Guest blogger Karen Shih gets us up to date on Top Design:
This week, the designers have to create a room of their choice around a Swarovski chandelier. Eddie, who has immunity after a good Pop Design, gets to choose the order in which everyone picks chandeliers.
He goes first, naturally, and chooses the "Golden Teak Glitterbox,: which is a long, horizontally oriented, rectangular chandelier. Andrea goes second and picks the "Light Peridot Glitterbox," which is like Eddie's, but green and hanging down, long-ways.
Nathan chooses the "Ice Branch," which really does look like the trees in my backyard that one year after that ice storm. Ondine picks the "Light Sock," which looks like just one large crystal at the bottom of a fishnet.
Preston is left with this pear-shaped, purply-gray ugliness. He's proven to be fairly brilliant though, so it probably won't hold him back.
They're painting this week, and Nathan starts this crazy purple and green design on his wall based on the shadows and reflections from his chandelier. Preston offers to help but gets rejected (no love there), and Nathan instead asks Eddie to help. (Eddie, who's gotten more fabulous by the week, is calling everyone "tranny" this week).
The designers go shopping the next day, and Eddie essentially does a commercial for Martha Stewart, drooling over every piece in her store and raving about how great the company is. (Note Eddie-is-full-of-himself line of the day: "I don't know where I come up with it, I think it's just a gift from God.")
Simon Doonan, Jonathan Adler's husband and Barneys' creative director, is the guest judge this week, filling in for Kelly.
Andrea's room is much more vibrant than the ones she's been doing. The walls are green, patterned with some chocolate-brown areas; it's a Hollywood starlet's room with the gorgeous green chandelier hanging prominently over the coffee table in the center of the room. She says she's on a learning curve with accessories after Simon pans her plastic shell vase with fake flowers, but it's not all bad news. Margaret says it does feel very glam.
Ondine's lavender-and-brown room is a world traveler's bedroom, with random things from around the globe: Indonesian statues, Indian puppets and more. The chandelier hangs above an end table to the bed. The bright chandelier looks out of place in the drab room.
Preston's room is a nice cocktail lounge, and he frames the chandelier as art against a patterned surface, making it surprisingly not ugly. The rest of the room is black. Against the mostly black-and-white palette, there are two random orange armchairs.
Eddie's room is what he calls a fun, young, wealthy couple's dining room. It's green and brown like Andrea's but much more blah, with some gold-colored leaves lining corners and mirrors. The chandelier, looking like a hanging log and not at all the gorgeous, sparkling object we saw at the beginning, is the focal point of the room.
I don't know what this hot mess is, but Nathan has pulled together a Lisa Frank plus wooden horse thing that I don't understand. The bold purple-and-green wall is adjacent to a bed with a blue bedspread and pink pillow. Then there's the large wooden horse and some gold suns on a white wall. I don’t know. I can't describe it. The judges don't seem to hate it outright, but who knows?
In the judging room, Eddie is thoroughly panned, but since he has immunity, he stays. Nathan's room, crazy as it was, had a great mood. Preston's room was quirky but "glamorous, fabulous and luxurious," Simon says.
Ondine and Andrea have the weakest rooms. Ondine’s room is too frumpy. Margaret says it depresses her. Andrea's room was stronger, achieving the overall look, but her details were bad, especially the vase. Then, Andrea falls apart. She starts crying, saying she's maxed out and can't figure out what the judges want. She cries about having her kids early and says that being a designer is her real dream, but then says she wants to go home.
"I'm just being realistic," she says. There's plenty of awkwardness. But before we get to see who goes home …
Preston wins again! Back to back!
Eddie is not so happy. He's "over" the judges, he says. Um, you're on a judged show. You're a contestant. You can't be "over" the judges.
It's down to Andrea and Ondine, and they say that normally, Andrea would stay, but since she wants to go, the decision's up to her. She can't make up her mind, and you can just see Ondine there, thinking, "Just make up your mind, you nut!" It's kind of unfortunate that Ondine's fate is in Andrea's hands, but oh, well.
She even has the nerve to ask Ondine what she thinks!
Finally, Andrea decides to go home. Andrea talks about wanting to see her kids and being able to do great if she could just see her kids, and it's like, seriously, how much longer is this show? A couple more weeks? Meaning a couple more days, shooting-wise? Stick it out!
But, whatever, it's what she wants.
Next week: down to four!