Daylight savings: Government plot to rule the world?
Libertarian Alex Tabarrok is honest and subtle enough to suggest that, were the government to propose daylight savings time today, he would be against it, thinking it an example of central-planning meddling and futility. And yet, and yet...
Had the idea of a government plan to shift the clocks back and forth twice and year been proposed today I am reasonably certain that I would have been against it. I probably would have argued that it would be chaotic, inefficient and unnecessary (private firms could agree with their employees to change working hours at any time, right?). Central planning of time! Washington bureaucracy messing with the clocks! Get your government hands off my time!And yet, it works and I like it. It is good to be reminded of this twice a year.







Comments
A sign of the time, indeed.
Posted by: NotableM | March 15, 2010 10:34 AM
In what way do you suggest it "works"? There are many who suggest that the purported "energy savings" of DST are a sham. This writer is only one of many:
http://greatergreaterwashington.org/post.cgi?id=5185
or: http://www.standardtime.com/
I suspect that the issue with many who dislike DST stems from believing the studies that basically allege the government is "lying" about saving energy,. and thus must have some other nefarious purpose in mind..... as in "look, just admit that you like the sunlight better, so you can keep the kids out of your hair for another hour in the summer!"
It's not really an issue for me; in general, I benefit from DST. But my wife and her family, who hail from Arizona, hate it.
Posted by: Alexander D. Mitchell IV | March 15, 2010 11:28 AM
The idea of standardized time is a private-sector one anyway; it's so we can all agree on when a train arrives when it isn't traveling in an exact North-to-South line. After that first step, the idea of monkeying with an hour here or there is small potatoes.
Posted by: Isambard Kingdom Brunel | March 15, 2010 12:05 PM
In what way does it work? Isn't that simply a matter of your point of view? I hate having it dark again when I wake up.
p.s. (Feel free to erase this part of the comment before publishing because I hate nitpickers, too) It's Daylight Saving Time.
Posted by: Dragon Lady | March 15, 2010 12:23 PM
I'm glad it works for you, but it doesn't work for us in the agricultural sector at all.
For example:
We have to wait for the dew to lighten before harvesting ground corps, regardless what hour it is. After harvesting all day, it would be great to get a run in to market like we can on some late fall crops, but no. It turned 5 o'clock an hour earlier and the market (silo, mill, etc) is closed, thus shortening our day. And if we have hired laborers, we have to have them get there an hour later ( which is an hour less pay) lest they stand around idle waiting for the fields to dry. But no, the UFW or FLOC would never allow that to happen!
Posted by: E. Bolin | March 15, 2010 2:12 PM
I'm with Dragon Lady. Getting up in the dark is the pits, and since I have to turn lights on, where are the energy savings? Last week it was light when I got up, and light when I got home from work. This week, I'm getting up in the dark, and the extra hour of light in the evening doesn't mean a whole lot. Making the change a few weeks later would make more sense all around.
Posted by: Barbara | March 15, 2010 4:22 PM
Regardless of whether the clock is moved forward or back parents and kids are still leaving home in the morning in the dark. So let's eliminate the games and just decide whether to have DST year round or not. The negatives of changing the clock twice a year have been proven to be real and far outweigh any benefits of "saving" daylight, whether it be at one end of the day or the other.
Posted by: Dan | March 16, 2010 8:02 AM
Paul Harvey said it best: We're lemmings, running off the cliff twice a year.
Posted by: Kevin | March 16, 2010 3:04 PM
Hi all,
I'm glad it works for you, but it doesn't work for us in the agricultural sector at all.
==============================
avelino
Compare ISAs
Posted by: avelino lobo | April 30, 2010 12:43 AM