Faux foods and what I think about them
RokChik kindly sent me a couple of links (here and here) about the faux cheeseburger controversy with this note:
I actually don't keep kosher at all, but I have some cousins that do. Apparently a kosher "cheez" burger with soy "cheese" yuk, is causing a minor fury amongst people with nothing better to do.
The first article is especially amusing to me because the rabbi talking about dietary laws is named Basil Herring. Awesome and an intriguing flavor combo.
I can't speak to the religious implications, but I do have a visceral dislike of what I think of faux foods -- foods that are trying to replace something else. I'm fine with corn oil, hate the idea of margarine. Tofu is great, soy whipped cream is not. Veggie burgers? No thanks, although sometimes I think I could be happy just eating vegetables. I know these are useful foods for various reasons; I can't defend how I feel. Particularly because...
...I love trompe l'oeil foods, which I've written about on this blog here and here.
(Photo courtesy of TrytheKosherCheeseburgers.com)






Comments
How about veggie burgers with bacon?
Gack. EL
Posted by: Hal Laurent, VoR | March 16, 2008 9:34 PM
Trompe l'oeil foods are artistic attempts to look like something else. If it happens to taste good (cantaloupe ginger) so much the better. Faux foods like to pretend they are what they think they are and are just bad (to be kind.) Soy cheese is never going to taste like cheese; veggie burgers, real beef.
Posted by: Robert (the Single One) | March 16, 2008 10:16 PM
Although in general I agree, I must put in a plug for a good veggie burger ... as long as you're not trying to replace a cheeseburger with it. I love a well-made black bean burger. Virtually any veggie burger, actually, as long as it's correctly done, is pretty good in my book.
I have trouble with turkey burgers, which I find dry.
I know, I know. The only thing my husband asks for when I go away is a package of Boca Burgers in the freezer. I've never tried them. Irrational food dislike. EL
Posted by: Ordinary Michelle | March 17, 2008 7:40 AM
I've tried Boca Burgers. Gack!!
I do like Garden Burgers, though.
Posted by: Rosebud | March 17, 2008 9:11 AM
I too like Boca Burgers. I also like the black bean ones. One 4th of July we had someone attempt to substitute turkey bergers for beef ones. After an insurrection, real hamburgers appeared.
Posted by: Dave | March 17, 2008 9:13 AM
So what's the hubbub about? If you can't eat meat and cheese together, soy cheez is not cheese at all, so that sounds okay? I think soy cheese is an affront to any gods, but I'm guessing that's not the point. Basil Herring sounds fake.
Posted by: voodoopork | March 17, 2008 9:18 AM
Here's the hubbub:
http://www.buzzfeed.com/buzz/Kosher_Cheeseburger
I guess some people just don't want you to enjoy anything. When Jackie Mason is outraged, wow, you know it's serious! I think it's like some anti-fur people hate fake fur because it glorifies, oh I really don't get it. Some vegans hate tofurkey because you shouldn't enjoy something that you are pretending is something else. I don't know, it sounds like these people were all cloned at the same misery factory.
Posted by: rokchik | March 17, 2008 11:34 AM
I too have issues with "fake foods"... I've never been able to comprehend why a vegetarian would want to eat fake turkey (tofurkey) or veggie burgers simulating a real burger. I'm a partial vegetarian (trust me this would take awhile to explain, let's just say "red meat in particular repels me). Thus the idea of eating something simulating real meat seems absolutely stupid. I love vegetables. Why can't we just enjoy them as they are?
Posted by: Misha | March 17, 2008 12:44 PM
See, this is why I'm an omnivore -- I don't have to worry about eating fake food.
All the food I eat is real.
Except for back in the day when I would munch on the Swiss cheese from my little sister's plastic toy kitchen set.The Swiss cheese always looked so real!
But that was a long time ago, and I've come a long way since then.
Posted by: Sam Sessa | March 17, 2008 1:51 PM
I don't like something that pretends to be something else, either. Some of the veggie burgers are horrible, especially the ones that are trying and failing miserably to look, feel, and taste like meat.
The ones that are just veggie burgers, like Gardenburgers, some varieties of which are actually slightly green, don't bother me as much. They have a portabella mushroon burger that I really like and the black bean chipotle one is really tasty.
Posted by: Rosebud | March 17, 2008 2:21 PM
Trompe l'oeil may have drawbacks, but ostentation (eg. "Irish bacon") is plain smarmy. Canadian's have so little. Why co-opt their bacon?
Posted by: jl | March 17, 2008 3:13 PM