Petrenko, Hough, Baltimore Symphony: incendiary
It’s a wonder the fire alarms didn’t go off at Meyerhoff Symphony Hall Thursday night. The incendiary match-up of the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra, guest conductor Vasily Petrenko (right) and piano soloist Stephen Hough produced one of the most memorable concerts of the season. Things should be just as gripping when the hefty, inflammable program is repeated on Saturday.
Petrenko, born and trained in St. Petersburg, where his mentors included Yuri Temirkanov, gives every sign of being the next great Russian conductor. In 2005, at the age of 29, he assumed the podium of England’s Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra. He has been winning considerable acclaim for his work there and elsewhere. For his BSO debut, Petrenko chose to make a big statement, packing in one of the longest and most elusive of Shostakovich’s symphonies, No. 8; Tchaikovsky’s sweeping Piano Concerto No. 1; and a rarity (on these shores) by Anatoly Lyadov, the tone poem Kikimora. From the start on Thursday, Petrenko revealed remarkable control of the material and, more importantly, an ability to communicate something beyond cues, tempos and dynamics.
In 1943, Shostakovich composed his Eighth Symphony in the relative safety of the countryside northeast of Moscow. Unlike his Seventh, which captured the attention of the world with what its chilling depiction of the German invasion of the Soviet Union and the defiance of besieged Leningrad, the Eighth presented a disorienting landscape and few signposts. Here, the composer ...
digs deep into the subject of evil and loss. No stirring patriotic chords, just honest, raw emotions. There is brutality in this music, and long stretches of propulsive machine-like pounding. There is aching slowness and shadow, too. But just before the gloomy fourth movement gives way to the fifth, Shostakovich subtly, gently, movingly shifts the tonality to that most comforting and familiar of harmonies, C major. From then on, although violent outbursts will break out, the music ultimately holds out a sliver of hope to hang onto, even as uncertain bass notes question the resolve of the hushed closing chord.Petrenko deftly shaped this hour-plus, eventful journey of the spirit. The expansive first movement had terrific tension, which he heightened by unleashing the BSO’s substantial power during the waves of percussion crescendos and shrieking brass (Shostakovich's use of this threatening effect seems to have been inspired by a similar one in Mahler’s Symphony No. 2). Petrenko drove the second and third movements hard, maybe too fast for their own good, but the effect had a startling intensity.
Speaking of fast and intense, Tchaikovsky’s overly flogged warhorse headed out of the gate with a refreshing vigor and absence of sentimentality. Hough (left), the widely admired British pianist, tore into the concerto in a way that may well have horrified some listeners. I think he even managed to outdo speed demon Martha Argerich when it came to octave whirlwinds.
Well, I’ve always been of the (probably unsound) mind that nothing can be played too fast — or too slow. But what typically happens when pianists want to rip up this work is that they go for both extremes in one sitting, constantly pulling the tempo every which way to apply an interpretive stamp. Hough would never stoop to that sort of thing. What he did was simply take the concerto out of its mushy romantic nest and treat it like a great work that combines bravura with un-sticky lyricism. The proportions were always sensible, and that made all the difference.
Hough left some notes in the dust, but the electricity he produced as he charged ahead had an almost giddy effect — I’m sure I wasn’t the only one smiling in the hall. For the most part, Petrenko and the orchestra got tightly into the soloist’s brisk groove. This kind of music-making — unpredictable, risky, fearless — is as rare as it is exciting. It’s what keeps us coming back to concert halls, even to such familiar repertoire as the Tchaikovsky concerto.
The chance to savor unfamiliar repertoire is another enticement, of course, and that came in Lyadov’s 1909 Kikimora, an evocation of a Russian fairy tale about an evil spirit. It’s a colorful little work, with traces of Paul Dukas’ The Sorcerer’s Apprentice, and Petrenko had it flowing with lots of character.
Although there was plenty of fine playing from the orchestra (Jane Marvine’s English horn solos in the Lyadov and Shostakovich works were particularly sensitive), Thursday wasn’t necessarily the ensemble’s best night, technically speaking. There were occasional lapses of articulation, some loss of string tone (in the Tchaikovsky concerto), fuzzy patches in the woodwinds and brass. But this was one of those occasions when the feeling was so right, the commitment so strong that the details mattered less than the big, involving picture.
If we're lucky, BSO management will sign up Petrenko -- and Hough -- for return engagements before they leave town.
PHOTOS COURTESY OF BSO






Last night, Peabody Conservatory's relatively intimate Griswold Hall provided a showcase for violinist Netanel Draiblate, who tackled the noble Violin Concerto by Brahms with an orchestra of fellow students. Draiblate has generated a good deal of local attention while at Peabody, and he already has management, a key step in establishing a career.
The future of the Baltimore Chamber Orchestra, a fixture on the local scene for more than 25 years, remains uncertain. After being hit hard by a drop in ticket sales and contributed income, the organization has suspended operations for the remainder of this season, in the hope that fundraising will be successful enough to re-launch in the fall. The unfortunate cloud over the BCO lifted for a couple of bright hours on Sunday afternoon at Kraushaar Auditorium, where the ensemble delivered its swan-song-for-now.
As if Soltzman's remarkable gesture of performing free for the BCO weren't enough, he added a substantial encore, Poulenc's saucy, compact Sonata for Two Clarinets, with Eyal Bor, director of education for the Beth El Congregation and an accomplished player. (The BCO originally was to have performed the program at Beth El, as well as Kraushaar.)
Carlos Kalmar is back on the
In an age when piano competitions are generally devalued (the bad rap is that only bland players can win, by alienating the fewest judges), the Gilmore Artist Award has easily become a big deal. Sort of like the MacArthur Fellowship, the so-called "genius award" bestowed after an anonymous search process, the Gilmore honor, given every four years, involves no competition. Candidates have no idea they are under consideration; unknown judges travel around to listen to the talent in action. Leif Ove Andsnes (1998) and Piotr Anderszewski (2002) are representative of the honoree quality. The most recent winner,
On paper, this week's Baltimore Symphony program looked a little, well, dull. Not that I wasn't intrigued to hear a performance led by French conductor Stephane Deneve, who has been generating a good deal of buzz for several years now (and whose head of wildly explosive hair rivals James Levine's -- it's grown considerably since the photo at left was taken). Or that I wasn't interested in experiencing French pianist Frank Braley. This is the BSO debut for both musicians.
When the dancing mood resumed after intermission, Deneve gave Rachmaninoff's brilliant score an equally compelling treatment that combined effective proportions of tautness and elasticity. The conductor paid keen attention to the bittersweetness that seems so much a part of this piece, and he deftly drew out the dramatic coloring of the instrumentation. Again, there were a few unsettled spots in the playing, but the orchestra poured on the tonal and expressive warmth. Gary Louie molded the melancholy sax solo in the first movement to eloquent effect.
The season, which WNO general director Placido Domingo describes as “a perfect balance” (some might call it a perfectly conservative balance), offers six staged productions, rather than the current seven, along with a Wagner opera in concert form and a concert of operatic excerpts.
WNO’s spring season opens in March 2010 with Gershwin’s iconic Porgy and Bess. Eric Owens and Lester Lynch will alternate as Porgy, Morenike Fadayomi (right) and Indira Mahajan as Bess. (Coincidentally, Porgy and Bess and The Barber of Seville are the two works that the Baltimore Opera won't be staging this spring, having filed for Chapter 11, so Baltimore opera lovers can catch both of them in DC next season.)
The company will introduce Ambroise Thomas’ Hamlet into its repertoire in May/June 2010, featuring Carlos Alvarez in the title role, Samuel Ramey as Claudius and Diana Damrau as Ophelia. Domingo will conduct this infrequently encountered opera. He’ll also conduct a concert in October with Abdrazakov and celebrated mezzo Olga Borodina (the two singers are husband and wife).
In the quirkiest quirk of the BSO's scheduling so far this season, a big, imaginative program conducted by Marin Alsop (right) was performed exactly once over the weekend. If you missed it Friday at the Meyerhoff, you were out of luck, although one item from that evening, Brahms' Symphony No. 1, was carried over to Saturday's "Off the Cuff" presentation.
This was the second in her new "Off the Cuff" series, a concept that includes a spoken introduction (truly and coolly off the cuff in Alsop's case) and then a complete performance of a big work, with everything wrapped up in a neat package of about 75 minutes. I don't think it would have been too stuffy if Alsop had spent a little time on describing the structure of the symphony (never miss an opportunity to toss in good ol' sonata form, I say), but her remarks were entertaining and as pithy as ever. A nice touch was having the BSO's first-chair string players offer a sample of the chamber work that introduced a 12-year-old Alsop to Brahms.
Speeches and music-making are typically mixed at concerts honoring Martin Luther King. That combination worked out particularly well last night, when the BSO and Maryland Commission on African American History and Culture presented the 23rd MLK Tribute at the Meyerhoff.
Joseph Young, the BSO-Peabody Conducting Fellow and recent recipient of the Sir Georg Solti Foundation Career Grant, for a performance of Global Warming, a 1991 score by Michael Abels. It's not so much an environmentalist piece as a can't-we-all-get-along exercise. Abels introduces more or less Celtic-flavored idioms, followed by more or less Middle Eastern ones, then puts them together. It's easy on the ears, if a little light on musical depth. Young (right) had the music flowing smoothly. Concertmaster Jonathan Carney and principal cellist Ilya Finkelshteyn brought plenty of flair to the solo flurries at the start of the work, which suggest a kind of blue-grassy take on Vaughan Williams' The Lark Ascending.
And Congressman Elijah Cummings (left) delivered a short, stirring address that concluded with the lyrics to a Garth Brooks song, "We Shall Be Free," that fit the occasion perfectly:
One of the best ways to promote and preserve the cultural health of this country would be to give the arts Cabinet-level status. After Quincy Jones (left) was quoted in a recent
The Baltimore Opera has gone dark for the remainder of the season (and perhaps beyond), but the company's longtime home remains operatically active. 