Gary Becker: Offshore drilling, yes; windfall oil tax, no
University of Chicago Nobelist Gary Becker says the economic benefits from offshore drilling will be significant even if the price of oil declines from its present level. A windfall profit tax on oil companies, he says, will discourage future exploration and production.
Although the risks of offshore drilling are much harder to quantify than the benefits, I believe the shift in the benefit-cost ratio has been large enough so that the time has come to allow drilling. Norway and Great Britain, to take two examples, have allowed drilling in the North Sea for many years without suffering major environmental damage.An excess profits tax that is expected to persist for many years discourages further exploration for oil simply because much of the profits on new oil production would be taxed away. In 1980, President Jimmy Carter introduced a windfall tax on oil companies to prevent them from profiting a lot from the high price of oil due to the Iran-Iraq war. An evaluation by the Congressional Research Service, a think tank that provides reports to Congress, concluded that the tax significantly reduced domestic oil production and raised oil imports. Disillusionment with the tax led to its abandonment in 1987. Yet the lessons from this fiasco have been forgotten, for since the post-Katrina rise in gasoline prices in 2005, members of Congress have made regular attempts to introduce legislation with a sizable excess profits tax on oil companies.
Comments
In the short term, off shore drilling may help reduce the price of oil but it seems that it will only delay any substantive action on global warming. Are economists evaluating the possible impact on the domestic and global economy when New York and other major coastal cities are under water because of our mindless pursuit of and reliance on fossil fuels?
Posted by: Laura | June 23, 2008 6:02 PM
Won't offshore drilling produce oil that will be sold on the global market? If this is true, it seems the effect of drilling off the coast of Florida and other U.S. states will be incredibly diluted by what world demand will be when the first barrel of oil from these sources get to a refinery.
Posted by: Wenzell Carter DDS | August 4, 2008 9:25 PM
i don't understand what you could mean???I have inflated my tires and man ooo man am i rollin...down down down down down....i luv my inflated tires...they are on my car....and boy are they round....maybe even rounder than they were before....before i inflated them that is...isn't it great to have inflated tires....i know how much i enjoy it when my tires are inflated....i think everyone should have inflated tires...don't you....boy i sure am glad my tires are inflated....you should try it....as a matter of fact...i think everyone should have inflated tires....and when you inflate your tires you will be as happy as i am....i luv my inflated tires just as much as i hate haliburton...don't you hate haliburton...i know i hate haliburton...if you don't hate haliburton you should....if you luv your inflated tires be sure to hate haliburton....thank you so very much....TT
Posted by: TOMMIETUTONE | November 18, 2008 2:19 AM