More thoughts on boxed wine and other things
This comment by Carey Hughes under the Wine in a Box entry got me thinking some more about how I feel about boxed wine:
I'm not a wine snob either, but I am a design snob and ritual snob. These aren't qualities I'm proud of because given a slightly better wine in a box and one slightly less good in a bottle with a beautiful label and a cork, ...
...I'd enjoy the one in the bottle more. Just as I'd enjoy it more in a beautiful wine glass than a jelly glass. (And believe me, I've drunk my share of wine from jelly glasses.) So the reality is I'm not going to switch any time soon to a box for my sippin' wine, although its longevity would be a real plus for me.
I also wanted to bring up Dahlink's comment, which I noticed nobody got near:
About a wine throw down--I have read that a majority of tasters can't distinguish a red from a white wine if they are blindfolded. Makes me wonder ...
Someone told me that Calvin Trillin wrote about this in one of his books, but I haven't had the time to track it down. As it was told to me third hand, he was referring to a study involving, I think, the Stanford Wine Program, in which blindfolded participants couldn't tell the difference between red and white. If anyone has more details, please post below.
It would be fun to try this out on your wine connoisseur friends. Blindfold them and try, say, three reds and three whites at room temperature. Then report back here. I'm not going to ask you to try it yourself and then report back, because you'd probably lie. Ha ha, just kidding.
("In this photo illustration, a cork is often the culprit when wine goes bad." Bob Fila/Chicago Tribune/MCT)


Comments
Help!
I want to insert a link to an interesting wine study, but I don't know how. I have googled and googled, and can't find anything that works!
Here's the entry explaining how to do it. (Don't forget to take out the absurd x.) You can just copy and paste the coding. If you forget, you can always find the instructions under the category Commenting to the right. EL
Posted by: Susan | April 15, 2008 12:03 PM
A lot of wineries are switching to screwcaps, as mentioned in this article and this one. Though apparently cork is still more environmentally friendly than synthetic cork or plastic caps.
Posted by: bonnie | April 15, 2008 12:12 PM
I just returned from a trip to Australia a few weeks ago. We visited about a dozen wineries near Melbourne, and drank several bottles on our own time (yes, it was tough, but someone had to do it).
Every winery we visited was using screwcaps for their wines.
Posted by: Doug | April 15, 2008 12:44 PM
Here's a link for a story about the study.
Posted by: Rosebud | April 15, 2008 12:49 PM
best $8 (or $17 at the Wine Market)bottle of wine you will ever have is a 2005 Wolftrap Syrah from South Africa. it's a screw cap, and delicious.
Posted by: Dan | April 15, 2008 1:18 PM
I used to be EXACTLY the same way - the experience and ritual was sometimes more important than the taste. But lately, since so many decent wineries have started using screwcaps, I've kind of gotten used to them. In fact, I find them kind of convenient. (Plus, I opened a nice bottle this week that was corked. And now I can't remember where I got it, so I can't even return it.)
I still hate synthetic corks, though. They just seem wrong.
Yes, I'm coming to kind of like the screw tops. EL
Posted by: kitpollard | April 15, 2008 1:55 PM
I checked Rosebud's link. Here is another study on taste and smell. "The stimuli consisted of 13 commercially available liqueurs, which were chosen because they are both strongly flavored and aromatic. The liqueurs were selected for their range of sensory attributes. They included Creme de Cacao, Amaretto, B & B, Drambuie, Citro, Nocello, Grand Marnier, Cointreau, Strega, Galliano, Kahlua, Tia Maria, and Kummel. The liqueurs represented a variety of flavoring agents." If you are blindfolded can you tell if you are eating different foods?
Posted by: Dave | April 15, 2008 1:57 PM
I have a beloved $1,000 (slight exageration) corkscrew contraption that's embarrassingly pleasurable to use. I never get tired of extracting corks with it. But, all things being equal, if I can get four bottles of the same great wine for less in a bag/box, that's what I'm going to do. I also find the asthetics and ritual of tapping wine from the box quite appealing and so far still delight in the simple wonder of it -- every time.
Posted by: jl | April 15, 2008 2:48 PM
I imagine that when it comes to wine, there's a lot of psychology involved with the whole experience.
I have somewhere in the back of my head a memory of reading a story recently about a taste test that took place; the wines were ultimately rated almost exactly according to what the tasters were TOLD the wines cost. That is, if the taster was told that it was a cheap wine (regardless of its provenance), it got a low rating, and a higher rating went to a wine that was presented as being expensive.
About a year ago someone brought a box of wine to a party at my house; people who didn't see that it was from a box were very complimentary, and were also very surprised to see where it came from. Go figure!
Posted by: Claude | April 15, 2008 3:21 PM
This is a link for another wine survey about price and perception.
Posted by: Susan | April 15, 2008 3:56 PM
I am a big fan of boxed wine. I feel as if I need to come to its defense—there are so many critics out there. It's perfect for having friends over, and for lasting for a couple of weeks. It's good (some better than others) and inexpensive. If you are a habitual wine drinker, save the fancy and expensive wine for nice house dinners and special occasions. Try it, see if you like it! If you don’t have the wallet to drink expensive wine all of the time, boxed wine is good and a perfect solution.
Posted by: Bethany | April 15, 2008 3:58 PM
Claude, we once went to a fancy wine-tasting event which featured Italian white wines. The prices were not revealed until we had all tasted everything. The most expensive wine was an "archeological wine," Greco di Tufa, which I had found totally undrinkable. Would I have dumped it if I had known how much it cost ahead of time? Hard to say...
Posted by: Dahlink | April 15, 2008 4:41 PM
Ms. Bethany:
Okay, let's try this from a different direction. At least for me, drinking wine has nothing to do with the alcoholic content which seems implicit in your comment (If you are a habitual wine drinker). If a buzz or drunk is what I sought, there are probably quicker ways to that end. I drink wine for its taste. I don't really care all that much about its shipping format or even its closure device (although cork screws do have a moderately high toy point score [and in jl's case, bonus points].) Its the same reason I drink Coke, not Pepsi.
To open a good bottle of wine and smell that wonderful oaky nose is rather like the smells of a well cooked meal. Its really not snobbery, but its for the the same reason you don't use american cheese to make macaroni and cheese.
So, show me a box 'o that is comparable to my Hess Select Cab (and Black Box might be it) and I'll lay down (snobby wine term I couldn't resist) I was going to say case, but I guess carton is the correct term.
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 15, 2008 6:17 PM
"You don't use american cheese to make macaroni and cheese."
This is true. You use Velveeta
Posted by: Robert of Cross Keys | April 15, 2008 8:13 PM
Velvetta: oh, much better. Tasty.
GACK!
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 15, 2008 8:59 PM
Velveeta isn't cheese. It's what cheese eats.
Posted by: Hal Laurent, VoR | April 15, 2008 9:53 PM
Are you kidding, cheese wouldn't even eat velvetta. That stuff looks and tastes like plastic, and that's probably what it is.
Double GACK!!!!!
Posted by: Rosebud | April 16, 2008 7:35 AM
cheese wouldn't even eat velvetta
Really? I thought that was why it was called "cheese food"? :-)
Posted by: Hal Laurent, VoR | April 16, 2008 8:00 AM
Sorry, Hal, I'm a little slow this morning. Actually that's quite clever.
Posted by: Rosebud | April 16, 2008 8:23 AM
Why go to the bother of using Velvetta? You have to use a spoon, dig it out of the jar, unstick the Velvetta from the spoon...repeat as needed. Go straight for the good stuff - cheese in a can!! Yum.
Posted by: Barb | April 16, 2008 8:37 AM
Mr. Robert - You misinterpret my comment because no, I do not drink wine to just “get drunk.” I enjoy having a glass of wine after work or ordering a glass of wine while out with friends. What I meant by habitual wine drinker was, well, if you drink wine often. I certainly appreciate the taste of wine as well. As far as Black Box goes, I’ve tried and I like it… I enjoy the taste. You are right though, if someone was just drinking wine to get drunk—there are quicker means.
Posted by: Bethany | April 16, 2008 9:26 AM
A couple of observation on the finner points of mac and cheese making.
Ms. Barb, aren't you describing Cheese Wiz, not Velvetta? Not to be pedantic about your 'error' since it leads to the obvious RoCK inspired question: if Velvetta is what cheese eats, is Cheese Wiz ... (we're all adults here [at least by age], enough said.)
To tie to another wonderful thread, notice who makes these wonderful items, sold in the dairy case of your local grocer? (And that includes the cheese in a can also mentioned. How can one company make Philadelphia cream cheese, which we all buy and eat and also the big V, W and in a can (okay, I see another adult level connection I won't make any more obvious, for fear of being censored or banned. What a waste.) But they are convenient.
Now actually on point for this thread -
To the well mannered Ms. Bethany: I guess my point was, why drink something with a high Gack quotient if not for its buzz potential, simply because its a) wine and b) cheap? That's like drinking store brand cola, instead of Coke?
And finally for all you Black Box fans: with one exception everyone says 'I drink and like BB' but never say what flavour. Is it really so forgettable that your experience its like you describing your meal last evening and saying I had meat, it was good? Or are we to conclude that fans of BB don't notice if its red or white they are tasting? Its just wine.
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 16, 2008 10:06 AM
I don't know if Cheese Whiz is the same stuff that's in cheese in a can. But RoSO, that's what's so great about CIAC, it DOESN'T NEED REFRIGERATION! Is this a great country or what? Plus, it's a great way to get your dog or cat to take pills.
Posted by: Barb | April 16, 2008 11:01 AM
Well I'm sure the Kraft PR machine is going to begin a huge advertising campaign based on the fact the CIAC (this is getting a little too EVOO) Cheese Wiz and or Velvette are great choices when you have to medicate your pet. I can see the sales spike now.
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 16, 2008 11:43 AM
Dear Mr. Robert- in my twenty something salary, I simply can't afford to drink expensive wine for more than just the special occasion. Price is one of the reasons why I buy and taste is one of the reasons I enjoy boxed wine. I like the Black Box red...ah, but I do know what I taste. However, I like all three of the reds that Black Box offers. But my favorite? The Shiraz.
Posted by: Bethany | April 16, 2008 11:59 AM
Since this tread seems to having a problem staying on point, may I suggest a new thread for the sandbox: the D@L Gack scale (huricanes and earthquakes have their own scales.) What's a 1? A 10 (box 'o wine, or is that only a 5)?
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 16, 2008 12:13 PM
Blind tasting against similar bottled vint/region provide suprising results. Remember how super tuscans made it onto the stage.
Posted by: sd1planet | April 16, 2008 2:35 PM
...a problem staying on point? Since when does this blog ever stay on point? Most people's philosophy seems to be: We don't need no stinkin' point. It's a free association, anything goes. Besides, I get the feeling many people would lump box wine and canned cheese in the same category.
In fact, I like to think not staying on point is our specialty. EL
Posted by: Barb | April 16, 2008 3:04 PM
Elizabeth wrote: In fact, I like to think not staying on point is our specialty.
Exactly right. That's why this blog is so immensely informative about things I never knew I needed to know!
Posted by: Dahlink | April 16, 2008 3:26 PM
I know wandering off point is a specialty of the house (we are to peripatetic threads as the Prime Rib is to beef), but this thread seems particularly egregious (which is mostly my fault, since I did bring up american cheese.) Free association is the hallmark of my posts. Sometimes a little too free. Oh well. Off the the Gack-o-meter post.
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 16, 2008 3:49 PM
What about the new place called Taps that will have wine on tap?
Posted by: Mike | April 16, 2008 3:58 PM
Mike wrote: What about the new place called Taps that will have wine on tap?
Depends on how they are "on tap." There are systems available that tap bottles of wine just like kegs of beer, although I don't really see the point unless you can get magnums or larger bottles - you'd be changing bottles all the time!
Posted by: Mr. Old Fart | April 16, 2008 5:38 PM
In defense of scary processed cheese: No one should eat Velveeta as a cheese in a cheese and crackers type way. But it does have important uses related to its meltability - melt it slowly with Rotel canned diced tomatos and chilies, with a good dose of red pepper, and you have a nacho cheese dip that is a staple in texas and a major hit at any party, even with wine and food snobs.
Similarly, Kraft used to make a seemingly scary processed cheese product called a "jalepeno cheese roll" (6 oz.). They stopped making it, and now cooks all over the country can't make the original, very popular Spinach Madeline recipe (from Baton Rouge Junior League Cookbook) that is also a major hit, even with foodies, and which is a perfect spicy compliment to turkey on holidays. Without that jalepeno cheese roll, the dish falters, and there was at one time much discussion on the internet about substitutes, none of which are up to par.
Posted by: LJ | April 16, 2008 8:15 PM
... Velvetta ... a staple in Texas ...
Well that says it all. Gack Gack GACK
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | April 16, 2008 9:34 PM
The benefit of tap systems for wine is to eliminate spoilage. The good systems are nitous charged. The nitrous fills the top exposed part of an opened bottle so the last sip a week after opening tastes the same as the first
Posted by: sd1planet | April 17, 2008 2:53 PM