Best books on war
Over on the Guardian's culture blog, Charlotte Higgins askes her readers: What is the best British novel since the war? Even before I considered possible answers, I was struck by the question itself -- one that would seem sillly in American. The war? Which war? The Brits' reference point remains World War II -- understandably, considering that Londoners faced annihilation from Hitler. But here, we've been through so many wars, semi-wars and police actions that some lose their punch as cultural touchstones. Consider Korea, Vietnam, Kuwait, Afghanistan, Iraq, not to mention the various actions in Africa and around the globe.
Great books have been born from all that human loss. In Vietnam, Tim O'Brien's "The Things They Carried," was truly memorable; so was "We Were Soldiers Once ... And Young," by Lt Gen Harold G Moore and Joseph L Galloway. In Africa, I'd pick "Black Hawk Down" by Mark Bowden. I don't know that the definitive novel on Kuwait, Iraq and Ahghanistan has been written yet, but I'm open to suggestions.








Comments
Remarque: All Quiet on the Western Front- ,Trumbo: Johnny Got his Gun, On the Beach, any of Phil Berrigan's books, recently departed Howard Zinn's. A J Muste, Ghandi (sp?), King, Simone Weill, -books by conscientious objectors...protestors...deserters, even!
doesn't Hemingway seem a bit too much in love w the macho?
Ha, i beat the war mongers to the punch
any book that praises war in the slightest? A soldier wld question it!!
I wonder if there's really been a good pro war book? Name me one.
The Things We Carried, for example- is revolting in its realism- but is there a protest in it?
here comes the capcha- was gilsey
today written by Louis Caroll
Posted by: david eberhardt | February 4, 2010 2:41 PM
We used to live in Auburn, so I got to meet General Moore and hear him speak. He is a remarkable man and it was fascinating to hear him speak. I read his book and learned a lot even though some of it was over my head.
Posted by: Kathy R (Bermudaonion) | February 4, 2010 3:50 PM
I'd have to say "Dispatches" by Michael Herr. I was born after the Vietnam War and we never really covered it in History class, but Herr's writing is so visceral that at times I think I can imagine what that era must have been like.
Posted by: Shannon | February 5, 2010 7:56 AM
Now I remember- the greatest war book is, hands down- Poems- Wilfred Owen- I have a copy of the first american edition- publisher was heubsch- if i remember-cost me plenty- but the first english ed?- outta site- thousands.
Owen's haunting poems are made more powerful by the fact that he lived the stuff of which he writes- he killed (i believe) and was killed- World War 1- western front- if i ever visit his grave- i will b so sad- but also inspired!!!
His verse has a vatic, hymnic, phrasing, rhythm and meaning that is extra powerful- it almost rises off the page.
"Strange Meeting" - "You are the enemy I killed, my friend"- and so on...
If that doesn't make a conscientious objector out of you- i don't know what would. and yet many have not got that far in english class
Posted by: david eberhardt | February 8, 2010 4:05 PM