baltimoresun.com

« 'American Idol' season 8 premieres | Main | Kansas City, here 'American Idol' comes »

January 14, 2009

Emotions run high on 'Biggest Loser'

It's not as if The Biggest Loser is usually an emotionally aloof kind of show. People are struggling to change their lives and working hard under a lot of pressure. But last night's episode took it to a whole new level.

Trainer Bob Harper -- nice, calm, zen Bob -- totally lost it on Joelle because he felt she wasn't working hard enough, and instead of working, she kept talking. (See for yourself in the clip above.) On the one hand, I understand where he was coming from. Every time he would push her to do something, she would go on and on: "I am focused; I will do it; I am determined; I will do this for you," or whatever else. In the meantime, she would continue to not work out. Bob finally couldn't take it anymore during the last-chance workout when he was having his team run 30-second sprints on the treadmill, and she kept stopping or leaning after 20 seconds. But he really handled it poorly. Not in terms of making the whole team redo the sprint -- that's a classic motivational maneuver. But the stream of f-bombs began to feel really uncomfortable after a while, and I really felt like this was not an approach that would work for Joelle. She seemed like she would be more likely to shut down in the face of such behavior. But still, stop talking and get back up on the step!

Things got emotional in a different way after the weigh-in. For some people, the week two curse struck again, and their losses were minimal. Dan lost the initial challenge and was given a one-pound penalty, and at the weigh-in, this was enough to put him in the bottom two and keep Joelle out. Dan and Jerry ended up below the yellow line -- DUN DUN DUN -- and the remaining contestants were torn up trying to decide who should go home. Dan is a teenager and the largest person to ever be on the show, and Jerry is the oldest and seemed the most in need of medical attention. (He fainted frighteningly during the premiere last week.)

In the end, it seemed to come down to the idea that Dan has his whole life in front of him and needs to change his mindset now, as well as the fact that he has been heavy forever, while Jerry was once thin. So Jerry was sent home to his wife, Estella, and thankfully, in the catching-up footage at the end of the episode, he looked great, having lost more than 80 pounds.

I don't think Joelle is long for the ranch. Her teammates seem frustrated with her efforts, and of course, same thing with Bob.

What did you think about the show?

Posted by Sarah Kickler Kelber at 1:59 PM | | Comments (5)
Categories: The Biggest Loser
        

Comments

I'd like to hope that Joelle is next in line to go, but I've been down that road before last year when I hoped beyond hope every week that Vicky from last year would get the ax. Every week she survived somehow and the season became more about the money and hyped up "revenge" than it did about losing weight. This year is already miles and miles better.

SKK: Oh, seriously! They are so much nicer to one another and supportive. Love that. Vicky made me seethe all last season (which was what, like five minutes ago?)

The Biggest Loser is an AWESOME show!!! I watch it just as much as I can. It motivates me to keep up with my diet and exercise. I was once obese in my adult life, and can fully understand the weight loss journey these people are going through. Seeing it helps me maintain the fitness goals I've acheived, and keeps me motivate to acheive more!

Get that crazy Bob off the show.He has no right to talk to anyone using the language or the tone he did, and I won't be watching Biggest Loser until he is gone.Throw him out with the pig slop!

Bob is an excellent trainer and I hope he stays on the show. The f bomb might not have been appropriate but neither is someone staying on the show who isn't trying. If you don't want to do the work leave.

I spent many years as a collegiate coach, and I totally empathize with Bob. Some people simply have no idea what "doing your best" actually is, and will argue you to death about it... it's a fundamental thing that goes completely beyond a simple lack of motivation. You can call Bob's meltdown inappropriate, but the fact is, it was effective, and it got the message to Joelle that there's no such thing as "faking it until you make it".

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Please enter the letter "b" in the field below:
About Sarah Kelber
Sarah Kickler Kelber, an editor in the features department since 1999, got sucked into reality TV with the first episode of MTV's The Real World in 1992. Then came Survivor and American Idol, and suddenly, the genre was everywhere. She started blogging about it for The Baltimore Sun in January 2006 and has logged more hours watching and writing about such shows as Dancing With the Stars, Big Brother and, of course, Idol, than she'd like to admit.
Follow @realityck on Twitter
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
TELEVISION AND MEDIA NEWS • TV section
Photo galleries
What's on TV tonight?
Find it fast
Stay connected