Choosing where to move: BRAC edition
Harford County figures it's bused 1,000 people down from New Jersey over the past two years to tour its communities. Cecil County has had bus tours of its own, plus one economic development employee there has -- by her count -- conducted 76 individual tours by car, van and truck just this year. Baltimore County organized a bus tour in May for about 70 people. And last weekend, Live Baltimore gave 33 folks a two-day "consider the city" pitch.
Relocating here for BRAC? You are in demand, in case you hadn't noticed.
The national base realignment and closure process is sending thousands of jobs to Aberdeen Proving Ground in Harford County and Fort Meade in Anne Arundel County. Because Fort Meade's jobs are largely coming from nearby Northern Virginia, the "won't you be my neighbor" action is focused on Fort Monmouth workers whose jobs are headed from New Jersey to APG.
I tagged along on Live Baltimore's BRAC tour on Sunday -- you can read the story about it here -- and it was interesting to see the city through the eyes of Fort Monmouth workers. The chatter ranged from property taxes to neighborhood comparisons -- Homeland reminded one worker of Princeton -- to "The Wire," the critically acclaimed HBO drama that isn't exactly an advertisement for Baltimore's quality of life.
Live Baltimore's talking points included this on the subject of television: "Although many people stereotype Baltimore by the storylines they see on HBO's 'The Wire,' it is a work of fiction. Baltimore is not unlike many metropolitan cities where drugs are to blame for much of the crime problem."
The nonprofit group has all the upsides of a sizable city to help make its case for Baltimore living -- museums, sports teams, walkable neighborhoods, funky stores and the like. But staffers have their work cut out for them in the BRAC competition.
Jim Richardson, director of economic development in Harford County, said his office's study of early movers shows about 80 percent of them living in Harford. Even considering that many early movers are higher-level managers who need to live near the post, that's a big number.
And Cecil County, the rural exurb to the north, seems to be getting a close look from prospective movers. Its two bus tours -- last May and November -- were packed. Erika Quesenbery, marketing coordinator for the Office of Economic Development there, says she's done 76 tours since January for people who drove down from New Jersey on their own.
Easter weekend alone, "we had 14 different couples that came in." She had to enlist her husband and parents to help. Other community members are giving tours, too -- too many for Quesenbery to keep track of them all.
"I'm very attuned now to seeing New Jersey license plates," she said.
It's not just home sales and tax dollars at stake. Counties want Fort Monmouth personnel for their brains. In the "knowledge economy" that everyone talks about, highly trained workers are a boon.
Harford County, as it happens, offers the reverse of Live Baltimore's "we're only 30 minutes from APG" argument:
"Certainly we use Baltimore City as a drawing point, that you can be 30 minutes from downtown," Richardson said.
I know some of you are skeptical that BRAC workers will opt for city living over suburb. But Baltimore already has some BRAC folks, despite the competition.
Eric Pilsmaker, 27, moved to Baltimore from Pittsburgh after taking a BRAC analyst job with a consulting firm.
"I asked colleagues ... where they lived, and they both lived in Baltimore," he said. "I figured for a young guy like me, I'm not interested in living out in Harford County. Baltimore's a really attractive option."
Are you a BRAC mover? A local resident seeing BRAC activity? Share your experiences.







Comments
I think it's great that people are considering living in the city. Baltimore has a lot to offer most of these folks and hopefully some make the decision that Baltimore is the place to be. However, I personally do not believe that a large portion of these people will decide that the city is the place to live. The high taxes, high crime, generally poor schools, and parking issues do not shine the best light on city living. Sure there are some great things about the city (it's why I live there) but the majority of these workers have good incomes and families that will hinder Baltimore being their choice.
Also, as a fan of the Wire series and reading a lot about how it was developed and who wrote the stories, I highly disagree with the statement ""Although many people stereotype Baltimore by the storylines they see on HBO's 'The Wire,' it is a work of fiction". Ask any cop or local writer (Which the two writers of the Wire are) and they will tell you the series is dead on accurate.
Posted by: M | September 16, 2009 7:40 AM
I'm a BRAC person, though my story is atypical. I moved FROM Baltimore to NJ then back.
I recently purchased a home in Towson, while most of my colleagues who have relocated here have moved to Harford or Cecil, very few have chosen or are even seriously considering Baltimore City or County.
The "B word" scares them.
Posted by: bryanintimonium | September 16, 2009 9:04 AM
I am not, but if I were moving to the area, I would chose the suburbs.
Having kids would dictate looking for a safe/secure community with excellent schools.
While Baltimore may or may not be as bad as portrayed in "The Wire", it is still not a place I would want to raise my family.
Posted by: bdc | September 16, 2009 10:21 AM
My husband and I are Ivy League grads who have lived in inner city Balitmore for nine years. We have raised both our sons here and they have received excellent educations in the Baltimore City School system. Our older son is in the IB program at Baltimore City College High School and our younger son is in Ingenuity at Roland Park Middle (both are blue-ribbon schools). Even though we live in a neighborhood that actually appears on occasion on "The Wire," we have not had any trouble with crime. Give this beautiful city and its historic homes a chance.
Posted by: UnionSquare | September 16, 2009 12:57 PM
What bryanintimonium said.
Posted by: JTK | September 16, 2009 2:21 PM
UnionSquare, i'm interested which neighborhood you live in, which you refer to as "inner city?"
Posted by: skeptic | September 16, 2009 4:33 PM
skeptic, I'm guessing UnionSquare lives in Union Square. Here's a link to a neighborhood website: www.union-square.us
Posted by: Jamie Smith Hopkins | September 16, 2009 4:51 PM
I'm part of BRAC, I am making the move in the near future. In my travels to APG have come to love Harford and Cecil, strong schools and close to base. Lower taxes then Baltimore, and more importantly, I'm giong to live closer to NJ and still be withing 15 mins of base.
Anyone moving down MUST consider a CLARK TURNER HOME. Since my wife is upset with the relocation, I promised she can design our new Clark Turner Home. Thanks and good luck
Posted by: Steve McClain | September 17, 2009 8:56 AM
Jamie is right. Union Square lives in Union Square, among a racially diverse group of young professionals, families and empty nesters who love the Victorian park, Hollins Market restaurants, Southwest Baltimore Charter School and easy access to downtown, the MARC, and the Gwynns Falls Bike Path. Most of all we love the fact that we know and like our neighbors.
Posted by: UnionSquare | September 17, 2009 9:32 AM
Steve McClain,
You wouldn't happen to be a salesperson who works for Clark Turner, would you? If you're going to shill for your company on a news blog, then at least have the decency to not bash Baltimore City in the process.
I apologize in advance if you truly are an APG employee and an enthusiastic CLARK TURNER HOMES buyer.
Posted by: MCG | September 17, 2009 10:45 AM
Union Square: As someone from an Ivy, I've heard so many fellow alumni use it as a trump card. As if our opinion matters more because we went more prestigious school. (And remember: At HYP the others are bashed.) But your posts suggest that you relish in pulling even more trump cards.
1. Why pull the race card? Is race the only thing that matters in diversity? There is more to people than skin color. Are you implying some superiority to wasps that move elsewhere? Your insinuation is subtle, but your other points make it clear. And I'm sure you're just frustrated, which is fine.
If you must know, one of the thing that drove me away from Baltimore were the race-based politics and what I perceive as reverse discrimination (for city bids) that hamstrings businesses and drives up taxes.
2. You were lucky to segregate your children from their underperforming peers in your neighborhood. My children might not have the same aptitude as yours; I cannot risk putting my children in an underperforming school if they don't test as well as your children to go elsewhere. Not everyone has the luxury of brilliant children.
3. Why acerbic tone about your neighbors? Those of us outside the city can do that, too, even if our houses are more separated and we aren't forced to come together to intentionally better our environment. Bonds can be formed under different circumstances, including wealth, safe neighborhoods, and overpriced status cars.
4. I once lived in the city and crime was a problem for my area. While I was never robbed, my neighbors were. A quick search of union square on crime stat from Aug 22 + 14 days shows that there was a rape, about 10 burglaries, 8 aggravated assaults, and several larcanies from vehicles. I'm glad that you haven't had anything happen to you, but your neighbors were less fortunate.
Posted by: Someone | September 17, 2009 11:12 AM
The "b" word will scare some just like cecil/harford will scare some. The fact is that where you decide to live is such a personal choice that neighborhoods are hard to choose from let alone counties. Luckily for the transferee, we have as diverse a choice as anywhere in the country.
Posted by: cdie | September 17, 2009 12:07 PM
Clark Turner? Bwahahahahaha
Look at the price history on this place crammed onto a postage stamp, sloped lot amongst 50 year old homes in a neighborhood with street wide enough for one car, no sidewalks - oh, but you can see the green of a golf hole from an upstairs window! HA! Perfect for a BRAC-er. Buy now - already at a $179,000 discount! What will price be after another 262 days on the market??!!
http://alturl.com/xuxx
Posted by: Darwin Rules | September 17, 2009 12:57 PM
Darwin Rules, the link doesn't work unless you're registered on that site.
Beyond that, I beg of you folks -- let's not get into a "this builder is the BEST!!" // "No, the WORST!!" conversation. It makes my teeth hurt. Also, for that matter, "my jurisdiction is the BEST!!" // "no, it's the WORST!!"
Posted by: Jamie Smith Hopkins | September 17, 2009 1:10 PM
OK jamie - understood. Thanks. Stick to forest, not trees (or homes built on treeless lots)
Posted by: Darwin Rules | September 17, 2009 2:12 PM
Well put, DR. Thanks.
Posted by: Jamie Smith Hopkins | September 17, 2009 2:18 PM
Spot on assessment from "someone" and "MCG". I agree Jamie. One thing I like about this blog is that it doesn't have a lot of BSing about irrelevant topics. Let's keep it that way.
Posted by: M | September 17, 2009 4:36 PM
I think your "style of life", whatever it may be, will dictate to a certain degree, where you will live. After all, it's about you and the "quality of life" you can afford and be comfortable with.
Posted by: Mel | September 18, 2009 6:21 PM
To All BRAC personel. I just wanted to pass on a few words of advice for living in the Harford and Cecil county areas. First and formost, RESEARCH the area you want to live in. It you want to live in the country you need to accept that the farm next door to you will be doing farming activities, such as spreading manure, plowing , etc.... Complaining to the farmer and the county officials will only make you the ***hole that moved in. If its not your thing, there lots of semi rural areas that are very nice and quiet that you would like. Second, really research the builders you are interested in. Many of the local builders and developers see people moving in from out of state as easy marks. MAny of the builders will lie through there teeth on the subject of quality and location just to get your money. I have heard numerous stories of homes less than 5 years old that are literally falling apart due to shoddy construction. There are a number of small custom builders who do outstanding work an are honest to a fault. I only say all this because I have seen too many people get over charged and decieved by people only caring how much money they could squeeze from them. Just use your head and dont be taken in by all the fancy add ons and you will come out on top and find both countys to be a great place to live. Best of luck and I hope this helps.
Posted by: Joe | September 30, 2009 4:35 PM