgeon who got tired of patching up young men, only to see them return with another violent injury. In 1998, he started the Violence Intervention Program, one of the country’s first hospital-based anti-violence efforts. To date, he estimates that his group has provided counseling and support services to nearly 500 people. What’s more, a 2006 study authored by Cooper and his colleagues – and published in the Journal of Trauma -- proved the program’s effectiveness. Program members were six times less likely to come back to the hospital with a violent injury, and three times less likely to be arrested for a violent crime.  It’s a track record of success that has made Cooper’s program a model for others around the country.

Posted by David Zurawik at 5:42 PM | | Comments (6)
Categories: Baltimore Television, CNN, Cable and Network News
        

March 24, 2009

Obama's new TV image: tired, uptight and cranky

Barack Obama news conference
President Barack Obama ended his six-night, buy-my-economic-proposal-please TV tour Tuesday with a prime-time news conference. And while not much hard news might have come out of the session, there was at least one major change there to be seen in Obama's TV image.

Gone was the cool, composed, almost serene Obama who seemed to enjoy the back and forth of his masterful first meetings with reporters following his election.

Instead, for the first time, viewers saw a tired-looked president who gave into his irritation and literally snapped at Ed Henry, the senior White House correspondent for CNN. That cable channel has been doing the best reporting on the contradictions by Obama and other administration officials over when they knew about the bonuses to A.I.G. executives. Not surprisingly, it was a follow-up question by Henry about the timing of Obama's "outrage" over the bonuses that set the president off.

Continue reading "Obama's new TV image: tired, uptight and cranky" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 9:10 PM | | Comments (44)
Categories: Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

More prime-time Obama tonight, and we'll be there

This blog has been with President Barack Obama every prime-time step of the way on his buy-my-economic-proposals-please TV tour, and I will be back tonight after his latest appearance on the tube.

Everyone who matters in cable and network TV news is covering it live, so there there will be lots to write about.

Already, I see Keith Olbermann is anchoring MSNBC's coverage. That's the same out-of-control Olbermann who MSNBC executives said they were going to remove from such news events after his childish behavior at the political conventions in August. I guess that was just one of those blah-blah-blah, let's-lie-to-the-peasants, PR statements from the cable channel. Just the kind of folks I want to rely on for trustworthy information.

Posted by David Zurawik at 4:48 PM | | Comments (1)
Categories: Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

March 22, 2009

Kroft, 60 Minutes go soft and safe in Obama interview

Steve Kroft and Barack Obama

If anybody was wondering why Barack Obama chose 60 Minutes as the one news outlet for an interview on his buy-my-economic-proposals-please TV tour, they got their answer Sunday night: Beyond the 16 million viewers who tune in each week, correspondent Steve Kroft played it safe and soft with the President, much as he had done during the election last year.

While I praised 60 Minutes in November for having built a relationship with Obama that yielded great access and ratings for Kroft’s interviews with the then-candidate, I have to criticize the celebrated newsmagazine for being far too gentle with the President on Sunday.

Continue reading "Kroft, 60 Minutes go soft and safe in Obama interview" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 9:30 PM | | Comments (86)
Categories: CBS, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

March 21, 2009

Some praise for good work by ABC News on Geithner

With all the high-visibility hearings on Capitol Hill and President Barack Obama appearing everywhere on TV last week, it is easy to overlook a piece like the one that follows from ABC News and abcnews.com. But this behind-the-scenes bit of reporting is the kind of solid, hard-work journalism that tells you what folks are saying off-camera.

It involves Rick Klein, of ABC News, canvassing members of the Senate Democratic caucus on the question of their support for Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner.

No one covers Congress better than CNN's Dana Bash, as she showed this week in nailing Sen. Christopher Dodd for his role in the A.I.G. bonuses. But this little textbook effort in nuts-and-bolts reporting by Klein also deserves high praise for the information and context it offers viewers trying to judge the confusion at the Treasury Department against President Obama's widely-publicized statements this week that he has "complete confidence" in Geithner.

Continue reading "Some praise for good work by ABC News on Geithner" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 11:12 AM | | Comments (4)
Categories: ABC, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

Obama and 60 minutes: Tune in here for postmortem

Staying locked in the Barack Obama buy-my-economic-plan-please TV tour, I will be writing about the President's interview on 60 Minutes right after it airs Sunday, so please make sure to stop back.

The interview with Steve Kroft was taped Friday, but so far, no major parts of it have leaked out (or been leaked by CBS). Kroft was given unusual access by Team Obama during the election campaign, and his most recent interview with the President was seen by more than 24 million viewers in November. Kroft is scheduled to be a guest on CNN's Reliable Sources show where he will be interviewed by host Howard Kurtz Sunday at 10 a.m. (EDT).

I have a column in Sunday's Sun about Obama's unprecedented TV blitz and the controversy of him spending so much time working the tube, while Washington burns with indignation (and confusion) over the AIG bonuses. The question I pose: We know he is a great media campaigner, but now that Obama is president, is he effectively governing, or spending too much time on TV talking about governing. There is a difference between governing and playing someone who governs on TV.

So read the column, post any comments you have about it here, and stop back to Z on TV Sunday before you call it a night for the latest analysis of TV Obama.

Posted by David Zurawik at 8:54 AM | | Comments (2)
Categories: CBS, Cable and Network News, Coming Soon to TV, TV and Politics
        

March 19, 2009

Barack Obama -- and the presidency as a TV series

Barack Obama at a bill signing

Zbigniew Bzdak/Chicago Tribune
President Barack Obama signs an Executive Order creating the White House Council on Women and Girls in the East Room of the White House last week.

As Barack Obama extends his buy-my-economic-plans-please tour from Jay Leno tonight into next Tuesday with a prime-time press conference, the question that begs to be asked is whether the President is spending enough time governing -- as opposed to talking about governing on TV.

There is a difference, and as much the author of this blog dedicated to mapping the intersection of TV and politics welcomes Obama's commitment to using the tube to sell his proposals, I worry as a citizen that he's not doing the nitty-gritty, late-night, deal-making, closed-door, on-the-phone politicking that it takes to really govern this troubled nation.

I'm talking about the kind of Presidential grunt work that you hear Lyndon Johnson doing on those audio tapes C-SPAN radio plays on Saturday afternoons.

Continue reading "Barack Obama -- and the presidency as a TV series" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 12:50 PM | | Comments (39)
Categories: Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

C-SPAN turns 30 today -- and it's getting younger

C-SPAN, the camera that never blinks in its coverage of American government, turns 30 today. And to celebrate, the cable industry's public affairs channel is releasing a survey that shows 20 percent of cable TV households, about 39 million viewers, watch C-SPAN regularly -- at least once or twice a week.

The survey also shows an audience that is very active politically, fairly evenly split between liberal and conservative viewers -- and surprisingly young with 43 percent of its viewers between the ages of 18 and 49. Ninety percent of C-SPAN viewers say they voted in 2008.

Here are some highlights from the survey that was conducted by Hart Research Associates:

Continue reading "C-SPAN turns 30 today -- and it's getting younger" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 8:54 AM | | Comments (0)
Categories: Cable and Network News, Ratings, TV and Politics
        

March 18, 2009

Obama goes back to 60 Minutes formula on Sunday

President Barack Obama will continue his outside-the-beltway-press-corps campaign with TV viewers via an appearance Sunday on 60 Minutes.

That's the Top 10-rated CBS venue that he used so skillfully during the campaign to bypass the press and reach as many as 20 million viewers in one staraight shot. Sunday he will be selling his embattled economic proposals.

The interview with 60 Minutes will be conducted by Steve Kroft and take place on Friday -- one day after Obama's sit-down with Jay Leno Thursday night on The Tonight Show. Kroft was the correspondent granted unusual access to Obama and his team during the campaign.

Continue reading "Obama goes back to 60 Minutes formula on Sunday" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 1:23 PM | | Comments (1)
Categories: CBS, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

What next on cable TV: Wanted posters of AIG execs?

AIG in Hong Kong 

It has been fascinating and a little scary this week to watch 24/7 cable TV news trying to find the right voice in which to address the rage among viewers over the economy and the bonuses paid to AIG executives.

We are at the point where viewers seem to be demanding a target for their anger, and cable TV wants to give them one. And that is a combustible mix.

Edward Liddy, chief executive of AIG, will provide a focus for much of that anger today as he testifies before a congressional committee about the bonuses paid with taxpayer money to some of the very AIG executives most responsible for driving the economy off a cliff. But now that swindler Bernie Madoff has been convicted, it seems as if the audience is looking for new faces to hate, and 24/7 cable TV is trying to provide them.

Continue reading "What next on cable TV: Wanted posters of AIG execs?" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 7:53 AM | | Comments (1)
Categories: CNN, Cable and Network News, TV and Politics
        

March 16, 2009

Is Obama trying to stiff arm cable TV with Leno visit?

leAs the perception spreads that cable TV news pundits are passing a hasty and harsh judgment on President Barack Obama's economic plans, you have to wonder if there isn't more than meets the eye to the annoucement today that the president will appear Thursday on The Tonight Show With Jay Leno.

Let me put it less delicately: Is Obama giving cable TV, which has seen its ratings and revenues rise with his candidacy and election, the stiff arm by going with NBC and Leno? Is this a taste of what's to come if Sean Hannity, Lou Dobbs and the gang of clowns at CNBC continue to play fast, loose and rough with his presidency? Is Obama going to further bestow his ratings magic on the struggling networks -- as he did with CBS and its 60 Minutes newsmagazine during the election?

There is nothing new about using late-night TV to get elected president. But no one has used that entertainment venue to try and govern as Obama will do Thursday night when he "talks about his economic plan" with Leno, according to the NBC press release.

Continue reading "Is Obama trying to stiff arm cable TV with Leno visit?" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 5:14 PM | | Comments (10)
Categories: Cable and Network News, NBC, TV and Politics
        

State of media report: good news for cable TV, web

The Project for Excellence in Journalism releases its annual State of the News Media Report today, and the news for the press is the worst in the six-year history of the report, according to its authors.

The report is a big one that runs 200,000 words, and there are highlights and lowlights from all media at the end of this post. But since this is a blog about TV, I'll focus on the that medium, where the 24/7 news channels showed not only growth last year, but an increased role in the political life of the nation -- neither of which will probably come as a surpise to those viewers who followed CNN's non-stop political coverage.

Those analysts -- and there were many of them -- who looked at the rise in ratings and earnings for channels like CNN,  MSNBC and Fox last year during the heat of the election and knowingly asserted they would lose it all after November were wrong. The news channels lost a lot of the audience they gained, but they are still ahead of the game -- and that is a big deal for any mainstream medium these days.

CNN's John King
CNN's John King

Continue reading "State of media report: good news for cable TV, web" »

Posted by David Zurawik at 6:28 AM | | Comments (1)
Categories: Cable and Network News
        
Keep reading
Recent entries
Archives
Categories
About David Zurawik
I've been The Baltimore Sun's TV critic since 1989. My writings on TV and media have appeared in such publications as TV Guide, Esquire magazine and American Journalism Review. I have a Ph.D. in American Studies from the University of Maryland, College Park, and an M.A. in specialized reporting (on popular culture) from the University of Wisconsin. I'm the author of The Jews of Prime Time (Brandeis University Press), a look at 50 years of Jewish characters and identity on network TV. I have also been with WYPR-FM (88.1) radio since 1994 and can be heard Thursday mornings at 7:30 doing a weekly "Take on Television" report.
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
What's on TV tonight?
Find it fast
Photo galleries
Baltimore Sun coverage
Z ON TV COLUMN • David Zurawik's "Take on Television"
(Courtesy of WYPR FM)
MORE TELEVISION AND MEDIA NEWS
Stay connected