baltimoresun.com

« 'Big Brother': Why did it have to be Jessie? | Main | 'Big Brother 11': Who goes home first? »

July 15, 2009

'So You Think Can Dance': Top 10 get new partners

The big question on tonight's So You Think You Can Dance is, how will the Top 10 be partnered up tonight and how will they deal with these new partnerships?

The first performance tonight is not from a new set of two or even a solo (we'll be seeing the solos tonight, too), but a Bollywood routine by the Top 5 women by Nakul Dev Mahajan. It is fast, joyful, complicated, intricate, and did I mention fast? Nigel Lythgoe credits Nakul for an amazing dance and then tells the women that they were all amazing and had "everything ... personality, spatial awareness. ... You are lacking nothing." Mary Murphy pulls a lame-o line: "Bolly-WOW!" Debbie Allen says they all articulated every part of the dance really well. "I think this is inarguably the best Top 5 group of ladies we've ever had."

Finally, we get to learn one of the new partnerships. It's Kayla and Evan. They are a little concerned because she is the tallest female and he's the shortest male. They will be doing the Viennese waltz with Tony Meredith and Melanie LaPatin. Melanie makes them trade shoes to even out their heights. Ow! They manage to work out the height differential in the dance, though, at least mostly. There was one lift where Evan looks kind of miniature, but for the rest, it's not as noticeable. They sell the relationship, too, with their facial expressions toward each other, and one of the lifts actually made me gasp out loud. I'd say not too shabby for brand-new partners. Oh, as it turns out, Kayla is in flats and Evan has heely shoes. Nigel says he didn't see as much Viennese waltz as regular waltz, but that is of course not Kayla or Evan's problem. But he thinks it was danced beautifully. Mary says Evan lacked power in some of his turns -- she says he is good, but he needs to take it to another level since it's the Top 10. She credits him on his lifts, though, and for his class and elegance. She says Kayla is taking it to that other level and is growing every week. Debbie says it is a wonderful, unexpected surprise: "Darling, you handled your big woman, baby! ... I don't care what kind of waltz it was, you were in 3/4 and you were in time." She tells Evan that they nicknamed him Gene Kelly during Vegas week, and he looks stunned and thrilled. Can you blame him?

Then it's Brandon with a solo. I never know what to say about the solos -- they are so short, I am just figuring out what I think, and it's over. Anyway, he crams a lot into that solo!

 

The next new couple is Ade and Janette. They take on hip-hop with Tabitha and Napoleon. Oh, by the way, Ade is the tallest guy and Janette is the shortest girl, so they have the opposite problem as Kayla and Evan. The story of this dance is that Ade is the funk-master, and he has to hypnotize Janette (with his comb) and make her funky, too, which they say is pretty much what is happening in real life, too. It's a cute idea and a cute dance, but something seems off about the performance, like they aren't quite in sync, and in a dance with that many sharp moves, it is kind of opposite. Nigel thanks "NappyTabs" for the fun dance and says that Ade has funk. Mary: "We've gotta get serious and just cut the crap: That was funkeeeeeee!" She also disagrees with me and call is "well-synchronized." Debbie says they wore her out and she wanted to join them on stage. She also tells Ade to keep his comb away from her daughter.

Then it's Randi's solo. Cat keeps trying to talk to her afterward, but she's just trying to breathe. After the break, Kupono solos, and he dances a lot more than the last time he did a solo.

Jeanine and Jason are both super-excited to be partnered together because they think they are complementary. Their choreographer is Travis Wall from Season 2, and they'll be doing a contemporary routine. It's about best friends, and the guy wants to give the girl his heart (represented by a heart on a chain, natch), but the girl doesn't think they are ready, so she fights him ... at first. This looks hard -- lots of jumps and lifts and emotion, but they pull it off. At the end it's a little too "get a room" for my tastes at the end, but they still do a really good job. So much that the judges give them a standing ovation (oh, and the audience, too). Nigel says sometimes this show shows "talent that goes nowhere" (yikes), so he is thrilled to see such amazing work from Travis, work that was only made better by Jeanine and Jason. He says they both became stars tonight, and they look moved. Mary is speechless. (Hooray!) She says it was great, and then she cries talking about how glad she is to see Travis' growth. She tells Jason that he went to a whole new level tonight and Jeanine that she hasn't missed a step. Oh, then the obligatory "hot tamale train." She does a silent scream. Debbie says this experience tonight means this show is more than a competition, but a conversation about the art of dance.

Melissa is next with her solo. It's kind of ... lacking in content besides turns. Then it's Evan's turn. His solo is definitely not lacking in content -- and it's full of personality. Kayla, too, has a lot of emotion as well as technical moves going on.

Randi and Kupono are another new couple. They are doing paso doble with Tony Meredith and Melanie LaPatin, who says they didn't hold back in the choreography at all. They do not look that comfortable during the performance, and Kupono doesn't seem to be showing the power and aggression that this style demands. Also, he drops Randi at the end. Nigel says it was good choreography from Tony and Melanie, but he doesn't think the dancing was as good as the choreography. He adds that Kupono didn't have enough strength, and he lost him about halfway through. He also wasn't sure about Randi's wig, and he thinks there was a lack of passion, but they did a good job on the death spiral. Mary says it was hard for everyone tonight and that they didn't rise to the challenge. Debbie thinks it was maybe that the trust wasn't there yet because they are new.

Ade's solo has a lot of tricks, and he's clearly having a lot of fun, but it's a little disconnected from the music ("Unchained Melody"). After the break, it's Jeanine's solo. (Isn't this the same music as the Argentine tango from the other week?) I didn't find it that memorable. Jason dances to Muddy Waters, and that alone makes him a bit more memorable.

The last new couple is Brandon and Melissa. Their first challenge is a Broadway routine with Tyce DiOrio, something from Hair. They work it out, but Brandon is so powerful, I find it tough to not watch him. I think Melissa was OK, too, but I didn't notice her as much. Nigel liked the routine, especially how it used their strengths. Mary thinks it was unbelievable and groovy. Debbie says they evoked "the real harmony" and that they were both powerful and technical and brilliant. 

Janette is the final soloist. She's the last partner dancer, and her solo has that weird quality of being a little odd since she doesn't have anyone to dance with. So it ends up being a show of hip action. Course, she's pretty good at that. 

The last performance of the night is an African dance with Jeffrey Page by the Top 5 guys. This looks tough, and on a number of levels. One of the most difficult things about it seems to be that it's all rhythm-based and not counts, and that it will look wrong if they start to rely on technique when they get lost, since it's supposed to be more raw. Rehearsal stops for a while so Jeffrey can talk them through it, and it seems to help because they pull it off well, but it just looks so unbelievably challenging. Nigel says he loves African dance, and that Jeffrey might be the meanest choreographers ever since that was so hard. Nigel talks to Evan: "You look like a dancing milkshake tonight. ... But nobody stood out like a sore thumb." Mary adored it and the energy and says Evan held his own even though he was clearly outside his comfort zone. Debbie says it's so important to have African dance on this show since it is the mother of hip-hop and jazz and so many other styles. She loved it. "You think you can dance, and then you get a challenge like this. ... You can't just get up and do this." 

So what did you think about the performances tonight? I could see Randi and Kupono and maybe Melissa being in trouble.

There were surely some memorable moments this evening, though. Both those group numbers were show-stopping, as were several of the partner dances. 

 

 

 

Posted by Sarah Kickler Kelber at 10:17 PM | | Comments (2)
Categories: So You Think You Can Dance
        

Comments

SKK, you might just want to clarify that it was Randi in the wig, not Kupono, but I agree with your comments. We remember the original Age of Aquarius and thought that Melissa carried off that style pretty well, but my husband commented that she makes everything look like ballet.

We think Randi will be in trouble. Not sure about the guys--I hope Evan survives. His solo along earned him another chance, IMHO.

SKK: Annnd clarified. Thanks, Dahlink! I also loved Evan's solo -- he reminded us why he's here, which is supposed to be the point.

I also loved Debbie Allen's comments to Evan, after Nigel and the Screamer took him down a few notches. We really appreciated the silent scream later in the program and hope that this replaces the screech!

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "y" in the field below:
About Sarah Kelber
Sarah Kickler Kelber, an editor in the features department since 1999, got sucked into reality TV with the first episode of MTV's The Real World in 1992. Then came Survivor and American Idol, and suddenly, the genre was everywhere. She started blogging about it for The Baltimore Sun in January 2006 and has logged more hours watching and writing about such shows as Dancing With the Stars, Big Brother and, of course, Idol, than she'd like to admit.
Follow @realityck on Twitter
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
TELEVISION AND MEDIA NEWS • TV section
Photo galleries
What's on TV tonight?
Find it fast
Stay connected