Installing Windows on a Mac: The good, the bad, and the ugly
On Friday my Mac Pro upgrades arrived via UPS from Other World Computing – a 4 gigabyte memory kit and two 500 gigabtye Seagate Barracuda hard drives.
I installed them over the weekend – perhaps the easiest hardware upgrade I’ve ever performed. Thanks, Apple.
With the hard drives installed, I moved on to Phase 2: installing a copy of Windows XP Professional on one of the auxiliary drives using Apple’s Bootcamp utility.
Bootcamp worked as advertised, though I’m not sure I’d recommend it to users who aren’t particularly tech savvy. I can see such people getting very nervous during the install process. As Apple warns, making the wrong selection from one of the DOS-looking text menus along the way could wipe the Mac operating off your hard drive. I’d hate to be the tech support guy taking that call.
Once Windows XP was installed, the Mac Pro rebooted into Windows (creepy, I know). That’s when things turned sour.
Within seconds, Windows started to nag me with warning balloons bout the lack of anti-virus software, the urgent need to “activate” Windows and how great it would be if I took a “virtual tour” of Windows to learn about all its great features. Ugh.
The Windows Annoyance Factor rose quickly. I wanted to change a few of the system settings, so I went to the Control Panels area. Finding the Control Panel you want is easy enough, but navigating all the tabs and secondary menus is a nightmare. If you’re lucky (and persistent) you just might find the setting you’re looking for. It’s much easier to locate items in Mac OS X’s System Preferences.
After noticing a lot of essential services weren’t working (such as the Internet), I decided to actually read the Bootcamp instructions I had printed out. Yep, I needed to insert the Leopard disk that came with the Mac Pro to install the proper drivers.
Windows rebooted again, and voila! Everything worked.
That done, I moved on to Phase 3: installing Parallels to enable the use of Windows in the Mac environment without rebooting.
The Parallels installation went smoothly, but after I installed Parallels Tools – the software magic that enables the seamless integration of the Mac OS and Windows – the Windows Annoyance Factor reared its head again. Windows had detected a significant change in my hardware and now needed to be reactivated. (I later discovered a warning to this effect in the copious Parallels user manual.) I had three days until my copy of Windows stopped functioning.
I clicked on the warning balloon to reactivate, which should have been easy. Instead, Windows altered me that I had exceeded my allotted number of activations and needed to contact Microsoft for instructions. I had activated it for the first time just an hour earlier!
I called the toll-free number on the screen and within a minute or two was having a conversation with a computer. The computer voice told me to read an immense serial number-like code to it. After I did that, it gave me another lengthy code, which I typed into a series of 8 boxes. After that my copy of Windows was activated again.
At work, I never fuss with my Windows PC – the IT folk have it set up the way they want it, and that’s fine.
But having experienced a Windows installation at home, I’m learning first-hand at least one reason why many PC users have switched to the Mac. They’ve grown weary of the Windows Annoyance Factor.

Comments
Question: Why would anyone buy a MAC and install Windows XP on it. That's like buying a high performance BMW and running it on low grade 89 octane rated gasoline. Hence, BMW=Mac and 89 octane gasoline = Windows XP.
Posted by: Joe | January 21, 2008 3:21 PM
Windows XP has always been annoying. Windows Vista itself is less annoying from a clean install such as what you did. The exception is the much maligned user access control which can be dispensed with with a few mouse clicks. Google everything. The problem you haven't experienced is the phenomenon of "crapware." When I bought my very nice new Dell Inspiron 1420 it was preloaded with Dell utilities, Google Search and Desktop, McAfee anti virus, some anti-spyware (I forget the name), and numerous other BS cluttering up the Vista desktop and blathering at me from balloons erupting from the task tray.
Now THAT is a annoying.
Luckily, I am a very experienced Windows guru and I made short work of the crapware and tamed the annoyances. I loaded ObectDock from StarDock.com and quickly transformed my Windows interface into a good facsimile of the Mac OS'.
I had the same issue on my MBP 17 with Parallels, but I reactivated ok. Beware of using the Fat32 file system; Use only the NTFS file system. Fat32 in Boot Camp lets you transfer files easily from the Mac OS to the Windows disk, but it is not worth it because the Fat32 volume experience frequent corruptions running under Parallels.
Posted by: Happy Phantom | January 21, 2008 4:24 PM
Re: Joe - For those of us transitioning from the pc world, it is useful to have a windows partition on a mac. There are still many programs that are only available on Windows and it's nice to be able to run them at native speed. This feature eliminates the need to have two computers - a pc and a mac (which is what I had for a while).
Mr Zeiler - you might want to check into the size of those hard drives, they sound a little small
Posted by: levivel | January 21, 2008 7:26 PM
@ Levivel:
Thanks for the heads up on the hard drives. Fixed.
@Joe:
I'm not switching to Windows, mind you. I just want the option to run Windows when I run into a Web site or happen upon software I'd like to run that is Windows-only.
@Happy Phantom:
I wish I'd known that before I formatted the partition as FAT32. The documentation recommended it because of the ability to transfer files between the Mac and Windows disks. This reinforces my belief that installing Windows on a Mac is not a decision to be taken lightly.
Posted by: Dave Zeiler | January 21, 2008 8:17 PM
Joe,
To address your question...
I am a the web designer for one of the largest Consumer Product Goods (CPG) companies in the region.
At work, I was recently upgraded to a new Mac Pro. As a web designer, I need the ability to check our sites across multiple platforms and browsers. A web page must look identical in Safari as well as in IE 6, despite each system having their own nuances.
Moreover, many older back-end systems are not compatible with the Mac environment. Therefore, now I can design and code on the Mac side, then seamlessly access and upload to our content management system on the PC side. Now I only have to have one computer on my desk, and I no longer have to use my jump drive to move files back and forth between the two.
Parallels has changed my life.
Posted by: Jared | January 22, 2008 12:45 PM