Could the government someday tax Roth IRAs?
Interesting piece from Ron Lieber on how the government might someday tax Roth IRAs, which are supposed to be all-but-exempt from taxation once you fund them with after-tax dollars. It would be a great betrayal and breed even higher levels of anti-government cynicism if Washington were to ever subject Roth assets to double taxation.
At the most extreme end, the federal government might try to tax the earnings on a Roth after all, say through the capital gains tax, which is currently at 15 percent for long-term gains but could go up in the next few years. Or it might levy some sort of an excise tax on excessive balances, however those might be defined.Roths are especially useful for estate planning purposes. Regular I.R.A. holders have to start taking money out once they reach the age of 70 and a half, but Roth owners don’t have to take money out during their lifetimes. Heirs of Roth holders, meanwhile, pay no income taxes when they cash out of the inherited account and can spread those distributions over an entire lifetime, allowing for decades more of tax-free growth thanks to the wonders of compound interest. Some part of this could certainly change.








Comments
Nice post. I agree that programs are begun by the Feds, Investment Bankers/Banks, Americans in good faith use the programs -the the game changes and taxes are created because our government is so corrupt.
We as Americans need to take responsibility for the our decision and take back control of the government. We can fire the Federal Government - we only need 33 states to Unite and they are gone - are you in? Call your state representatives, not Congress and let them know you support Firing the Federal Government. and let's get it done.
Nice post
Posted by: JanSimpson | July 21, 2009 1:13 PM
Gains?
Wall Street took care of most of that problems last year.
This betrayal would raise widespread outrage.
Posted by: save_the_rustbelt | July 21, 2009 4:44 PM
I fully expect them to tax IRA's and justify it by simply saying they NEED the money. I seem to remember when SS was supposed to be tax exempt...not anymore.
Posted by: jack cowart | July 23, 2009 11:55 AM
Do you really trust the government not to tax ROTH IRA's in the future?
As for me, I'm taking my tax breaks now. I hope I'm wrong but I doubt it.
Posted by: Ray | February 8, 2010 2:52 PM