Real estate closing costs on the rise
If you got a "good faith estimate" for a loan last year and again more recently, the closing-cost figure probably went way up.
Closing costs -- minus taxes -- are about 35 percent higher on lenders' good faith estimates in Maryland and nationwide this year, Bankrate.com says in its annual mortgage fee survey.
Some of that jump is actual, honest-to-goodness increase. But a big part of it, Bankrate says, is more honesty. Or at least more careful calculation.
"Before this year, lenders were not penalized for underestimating fees in the good faith estimate. Now they are penalized for lowballing fees," the company says, referring to a federal rule that went into effect Jan. 1.
Maryland's closing costs, not including taxes, average $3,402 for a $200,000 loan, according to Bankrate's survey of lenders. That ranked the state 15th lowest.
Bankrate picked one area in each state for its cost survey -- not including California, where it studied costs in two metro areas. In Maryland, it looked at the 21236 ZIP code, Nottingham in Baltimore County.
About $1,500 of the total here is for origination and the rest -- about $1,900 -- is for title and third-party fees. (Here's the 2009 study, for comparison.)
Bankrate compared good faith estimates for a $200,000 loan on a $240,000 purchase. It didn't include taxes and escrow fees, which vary a lot from one area to another and can be substantial.
Take transfer taxes, for instance. If you're buying in Baltimore, they'll add $3,600 to your tab for a $240,000 home.
Categories: Closing costs, Resources for new buyers & owners



Comments
And thus the scam continues. Super low interest rates are the bait, with the a) Buyer scammed by the overpriced home or b) the owner scammed by the overpriced closing.
The only way to win in a losers game is to NOT PLAY!
Posted by: Darwin Rules | August 18, 2010 10:55 AM
This is very true. Banks are increasing their fees in an effort to drive additional revenue. Appraisal costs have increased as well with the implementation of HVCC. Overall things are becoming more costly for the consumer. Not exactly the way to stimulate the economy.
Posted by: Mortgage in Sarasota | August 18, 2010 12:46 PM
I thought that all of the additional government regulation with the new GFE, new HUD1 form, and HVCC were supposed to make things safer and cheaper for everyone :). I guess it didn't quite work out that way.
Posted by: Grover | August 18, 2010 1:32 PM
I think the main point of the good faith estimate regulation was to keep buyers from being shocked at the settlement table by how much higher their closing costs were compared with the estimate, Grover. :-)
Posted by: Jamie Smith Hopkins | August 18, 2010 1:39 PM
The State's MD Mortgage Program (MMP) recently increased the base amount for its Downpayment and Settlement Expense Loan Program (DSELP) from $3,500 to $5,000 for borrowers who apply and are approved for an MMP loan. The MMP also lowered its interest rate to 4.25%. For more information, go to http://tinyurl.com/32hfmdz
Posted by: R. Cruz | August 18, 2010 3:28 PM
Thanks, Rosa. I blogged about the change here: http://weblogs.baltimoresun.com/business/realestate/blog/2010/08/state_program_ups_its_downpayment_help.html
Posted by: Jamie Smith Hopkins | August 18, 2010 3:30 PM
It's OK with me if they get more money for their honest work. I would personally pay them even more. However, in case of foreclosure down the road, all the closing costs monies (and provisions/commissions) should be paid back.
Posted by: Benny | August 18, 2010 8:42 PM
Attempting to cash out before the wave of ARMs and Alt-As reset???? Then nobody will buy a home.
Posted by: ironhide196 | August 19, 2010 12:46 AM
With the first time home buyers, the buyer isn't supposed to pay the taxes, but when you buy a government owned property, the government doesn't pay taxes. Someone has to the pay the taxes, so it goes back to the buyer and their costs go up.
I tried the DSELP, that was a complete waste to do the counseling program. I don't have any credit issues but I was required to do the program anyway and every time I turned around there was some other hoop to jump through. They dragged everything out and by the time they went to put in my application which I was on the lady about for over a week, conviently the program ran out of money the day before she submitted my application. I have no credit issues, I don't need the counseling program but I had to have it to apply to the DSELP.
Those programs can take up to a year if you have credit issues, but if you don't have credit issues and have all your ducks in a row you can do the program in two weeks. Get the program done before you even put an offer on the house, chances are you'll still be working on the program when it comes time to settle.
Posted by: Pigtown | August 19, 2010 8:28 AM
check out the livebaltimore sit:
www.livebaltimore.com
the site has a bunch of down payment programs, grants and a list of all the approved counseling programs, however these are home buying counseling programs.
Posted by: Pigtown | August 19, 2010 8:31 AM
I went once to LiveBaltimore @ the Charles. The nice lady volunteering turned out to be a realtor.
Posted by: Scott | August 19, 2010 2:32 PM
My guess is that this is more a result of lenders overestimating the fees for fear of tripping tolerances than actual costs increasing. The best and most accurate analysis would be done on signed HUD-1 Settlement Statements, not GFEs.
Posted by: Derek Massey | August 19, 2010 6:22 PM
From my understanding a lot of the volunteers at the actual place are local business owners who advertise on the website, easier just to use the website then go in if you dont want to be bothered.
Better to overestimate then underestimate and not have enough at the table.
Posted by: pigtown | August 20, 2010 12:12 PM
I definitely feel like costs are going up. With all the new forms and disclosures...it is costlier to complete the transactions now. With the tolerances...it seems that loan officers, especially ones that work for mortgage brokers are aiming high to prevent having to redisclose. Unfortunately, there has been so little true guidance from HUD, the feds...that many, many industry people are still in the dark. It seems that each lender is interpreting things differently as well. Bring back the old HUD form as it was much simpler than the new one.
Posted by: Murfreesboro Homes | August 28, 2010 7:38 AM