The mysterious milk carton
![]()
I haven't heard from Owl Meat today with his usual Funtastic Thursday game. He hasn't been commenting as much as usual either. Perhaps he's actually involved in something important in the real world. I hate that.
I was thinking about him and his mystery ingredients yesterday when I was reading the pint carton of skim milk from Giant I was having for lunch. It was very mysterious. ...
Not the ingredients, although they weren't, as you might expect, just skim milk. But on the front of the carton was this statement with an asterisk after it:
Our farmers' pledge: No artificial growth hormones
That sounded good to me (although it started me wondering if the milk maybe had some natural growth hormones in it), but I couldn't find anything on the front of the carton that the asterisk was referring to.
On the back was this with an asterisk after it in the section that was giving the Recommended Daily Allowances:
% Daily Value
And finally there was this that referred to one of the two phrases with an asterisk after them:
*No significant difference in milk from cows treated with artificial growth hormones.
Cryptic. (Although I'm sure one of you can explain it to me.) If it refers to the statement in front, what does the asterisk by daily values refer to?
More important, I remember when I used to eat lunch and think about how good the food was and maybe talk to the friends I was eating lunch with, not read milk cartons.
By the way, pictured is Sultana the brown Swiss cow.
(Monica Eng/Chicago Tribune/MCT)


Comments
My guess is that the same explanation applies to each asterisk, whether on the front or on the back. What it means is: Milk is milk. Or, rather, milk from cows that were fed growth hormones has the same nutrition values as milk from hormone-free cows.
Is this meant to reassure the hormone-free milk consumers that they're not losing out on any RDA values? Or is this meant to reassure the hormone-laced milk consumers that they're getting the same RDA values as the hormone-free crowd?
Posted by: hmpstd | July 24, 2008 11:29 AM
The * after %Daily Value usually refers to "based on a 2000 calorie/day diet".
Posted by: Cara | July 24, 2008 12:04 PM
BGH is what you want to google. Bovine Growth Hormone. Banned in the EU, Monsanto and the FDA claim it is a totally safe way to get more milk from Bessie. The kinds of folks who shop at farmers' markets and Whole Paycheck don't want it.
The weird wording on the nutrition portion is because lobbyists have gotten some states to mandate wording like that to make BGH sound natural and normal. The big dairies have even tried to get mention of BGH outlawed on packages in some states.
Is BGH dangerous? I don't know, but I am leery of factory farming...no, I think it is immoral, cruel and leads to inferior food. So, given a choice, I'll go for no BGH.
Posted by: Lissa | July 24, 2008 12:06 PM
Cow Picture: The corner of Rt 24 and Belair Road is now the de facto epicenter of Harford County, with Harford Mall and three shopping plazas holding down the corners. The Chili's on the northeast corner has a wonderful memento of bygone days when that property was a farmer's field across from the old fair grounds and race track: it is a picture of the last of the farmer's cows, the last one to graze in the Bel Air town limits. It's a nice touch.
Posted by: MD Canon | July 24, 2008 12:37 PM
Is Sultana where the Swiss cheese comes from?
Posted by: Rob in PCB FL | July 24, 2008 1:16 PM
I've noticed that statement on milk down here as well. I'm with Lissa, I'll stick with the non-BGH milk.
Posted by: Rob in PCB FL | July 24, 2008 1:19 PM
Lissa's got it.
In a nutshell, dairies that use hormones to increase milk production don't want the hormone free dairies to be able to advertise that they don't use hormones. It costs money to be certified organic but no money to call yourself natural and explain why on the package. They also don't want to lose business when people realize that maybe pumping cows full of hormones to increase milk production isn't the best thing for the cow or the human consumer.
I don't want hormones in my body that don't belong there and if organic dairy products aren't available I'm going to go for the rBST free ones.
Posted by: Kiki | July 24, 2008 1:51 PM
I think hormones in milk, beef, chicken, etc are responsible for a high cancer rate in this state. Just my personal theory.
Posted by: Joyce W. | July 24, 2008 2:25 PM
Rob in PCB FL, Sultana is the BROWN Swiss cow, so she gives chocolate milk.
Posted by: Dottie | July 24, 2008 6:34 PM
Dottie's remark about chocolate milk reminds me of the time I took a carload of boys for ice cream. We sat outside with our cones on a hot day and were amazed to see a woman deliver an ice cream cone to the dog in her car--chocolate ice cream. "Makes sense," said my son. "It's a chocolate lab."
Posted by: Dahlink | July 24, 2008 7:19 PM
I would gladly welcome the cow back to Bel Air. If that meant getting rid of the Chili's and the Taco Bell, it would be triple blessing.
Posted by: Robert of Cross Keys | July 24, 2008 9:17 PM
*obligatory-wince-at-feeding-chocolate-to-a-dog*
Posted by: Lissa | July 24, 2008 9:45 PM
A few years ago, my scary neighbor (don't get me started) got a pit bull puppy... and I was terrified... and then a few weeks later, it was gone. I asked her what happened to her puppy and she said "don't feed chocolate to a dog."
But then later that year a co-worker said his dog (golden retriever) found the hidden halloween candy and ate ALL the chocolate, and that dog was perfectly fine after.
So there is something about chocolate and dogs, but it's not the same for all breeds?
Posted by: LJ | July 24, 2008 10:48 PM
I don't care what the milk carton says as long as my picture is not on it.
Posted by: bra1nchild | July 24, 2008 11:35 PM
LJ - Larger dogs can get away with eating chocolate depending on how much it is. The effects, however, are not pretty.
The smaller and younger the dog, the more likely it is to be fatal.
Posted by: Rosebud | July 25, 2008 7:20 AM
RoCK, maybe if we wish hard enough, the Chili's and Taco Bell will disappear. I live relatively close to Bel Air and always wish it weren't such a mecca for bad chains.
Posted by: Stacy | July 25, 2008 8:45 AM
I don't care what the milk carton says as long as my picture is not on it.....
Not PC but
The Perfect Breakfast....
Reading the morning mail as you eat your cereal..
Your son's picture is on the Wheaties box..
Your daughter's picture is on the cover of Glamour..
Any your exe's picture is on the milk carton..
Posted by: Hue | July 25, 2008 11:04 AM