'Top Chef: Las Vegas': Sin City's full of vices

Howdy folks, Liz and Justine here. We're both business editors who appreciate good food (especially when others cook for us). We'll be here to offer our pedestrian insights and snarky comments about this season of Top Chef.
It's a whole new cast of 17 cheftestants, which makes it hard to keep up with everyone and learn their names. Luckily Bravo only kept up with a few, including Maryland's own brothers Michael and Bryan Voltaggio and Baltimore chef Jesse Sandlin. Even in the opening credits, their sibling rivalry came to a head, complete with cussing each other out in the kitchen.
Other cheftestants have to make their mark by more creative means, including Mattin who is French and wears a jaunty scarf and Kevin with a huge beard. Hector has facial hair, too. This will be a beard-tastic season for sure.
Enough about the fashion -- on to the cooking.
Quickfire
Top Chef delivered on the Vegas showgirls immediately, just like Liz said. A half-dozen appeared on screen for about 10 seconds, just in case you forgot you were in Sin City. (As a side note, did anyone else think judge Tom looked thinner? Liz thought it was the vertical stripe action, but Justine thought he might've lost a few pounds between seasons. Padma looked hot as always.)
The first quickfire challenge divided the chefs into teams of four by choosing poker chips from a bag. Let's see how long they will keep that gimmick up. With an odd number of chefs, Robin drew the gold chip, which gave her immunity and the option to sit out this challenge. It seems silly to not cook when you're on a cooking show, but we guess it's more about strategy this early in the game.
The challenge had them shucking 15 clams, peeling 30 prawns, cleaning 5 lobsters and cutting 2 prime rib chops. Early on, Mike (a "jerkface," as Justine refers to him) cast himself as the villain by saying he couldn't lose to a girl. Sadly, Mike's team did end up losing to Jen C., the girl he shucked against.
This quickfire had a surprise second part where the winning group of four -- cooked against each other to win a $15,000 poker chip (again with the product placement). The catch was they had to cook the item they prepared in the mise en place portion of the challenge.
As much as Bravo built up the sibling rivalry between Michael and Bryan, they were able to put it aside because they weren't cooking against each other at that point in the competition.
Tom called Jesse's prawns and grits "a mouthful of ocean," but even the ocean can't beat the clam ceviche from Jennifer C., so she got the $15k chip.
Elimination challenge
The teammates turned rivals as each group of four had a winner and a loser to go to judge's table, where they'd face a tough critic in legendary chef Wolfgang Puck (who conveniently let them cook in his Vegas restaurant Cut). To reinforce the Vegas theme, the cheftestants had to introduce themselves through cuisine by representing one of their vices.
Off to Whole Foods! (How far away from the Las Vegas Strip did they have to drive to find a Whole Foods, we wonder.) A budget of $150 and 30 minutes to shop of course put these first-timers in a tizzy as they frantically scoured the store for their specialty ingredients, the oddest of which may have been Jennifer Z.'s seitan (a wheat gluten protein -- we had to Google it). Thank goodness they were at Whole Foods.
Many of the vices were boring and full of alcohol. The most creative jaunty red scarf Mattin's Buffalo rib-eye and zucchini with mashed potatoes who referenced his astrological sign but didn't clearly reference a vice. Robin finally decided to cook for the elimination challenge, citing her vice as being a "bad Jew" who enjoyed pork. One of the components of her dish didn't make to the plate, but her pork tenderloin with chorizo and bread pudding was still clever.
The Maryland brothers, while on different teams, both got very good comments from the judges (Bryan, while Puck said he made "steak and baby food" because he put put pureed sauces on the plate, made a well-executed dish with the beef cooked and rested perfectly; Michael's rack of lamb with coconut sauce and gnocchi was "professional" though it was a little weird that his vice was Vegas' plastic surgery -- note the rack and coconut).
The Marylander who disappointed, Jesse, knew before the judges even said anything that her chicken had been a disappointment because the chicken breast was dry. The judges liked the flavor, though, so it seemed pretty clear that while she had the worst dish of her team, she wouldn't be eliminated.
The team that seemed to have the weakest dishes was Ash, Jen Z., Ron and Laurine. Jen Z.'s stuffed pepper didn't even look appetizing, and the judges weren't impressed with the flavor, either. She said she wanted to make a statement of being bold and taking risks by using seitan, she wanted the dish to represent her temper. "I'm mad as hell but good for you" -- the judges complained about the lack of spice. Gail (she's so cute!) said "there's no heat" and the rest of them nodded.
The dish Justine was most excited for, Laurine's bacon doughnuts with some sort of lambic beer and chocolate sauce, didn't get rave reviews. Puck actually threw a doughnut across the room to emphasize his argument that they weren't fluffy enough. They did love the sauce, though, and with Jen Z.'s terrible pepper, Laurine could've made chocolate-coated bacon and been safe.
Judges' table
They called the winners in first, with Padma looking very stern, sad and official (as always). Ron, Jerkface Mike, Kevin and Jennifer were the winners of their respective teams, and Bearded Kevin took home the win for his Arctic char with turnip salsa verde -- Jerkface Mike looked equal parts mad and cocky. Wolfgang apparently is hard-up in this economy because he couldn't even cough up a signed cookbook for him. Cooking in Puck's restaurant will have to be prize enough.
The losers were Hector, Jen Z., Jesse and Eve. Hector deep-fried steak, which was not acceptable in the august culinary world of Vegas. Liz would've scarfed that bad boy down though. Jen Z.'s aforementioned chile relleno (the fancy way of saying stuffed pepper) was like a "vegan bar midnight special," Padma said. Tom said it would've been terrible no matter what protein she used. Jesse's chicken was too dry, but the judges like that she knew what was wrong. Bad execution's usually the kiss of death, but she was safe this time. Eve's food was bland and forgettable (overcooked shrimp, bland sauce made blander with cream -- she said usually cooks "big, bold flavors" and toned it down with the last-minute cream, but the judges didn't seem to believe her).
It was no surprise that Jen Z. went home. She even squeezed out some tears as she packed her knives (but did she really have time to unpack them in the first place?). She complained about the vendetta the world has against seitan, but Justine's happy not to have those peppers served to her.
The predictions:
Early favorites: Justine likes Kevin because he's a winner and because Liz hates his beard (Shouldn't he have to wear a beard-net?), and Liz likes Eli because his “buttered" Scotch with scallops and beer cashews was all about being bitter.
Who's going home next: Eve -- she had a bland dish, bland personality and she got enough camera time for us to recognize her as the door hits her on the way out.
Preeti could also be going home next. She made the Top Chef fatal flaw of trying to do something she hadn't done before, and c'mon, you really shouldn't be on a cooking show if you can't even shuck a clam.
Who do you think is going home? Does a chef with a beard make better food? Did anyone else totally ignore Top Chef: Masters?
Categories: Maryland reality contestants, Top Chef



Comments
I'm sure Jen is nice enough, but I'm not that sad to see her gone since her super-stretched-out earlobes were SO distracting. Especially coupled with the news that she has a toddler. *twitch*
I hope Jesse steps it up next week because she seems cool and clever (plus the whole Team Baltimore thing). I think the Voltaggio brothers are going to be safe for a while since the show is milking the heck out of their sibling rivalry.
All in all, it was a good start to the new season.
Thanks again for the recapping assist!
We, too, were kind of put off by her giant earlobes. And totally agree on keeping the brothers around for a while. It's too good a storyline, and from what we saw tonight, the only noticeable one right out the gate. -Liz
Posted by: sarahkk | August 19, 2009 11:52 PM
First off, I want to know exactly what the guy from Haiti did to be stranded. Secondly, Tom is hot regardless of how much he weighs, but he's definitely been working out, and I appreciate that. Third, I miss Team Europe already.
My predictions? Jen C. may be the female Hung, Eli is the new Dale (short, angry Dale, not cute gay Dale), Kevin has some skills, the brothers have some skills, Jerkface Mike isn't really a jerk. I have no idea who is going to win though.
Oh, and since when is a "mouthful of ocean" a good thing. Things live and reproduce in the ocean and I don't want to think of things like that in my mouth.
How do you figure that Jerkface Mike is not a jerk? Does the sexism cancel out the jerkfacedness? I wouldn't want to be in the same room with this guy!
I like Eli, but not as much as Liz does. I'm sure we'll see more of him, though, and his sense of humor was great.
As for the "mouthful of ocean" thing, Tom said it like it was a good thing. I'm all about tone. I guess it just wasn't good enough. --Justine
Posted by: FoulMouthedKitten | August 20, 2009 12:17 AM
I am very excited for this season of top chef!
And good article by the way! :)
Thanks! --Justine
Posted by: Anita | August 20, 2009 5:13 AM
jerkface mike...i agree 1,000%
we thought eve would be the first to go
more to come
I was rather proud of his nickname. With two Michaels on the show, you have to differentiate them somehow. --Justine
Posted by: dkh735 | August 20, 2009 7:41 AM
I can't believe someone just said something nice about bland, unoriginal Gail Simmons.
Let's count the times she commends presentation this season. Maybe it's because you don't have to have any particular talent to recognize whether something is presented well.
God I hate her.
But did you like Toby better? Mr. Catch-Phrase wasn't that entertaining, really, and didn't seem like a very good judge, either. I don't eye-roll Gail as much as I did in 5 seconds with Toby. --Justine
Posted by: AK | August 20, 2009 8:54 AM
I thought Top Chef Masters was a fun change of pace, except for Kelly Choi. She was a poor replacement for Padma. It was nice to see the camraderie between the chefs, and everything made for the last challenge looked absolutely delicious (and I'm a vegetarian). As long as Michael Ciarello didn't win, I was happy.
Seitan can be really good if made well, but that didn't sound or look like it had been made well. I'd love to see somebody win while making a vegetarian dish or two, but it would be an uphill battle, judging from the sneer on Padma's face when she asked "have you worked with this protein before?"
I've often wondered whether there would ever be a vegetarian top chef (or even a vegetarian who makes it halfway through a season). The deck is certainly stacked against them, and not just because many vegetarian proteins take longer to cook to develop good flavor.
I didn't mind Padma's sneer though, because that pepper did look really unappetizing. --Justine
Posted by: bonnie | August 20, 2009 9:38 AM
Musings, in no particular order:
I didn't notice Jen's earlobes because I was mesmerized by that gross tattoo on her neck. I knew that she was doomed from the start because she only mentioned her kid about a dozen times.
Jerkface Mike is a jerk and, as pointed out by my viewing partner (Joe), a misogynist. I hope he's only faking his attitude to become this season's Howie.
The Jennifer that won the quickfire challenge is another jerkface, imo. I can't believe she kissed Chef Tom when she won, and I don't think he could believe it either. Don't like her at all; she's the hot one by default (according to Joe) and doesn't know that there's an "ay" at the end of ceviche.
Didn't like the guy who won - gross beard & swears too much.
All of the winners cooked some sort of fish dish.
I'm sorry, but all of the metal parts in the Baltimore girl's face are very off-putting to me.
Ash announced that he was gay about 15 minutes into the show, that makes him the new Dale (cute, gay Dale, not short angry Dale)
Wolfgang Puck is my new favorite judge.
Can't speculate on a winner but Eve and Laurine (I think that's her name) are on the short list.
Can't wait for next week.
I think Liz was more distracted by the earlobes -- I was appalled at the neck tattoo because I can't imagine letting someone with a tattoo gun anywhere near my neck.
I did think they talked to/showed her more than they did the girl who got booted off first last season. I'm not disappointed though. She wasn't entertaining enough to keep. -- Justine
Posted by: dkh735 | August 20, 2009 12:30 PM
People need to let up about Jen's pronunciation. I'm from Philly, that's our accent! Get over it!
Posted by: Gwen | August 23, 2009 11:44 PM
I finally watched it, five days late and a dollar short. Jerkface Mike is totally a jerkface! I counted at least three sexist comments (and three mental punches to the face from me).
I think Jesse will make up for this, especially knowing what she did wrong and not arguing (ahem, Jen Z., drop it; your food was not bold and interesting) with the judges. She seems like the kind of person who won't let this happen again.
I'm loving Beardface Kevin and the hot, hot, hot Voltaggio brothers. Swoon. Oh, and the other Jen, the self-proclaimed b**** in the kitchen. Bring it!
Posted by: Former Reality Check "Top Chef" blogger Mary | August 24, 2009 10:48 PM