baltimoresun.com

« You have to see this: surprising audition on 'Britain's Got Talent' | Main | 'American Idol': It's results time »

April 15, 2009

'Biggest Loser': Tears, Tim Gunn and injuries

Lots of tears are shed throughout every season of The Biggest Loser, but I would be willing to bet that last night's episode might have provided the largest volume ever.

First, there was the weekly challenge: The contestants had to cross a 700-foot canyon using two wires, and at times they were as high as 10 stories in the air. Filipe got a good start, and was determined to win in honor of his cousin Sione, who went home last week, but challenge-dominator Tara came from behind. And Mike conquered a longtime fear of heights and placed in third.

The big news of the episode was that it was makeover week. The contestants headed over to Macy's to get their new look, and who was there to guide them but Tim Gunn? All the finalists found outfits for their new bodies, thinking they were going to be attending a Hollywood movie premiere. Helen cried about feeling pretty for the first time in a long time, and she wasn't the only one.

At movie premiere time, shocker! The finalists were reunited with their family members, all of whom were stunned by the appearance of their weight-loss fanatics. But the most tears were shed by Mike and Ron's family, especially Mike's little brother, Max. Max, 16, seemed totally overwhelmed by the idea that now he was going to be the only "big one" in the family since his brother and his father have lost so much weight. Everyone cried (yes, that includes me). Mike reassured him that they would help him when they got home, which on the one hand seemed like he could really use more help than that, but on the other, if the other two people if your household with big appetites start eating healthfully, that should only be positive.

That movie, by the way, was a total sham. Instead of a film, the contestants and their families got a sneak peek at footage from throughout the season, including the initial weigh-ins, which led to, you guessed it, more tears. (See a bonus scene from the event above.)

Even with all of that, the majority of the tears were saved for the end of the episode, when Laura learned that she was injured. She'd been having shooting pains in her leg for a while, and the doctors discovered that she had a serious stress fracture at a pretty bad place in her hip. It was called the most serious sports injury anyone's gotten on the show before, and she learned that if she didn't take it super-easy, she could end up needing major surgery.

So this sounded bad, but somehow to me didn't seem incredibly dire, until it was time for the weigh-in. When it was Laura's turn, Mike and Filipe had to carry her to the scale. Then it really became clear how hurt she really was. Unfortunately, this meant she hadn't been able to work out at all, and she gained 3 pounds, which put her in the bottom two with Kristin.

At deliberations, Laura begged to stay, and Tara pled her case, too, saying she didn't have support at home. Kristin defended herself very well, saying that if they kept Laura, it would be a cowardly move -- that they would be keeping her only because she wasn't a threat. Kristin added that she wasn't there to win the money, she was there to get healthy, get her life back and start a family.

Apparently, the plea worked because Laura got voted out. It looked like she got lots of medical attention from the show, so maybe the no-support-at-home thing wasn't an issue in the end.

In the "Biggest Loser Moment" footage, Laura had maintained her weight loss since leaving the ranch, despite not being able to work out very much. She'd also managed to avoid surgery by doing lots of physical therapy. So that was good. I hope for the best for her, though. She was having such a tough time on the show, and like trainer Jillian said, she was just beginning to make progress.

Posted by Sarah Kickler Kelber at 12:44 PM | | Comments (3)
Categories: The Biggest Loser
        

Comments

Tara is a freak! When she fell, I thought to myself, she's still not out of it. Next thing you know she's taking the lead.

Even I shed a few tears when Mike and Max were talking, so I can only imagine how other people were.

I thought Kristin did a very good job of explaining/fighting for why she should stay there, glad to see they didn't go the cowardly way and kick her off. It would have been easy for them to get rid of her last night.

SKK: I was really impressed by Kristin's statement -- somehow she managed to call the other choice "cowardly" without it seeming like it was against Laura or being whiny.

Am I the only one who sat there and thought he was watching a audition tape for Max to be on the next season of the show. I do not think it was staged I think that was true raw emotion breaking through. I also think he already has a following that would watch the next season to see how he did. I hope the producers saw this as well and consider him.

SKK: Oh, Brian, good point. I think Max will still be too young next season, but the season after, he should be 18. I am hoping that at the finale, he will get at least a couple of minutes of airtime, and that we will see he has already started to make some progress. I felt for him so much last night.

This entire season has been one big sobfest for BL. Bob blubered like a baby when the teams were split up. This week, Jilian breaks down when Laura gets hurt. Maybe Kleenex will sponsor the show with one of those non-subtle product placements next season.

Also, despite her "I need to stay here" please, I don't think it would have been a cowardly move to vote Kristin out. Like it or not, they are in a game for $250,000, and sadly you have to vote people out based on game play decisions. If Laura was medically cleared to stay, it would have been smart to keep her there. Was it cowardly when Laura voted Sione out last week? No it was just taking out the bigger threat. I think this elimination was just a case of the original Bob team alliance (Brown, Purple and Blue) holding together when Mike decided to vote with his Dad and Filipe.

This has been a pretty good season IMO, can't wait to see them all at the Finale.

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "d" in the field below:
About Sarah Kelber
Sarah Kickler Kelber, an editor in the features department since 1999, got sucked into reality TV with the first episode of MTV's The Real World in 1992. Then came Survivor and American Idol, and suddenly, the genre was everywhere. She started blogging about it for The Baltimore Sun in January 2006 and has logged more hours watching and writing about such shows as Dancing With the Stars, Big Brother and, of course, Idol, than she'd like to admit.
Follow @realityck on Twitter
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
TELEVISION AND MEDIA NEWS • TV section
Photo galleries
What's on TV tonight?
Find it fast
Stay connected