baltimoresun.com

« More than 140,000 behind on mortgage payments | Main | The market for pricey homes »

November 23, 2010

Report: Two years of "shadow inventory" looming over Md.'s housing market

In today's topsy-turvy housing market, the number of homes that soon could be for sale is just as important to know as the number that actually are.

Here's why: The so-called "shadow inventory" of seriously delinquent borrowers whose properties are in danger of landing on the housing market in Maryland are so numerous that these homes would take a full two years to find buyers at August's pace of sales, according to a new report from real estate data firm CoreLogic.

That's the worst in the nation -- in part because Maryland has been hard-hit by the foreclosure crisis, but also because the pace of sales dropped faster here than in the country as a whole after the federal homebuyer tax credit expired.

CoreLogic, which calculated the shadow-inventory figure by analyzing the number of homes whose owners were at least three months behind on their mortgages, said the top states after Maryland (at 24.4 months) were New Jersey (24.1 months), Illinois (23 months), Florida (20.8 months) and Georgia (19.5 months).

As a region, the Baltimore metro area was somewhat better off than the state as a whole. Its 18.3 months of supply ranked it 17th among the 50 largest metro areas. (Miami was tops, at just over 33 months.)

"The weak demand for housing is significantly increasing the risk of further price declines in the housing market," Mark Fleming, CoreLogic's chief economist, said in a statement. "This is being exacerbated by a significant and growing shadow inventory that is likely to persist for some time due to the highly extended time-to-liquidation that servicers are currently experiencing."

Economist Sam Khater with CoreLogic said in an email that the homebuyer tax credit "has really made analyzing the market tricky."

"Absent the impact of the tax credit, traditionally the largest months’ supply have been in the distressed states" such as Florida, Michigan and California, he wrote. "After the tax credit expired, sales collapsed throughout the US, but especially in the upper segment of the price distribution. Therefore states with above average sales prices (especially NJ/MD) experienced a collapse in sales that was larger than the US. This caused states like a NJ or MD to experience pronounced increases in months’ supply."

But how long will the "tax credit hangover" last? That's what a lot of people would like to know. The assumption is that home sales that would be happening now and into early 2011 instead were made late last year and early this year as buyers rushed to get up to $8,000 apiece.

If so, and home sales pick up the pace after early 2011, then the months' supply of shadow inventory will recede in Maryland.

Only assuming the number of seriously delinquent borrowers doesn't get worse. (At last count, fewer Marylanders were newly falling behind.)

Posted by Jamie Smith Hopkins at 7:00 AM | | Comments (11)
Categories: Distress sales, The foreclosure mess
        

Comments

is there an echo in here?

"If so, and home sales pick up the pace after early 2011, then the months' supply of shadow inventory will recede in Maryland."

"no if's and's or but's" allowed

There's a whole lot of if's in the housing market these days.

Ill say it again to the " Shadow Lurkers" on this blog. I would bet that you could take 100k off the price of every home in the metro area and you would still have a Ho-Hum market.
Instead of an MLS, we should switch teh tables and list a buyers MLS. It would show well qualified buyers and what they are looking for such that the banks could woo them instead of the other way around.

Look at how many people are asking for half a mil for some ho-hum MCrap shack. LOOK AT IT!. Do you realize that in order to afford a 450k home with a 20% down paymentthat you need to have 100k/year stable income? Oh and regarding that down payment. Twenty percent is 90k not including closing cost, trasfers etc. How many people want to throw down there life savings at the risk of watching it evaporate in a year when the house goes from 450k to 350k? Thnk I am blowing smoke? Ask folks that bought a year ago when the market was at a "discount".

If you want to know what a house is worth, use 2001 as a reference point. In the absence of hocus pocus loans, home improvement get rich quick shows, and easy credit, there was no reason for ANY price increase during the last decade. The economy was much stronger then too.
Course maybe i am wrong, maybe i should sign up for a *sweet* $3000/month x 30years so people can glowing rave about my stainless and granite combo.

Just another reason to sell property at auction. No inspections, no contingencies. Set your reserve and bring the buyers to you.

Or better still, another reason to invest in real estate. There has never been a better time to own. So many former home owners looking for a house to rent.

When the shadows meet the daylight, there is gonna be some serious price drops. As I have said all along, 1999 prices, unless the Federal Reserve is successful at making the dollar worthless

Who would have thought this would happen? What a big surprise. Never saw that one coming...

Where are the pumpers who said you have buy NOW!!!!

Never understood that tax credit...it's only 8000$ and house prices were some 30-50 x greater. 8000 is a value of a comma in realtorspeak.

Darwin has a very real point. My contention has long been that the only way out of this mess was to inflate away the debt. IF the dollar is work half as much, a gallon of milk cost $6 instead of $3. Presuming wages double but, only aificially not in real terms, then we would all make twice as much while our debts would be half as much by comparision. Our debts were made in yesterdays dollars. Sounds great, right? Problem is that China as well as other investors wont tolerate us halving the value of their principle by devaluing our own dollar. Think of it this way. If i borrowed $100 from you in 1980 and paid it back today, it would be the equivalent of iving you back say... $15 the day you lent in to me in 1980. Forget about interest, i am just talking the return of your principle.

My fiance and I just bought a house after 10 months of looking. A brief summary of our experience:
1. First three offers were met with unreasonable counter-offers from the sellers. In each case, we said thanks but no thanks and moved on. In all 3 cases, our agent got calls a few weeks or months later that the sellers were really motivated and had dropped the price. Some admitting getting no other offers (not sure why they'd tell a buyer agent that, but they did). In one case, they held an open house and no one came, then our agent got a call two days later. In all 3 cases, the properties are still on the market, now with reduced prices. They've all been on the market over 6 months.
2. The reasonable, yet motivated, sellers have been able to sell. Not every house was right for us, but there were a few we walked away from knowing that someone else would buy them, because the pricing was reasonable. Over time, each of those houses has sold for pretty close to what the seller was asking to start with. They just weren't right for us (only 2 BR, street parking issues, etc).
3. This brings me to my 3rd point... why bother listing your house unreasonably high to begin with? It means no one will come look at the place. If you won't accept less than 300k and the house should really sell for 250k in this market, why bother at all? Just wait 5 yrs and pray a lot, I guess. In this market, you're just wasting your time and a RE agents' time trying to get anything near peak value for your house.
4. Sellers, take your RE agent's advice or else go look at a lot of houses yourselves. Because then you'll see the competition. Many areas have dozens of houses for sale withina few blocks. If your house is priced significantly higher than similar ones in your area, stop wasting your time.
5. Keep in mind that if your house hasn't been modernized or renovated in 20+ years, it's not worth nearly what the similar-but-renovated house on the next block is worth. And if your house is ugly and old looking, don't bother listing unless you truly realize that you're going to have to discount. Be honest: Are you kitchen cabinets, counters, bathrooms, floors, and windows 20+ years old? If so, sorry but you're going to have to discount.
5. Don't underestimate how much foreclosures and short sales pull down prices on other homes. Many entry-leve/young buyers would rather fix up a foreclosure/short sale and take their time working with banks to get approval for bank-owned properties rather than buy a non-foreclosed house that needs updating anyway and costs much more money.
6. I feel bad for alot of the older folks out there trying to sell their house. It's their biggest asset, but they're facing a harsh market with critical buyers. They could've sold for much more money 3-4 yrs ago, even with old appliance and ugly carpet, but now no one wants their houses unless it's 50k off asking prices. It's not their fault the market is rough, but they're paying the price.
7. Reasonable sellers are rare, so when you find one, work with them! We finally found some sellers who came back with a reasonable counter, we loved their house, and we could tell they really were serious and motivated. They met us most of the way towards our price and even though we could've waited them out and gotten them down some more, we wanted to lock in 3.875% 30 yr fixed rate mortgage, so we ended up accepting their counter at a great price. Meanwhile, the other sellers have still been calling our RE agent trying to get us to come make another offer on their house. All those houses will end up selling for less than we would've paid and they'll be waiting til spring or summer, most likely. All because they were like immovable objects when it came to negotiating.

Where is Greg Northrop? We need him to respond to this report!!!

I referred this topic to my son and his fiance, who are looking to buy. And I agree with Chappy 10's comments.

Sellers have to get real. The days when desperate buyers would pay any price for a house in lousy condition are long since over. I've told my son and his fiance that they should try to drive a hard bargain. Ask for at least a 20% reduction in the asking price. Especially if they see a house that's been on the market for 6 months to a year.

The sooner sellers realize that the market has dramatically changed, and that it's not going back to what it was, the better.

Post a comment

All comments must be approved by the blog author. Name-calling aimed at other commenters is not welcome here. Please do not resubmit comments if they do not immediately appear. You are not required to use your full name when posting, but you should use a real e-mail address. Comments may be republished in print, but we will not publish your e-mail address. Our full Terms of Service are available here.

Verification (needed to reduce spam):

About Jamie Smith Hopkins
Jamie Smith Hopkins, a Baltimore Sun reporter since 1999, writes about the regional economy. Her reporting on the housing market has won national and local awards. Hopkins is a Columbia native and has lived in Maryland all her life, save for 10 months spent covering schools in Ames, Iowa.
She trained to become a wonk by spending large chunks of time as a geek and an insufferable know-it-all.
Baltimore Sun articles by Jamie
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Most Recent Comments
Baltimore Sun coverage
Baltimore Sun Real Estate section
Archive: Dream Home
Dream Home takes readers into the houses of area residents who have found their ideal home.
Sign up for FREE business alerts
Get free Sun alerts sent to your mobile phone.*
Get free Baltimore Sun mobile alerts
Sign up for Business text alerts

Returning user? Update preferences.
Sign up for more Sun text alerts
*Standard message and data rates apply. Click here for Frequently Asked Questions.
  • Sign up for the At Home newsletter
The home and garden newsletter includes design tips and trends, gardening coverage, ideas for DIY projects and more.
See a sample | Sign up

Charm City Current
Categories
Stay connected