Howdy, Mary here, carrying out the main recapping duties for the Christmas-in-July episode of "Top Chef." I don't actually know what month this was filmed in, but I know it wasn't December -- one more awkward set of holiday wishes, after the Thanksgiving episode, that I cringe my way through.
I always enjoy the tidbits as the show opens, and we begin with Ariane again, who says her focus is on the food she knows. She still has that air of incredulosity about her, tied to her recent wins, and she says, "I've learned just to do my food and keep it simple. Simple is good." Simple will become this episode's theme.
We also see Eugene looking determined to stick around, and he says, "I was brought here for my particular style of Pacific Rim cooking," and I'm going to stick to it. How about thinking outside the sushi, Eugene?
I was happy to hear Eugene describe his cooking because all I've seen is sushi. Oh, and that awesome roast in the Thanksgiving episode.
We also catch a little bit of Hosea on the phone (Sidekick product placement alert! He looks like he has no idea how to end the call.) with his sister, discussing his dad, who was recently diagnosed with cancer. This seemed a little like Alex a few episodes back, in his I-have-a-life-and-I-want-to-go-home sort of way.
And Stefan and Fabio are in the confessional (what are we calling the camera room?) talking about how their plan is to first beat everyone else, then beat each other. With sticks, I think Fabio says. He cracked me up this episode.
I agree. I've really come to love Fabio as his personality has come out during the show. But, it seems his food has suffered in the meantime.
Quickfire Challenge
We knew from last week's teaser that the guest would be Martha Stewart, and she comes bearing her new book, Cooking With Martha Stewart Something or Other Martha Stewart's Cooking School. Do judges ever come on anymore who don't have a recent book out? And/or bring a better prize? Autograph schmatograph. I know Maryann has some thoughts on this. (By the way, Carla's face is priceless when Stewart walks in.)
I've been saying stuff here and there, but I'm about to combust. Chefs don't want a cookbook! They want cool food experiences! Cover up the product placements a little bit better, Top Chef producers.
The challenge is to create a one-pot holiday meal in 45 minutes, and Martha admonishes them to "make it simple but not too simple" a la Albert Einstein. About half the chefs start cooking one thing after another in the pot, and the rest make a true one-pot dish -- everything at once. Hosea goes for paella, which I thought was the most inspired choice. It may not scream "Christmas," but at least it's delicious and all cooked in one pot.
I agree. The people who cooked one thing, then another totally cheated. Those meals were one-pot-plus-a-plate-or-Tupperware meals.
Jamie makes a potato stew with scallops, and Martha says something about going diving for scallops off the coast of Maine in January. What? That can't be true. Ariane does a cauliflower puree with steak, and Martha is blown away that it doesn't include butter -- olive oil and cream, Ariane says. Isn't that just as bad for you?
Fabio does a polenta with duck breast and goes off on a tangent about how he had to stir a lot of polenta when he was 6 to keep him out of trouble. (I love the part where Fabio offers Stefan a taste his polenta, on his spoon, and Stefan puts it on his finger to taste it. Cute!) Eugene goes for a pork stew that his grandma used to make and has to add cornstarch to thicken in because of the time -- Martha, of course, notices right away.
Stefan goes for a veal ghoulash with chanterelles, which Martha seems like.
(I love how Martha was like, "Stew in 45 minutes? That's the idea! BURN on Eugene! -- Or was it the magic of editing?) Melissa introduces her pork tenderloin with apple and braised fennel by talking about growing up in Maryland with an apple tree in her backyard. Maryland reference! Woot!
Martha says most, but not all, of the cheftestants took her advice about simplicity. She didn't love Jeff's risotto, Eugene's stew, or Fabio's polenta stew. She loved Hosea's paella, Jamie's perfectly cooked scallop, and Ariane's cauliflower and beef. Ariane is the winner. She gets ... a book! Oh, and immunity. "From one Jersey girl to another," Martha says.
The Elimination Challenge
As soon as Martha's done pimping her book, in walks the Harlem Gospel Choir, singing "The Twelve Days of Christmas," to introduce the elimination challenge. We learn that each chef must make a dish inspired by one of the 12 days and its accompanying gifts.
Awkward moment when the choir members start singing the individual days. I love the look on Stefan's face when they sing his pick.
They draw knives and find out they have to make the dish for a party of 250 people the next day, with three hours of prep tonight. Carla, who runs a catering company, says, ""This challenge is so daunting to me and so unrealistic that I cannot compute."
The cheftestants run around the store, and their dish conceptions start to congeal into ... stew? I don't know where I'm going with that. Let's see if we can organize this: Firm up into Jell-o? Jell-o's nice.
12 drummers drumming, Stefan. Chicken (drumstick) pot pie.
11 pipers piping, Hosea. Smoked pork tenderloin.
10 lords a-leaping, Jeff. A confusing "island-hopping" salad of two cheeses.
9 ladies dancing, Fabio. (Of course.) Crab cakes with chipotle aioli.
8 maids a-milking, Melissa. Beef with Gorgonzola and toast points.
7 swans a-swimming, Jamie. Scallops "swimming" in vichyssoise.
6 geese a-laying, Ariane. Six different kinds of deviled eggs.
5 golden rings, Eugene. Poisson cru with a "golden" pineapple ring.
4 calling birds, no one apparently. There are only 11 chefs left! I guess the producers wanted less poultry.
3 french hens, Leah. Braised guinea hen with squash puree.
2 turtle doves, Carla. Braised chicken with duxelles and a mushroom cap.
1 partridge in a pear tree, Radhika. Duck breast with pear chutney and brioche. Chutney! There's an Indian element! Sorry, I can't help myself.
I heart the episode interludes between commercials. The chefs "singing" the 12 days of Christmas was funny, especially Fabio, who sang "9 ladies dancing" with a little bit of flourish. Awesome.
The kitchen drama starts almost immediately. Everyone goes into frantic mode, which isn't helped by Hosea smoking out the room. He used a lot of marinade on his pork tenderloin and the room starts to turn entirely gray. No one seems to mind terribly, although they rib him. There's also drama over packing the refrigerators, with lots of hot food going into them.
Stefan also mentions how 3 hours seems like a long time, but it quickly is eaten up by all the little tasks you have to do. I hear him. I can't even do a Rachael Ray 30 minute meal in less than an hour. I also would like to draw attention to Stefan's watermelon centerpiece at the house -- with knives sticking out of it. Awesome.
The next morning, everything inside one of the fridges is warm. The way the footage was cut, it's Hosea's fault, but there are no accusations and there's no followup, and the cheftestants start pitching in to help Hosea and Radhika, whose meat-heavy dishes are ruined. The chefs seem pretty tight at this moment, everyone helping out, though Stefan says he is helping because he doesn't want to win by default. He doesn't have the "Christmas spirit" that Jamie mentioned, and neither do I -- because it's not Christmas! Argh.
They head over to the ballroom and learn they're catering an event for amFar,
an AIDS foundation. The event is hosted by actor
Natasha Richardson, and
chef Michelle Bernstein is there to judge, as well. There's one added twist, which I love: guests (who are not dressed for winter, exactly, AHEM) should pin their red ribbons to the table of the dishes they like the best. This comes in handy later when some cheftestants are sure everyone loved their dish and the judges are crazy. (Eugene, I'm looking at you. Why are you still here?)
The hits seem to be Stefan's pot pie, Hosea's smoked pork with paprkia and potatoes, and Radhika's duck and brioche.
The judges and guests feel Jamie's scallops "taste wrong" and "slimy"; Fabio's crab cake is "dense and greasy"; Melissa's cheese overpowers the beef and everything else on the plate; and the puff pastry on Leah's plate seems to dry out the hen and squash puree. Ariane's deviled eggs send Tom Colicchio into a rant -- "I don't get it!"
C'mon Tom. Everyone loves a deviled egg. Shush.
A couple more notes from the party: A guest named Becky is flirting with Hosea, and he brags about it to Jamie -- "This one chick was just hitting on me. It was hilarious" -- and then refers to Jeff as a "pretty boy" and says he's his only competition. (Jeff had said, "My station was a mosh pit," which makes me think of
that very old SNL skit with Janet Reno yelling, "No mosh pitting!" To be fair, I think of that anytime anyone says "mosh pit," which doesn't happen that often anymore.) Where did cocky Hosea come from? Wow.
Judges Table
The top four are Radhika, Hosea, Jeff and Stefan. No surprises here, and there's some general huffing and puffing over how their food could have been better. Hosea wins, and he gets ... a book! Bernstein's new book. This is the first of at least two seriously underwhelming moments. What happened to trips and crazy kitchen tools?
Thank you, thank you. I was yelling at the TV! Are the lame gifts this season a sign of the struggling economy?
At the bottom of the cheftestants' ladder are Eugene, Melissa and Jamie. Ariane chases them out of the backstage room, cheering them on. "All right, guys! Stand up for yourselves! Fight, fight, fight!" Where did positive Ariane come from?
I think it's the mom part of her cougar status.
Padma points out that their dishes were the least favorites of both the judges and the guests. Jamie's scallops were raw (Padma gagged(!!) on her dish. You knew she was in the bottom.), and Bernstein points out she should have just seared them -- everything was too fishy. Melissa gets dinged for using too much of a too powerful cheese. And Eugene, well, his dish was too sweet, not tart enough, couldn't taste the fish, and he only got eight ribbons on his table (out of 250 guests). Ouch. He's deflated enough to stop defending his Pacific Rim cuisine. I was personally confused with the one potato chip on each plate. Weird.
Tom starts ranting, always the show's highlight, and says there wasn't one dish he wanted to taste a second time. He says the food wasn't up to par and that he wants to have a chat with everyone and tell them to step up their game. Apparently the producers think this is a great idea, so Tom goes backstage to chat with everyone.
"Do me a favor: Cook the food you think is going to make you win," he says. Tom says there's no way they're happy with everything they cooked. This is my favorite line: "You don't win with a deviled egg." (This reminds me of
"You don't win friends with salad," a la The Simpsons. Apparently I haven't watched any new TV except for
Top Chef since the mid- to late '90s.)
OK, now I'm mad. This episode was an hour and 15 minutes, again, and no one is getting kicked off? If they want the chefs to be bolder, then the producers should be bold and give someone the boot. I feel cheated.
I think it's fair not to kick off a chef, given what happened, but they need to stop playing and just go ahead and kick Eugene off. Why is he still there?? I guess we'll see him get kicked off in the New Year. Happy Holidays, folks!
Comments
What the heck is vichyssoise anyway? I don't want my food swimming in anything, thank you very much.
Posted by: eth | December 18, 2008 10:47 AM
I don't know, but it was damn hard to spell! Maryann? Can you 'splain?
Posted by: Mary | December 18, 2008 11:05 AM
It's obviously NOT around Christmas when the chefs go shopping at Whole Foods in their shorts and tank tops. I don't have a problem with a seasonal show, but it would make more sense to film it over the holidays and run it the following year. The contrived holiday atmosphere is a bit over the top and insults the intelligence of the viewers.
Posted by: Dave | December 18, 2008 11:31 AM
Thanks for the recap, Mary. It is lame they didn't kick anybody off. Is it just me, or in past seasons when they all did kinda bad, they still eliminated?
Maybe they want to air an extra episode this season to make up for poor advertising revenue.
Posted by: Justine | December 18, 2008 11:40 AM
My question: does anyone else wonder whether the whole "open fridge" thing was contrived? Seems awfully convenient.
Posted by: Jenni K | December 18, 2008 1:21 PM
I thought the episode (and the food) was a little lackluster overall. But I disagreed with the judges about this being the contestants' faults. This week's theme was ridiculous! I don't think you could even call it a theme. 9 ladies dancing? There is nothing culinary about that. Tom tells them afterward to cook their best food ("cook to win"). If they had been told at the beginning of the episode to whip up the most elegant appetizer they could for a swanky, "Christmas"-y, New York event, I think they would have risen to the occasion. But drummers drumming isn't going to inspire anyone.
Posted by: Chris | December 18, 2008 1:55 PM
I think it was the Miami season where there was no clear winner after the first attempt at Restaurant Wars and they didn't eliminate anyone and made them go right back into a second round of the wars the next night. So there is some precedent for what they did.
I think they should tell them they are going to boot the bottom two on the next challenge to ratchet up the pressure on the next round.
Posted by: etucker | December 18, 2008 5:07 PM
I felt like Martha's appearance was wasted. When you think of Martha Stewart you most certainly do not think of a one pot holiday dish. And half those dishes had nothing to do with the holidays anyhow.
Posted by: MarthaAndMe | December 18, 2008 9:43 PM
Chris and etucker, you both make excellent points. I would love to see two people get booted off next episode, and the challenge was definitely odd. It does seem like the judges may have realized that and made some concessions.
MarthaAndMe, you're right. I would have liked to have seen MS stick around and guest-judge the elimination challenge.
Posted by: Mary | December 18, 2008 10:08 PM
I personally have a problem and watch the reruns of the episodes far too often...and my favorite part of this weeks episode was actually the preview for the next new one...
They show a clip of Jamie making scallops (SHOCKER!) and Fabio says "This is Top Chef, not Top Scallops". Best line ever.
Posted by: lore | December 23, 2008 7:39 AM
Yes! I am looking forward to that one line on this week's episode. Fabio has really won me and Maryann over.
Posted by: Mary | December 23, 2008 7:42 AM